It seemed like just another ordinary Saturday date night when we made our way to Insignia for some steak and wine and laughter, but it would be a night to remember for both of us by the time it ended and the next morning began. When we arrived at the restaurant our table wasn't ready yet, so we found a spot at the bar and each had a glass of wine. I had my hand on your lower back and you had your hand around my waist as we laughed and joked like we always do. Out of the corner of your eye, you noticed a pretty brunette woman in a light purple dress looking in our direction. She smiled at you and you smiled back and then looked at me. I said, "I think she likes you!"
You replied, "I think she does too, and I wouldn't mind finding out just how much she liked me if you were OK with that."
A bulge was forming in my jeans at that thought and I discretely moved your hand there so you knew exactly how I felt about that idea. We had sometimes fantasized about you being with another woman while we were in the heat of the moment and it usually sent you over the edge very quickly, but this was suddenly very real because you thought she was hot and you liked being stared at. I motioned for her to come over and join us and she slowly made her way over to our bar space. I introduced myself and said this is my girlfriend, Sue.
She reached for your hand and said, "It's really nice to meet you, Sue. I'm Elena. You have beautiful eyes, and I'm sorry for staring at you, but your breasts look amazing in that top."
You laughed and said, "Thank you. I like your dress. You have really nice legs."
I was enjoying this scene way too much and got lost in my thoughts when the hostess came over to tell us that our table was ready. I asked Elena if she was meeting someone here for dinner and she said, "I was actually supposed to meet a girlfriend, but she just texted me that her babysitter canceled so it looks like I'm solo."
I made eye contact with you to see if you were OK with me asking her to join us for dinner and I could tell by your grin that you wanted to see how this night was going to play out. I asked the hostess if she could add a place setting to our table, and she said that wasn't a problem at all.
Elena objected and said, "No, don't be silly. You two enjoy your date night; you don't need a third wheel." But you immediately told her that we go out together all the time and it would be fun to continue our conversation and share some wine.
She said, "Are you sure?"
You replied, "I am positive. I just hope Steven doesn't get too jealous if you keep staring at my chest like that!"
We all laughed and I said, "I don't mind at all. I know I'll be seeing them later so it's all good by me."
Elena followed the hostess to our booth and I followed you and cupped your ass along the way. I could tell you were feeling extra frisky tonight and I was starting to wonder if we were going to end up inviting Elena back to our house once our meal was over. Normally you're so shy, but tonight you were very outgoing and flirty. I think it had something to do with the wine, and something to do with your attraction to this pretty brunette. I sat to your left and Elena squeezed in the booth on your right side. Our servers brought over the wine list and our menus and told us about the specials. You were laughing with her about not understanding the broken English when they walked away, and said, "I always get the same thing every time we come here, but I know what I like, so why try something new?"
Elena smiled and said, "Oh I get that, but sometimes trying something new can be really rewarding, and you might find out you like it even better than having the same old thing." She winked at me, and I didn't think she was talking about food!
Elena excused herself to the Ladies' room and you slid closer to me and kissed my ear and whispered, "She's hot, hon. I think I want to fool around with her! Are you OK with that?"
I was rock hard at the thought of this woman between your legs and you between hers, but I was also a little nervous because she was basically a total stranger at this point, and maybe she was a scammer. I told you that if you really wanted to hook up with this girl and she was into it, I didn't have any objections other than making sure she wasn't a crazy person, and I was really turned on. You told me that you were slightly wet at the thought of kissing her!
Elena made her way back to the table and our waiter took our orders and brought over some glasses of wine. You were not exactly sipping it, and I knew that was going to make you even friskier if we ended up leaving here with this woman. I had my hand on your leg and the conversation was very easy and friendly. Elena was also a school teacher on Long Island so you had that in common as well. You were telling her how many kids you had in your class, and she was in shock at how difficult that must be for you because she put her hand on your shoulder and said, "Oh my God, that is crazy! Now I see why you need so much wine!"
We all laughed, but you didn't miss a beat, and added, "Yeah and the wine also helps me relax and gives me the courage I need to try new things if you're interested."
Elena looked at you and said, "I don't think you're talking about food, are you?"
And you said, "Nope. Not at all."
She chugged the rest of her wine and replied, "I'm definitely interested."
I needed to use the Men's room, but if I stood up, the entire restaurant would know how aroused I was by the conversation at our table. I tried to shift my focus to something else and finally excused myself and said, "You two behave. I'll be right back."
