It had been over a week since Lyndsey secretly invaded the intimate moment shared between her neighbors, Devon and Kate. While she suspected Kate might have realized she was there, she hadn't run into either of them to get a read on how they acted towards her.
It was killing her.
Every night as she lay in bed, her mind wandered back to that night. As she imagined Kate's creamy breasts, wet pussy, and Devon's huge cock, she would bring herself to the most powerful orgasms she'd ever had at her own hand. Watching them had unlocked something in her....or it had just made her unbearably horny. The jury was still out on which.
She made her way home from work, stopping to check the mail on her way in. As she stepped off the elevator to her floor, she saw Kate walking away from her door and a bright pink sticky note in the middle. Kate turned towards her and smiled broadly.
"Oh hey! I was just leaving you a note." Lyndsey instantly felt her heart start racing, worried that this was the confrontation she'd been dreading all week. But Kate surprised her. "I just opened a bottle of wine and Devon is tied up at work so I thought I'd invite you over to help me finish it off."
Lyndsey took a deep breath to tame her nerves. Kate seemed sincere, with her green eyes wide and innocent. Maybe she hadn't seen Lyndsey that night and was only being friendly. "Uh, sure. That'd be nice. Just let me drop my bag off and change." She watched Kate's eyes slowly move down her body, lingering on the deep V of her blouse and her office appropriate pencil skirt. The perusal felt charged, especially as Kate's tongue darted out to wet her bottom lip. Lyndsey shifted nervously as she felt her nipples tighten in arousal.
Kate's full lips lifted in a small smile as if she could sense it. "Oh sure, of course. Take your time. Just let yourself in."
Lyndsey's answering smile faded as she watched Kate go back to her own apartment. This will be fine, she thought. It's just a couple of neighbors being friendly and sharing a glass of wine. But there was a smaller voice in her head reminding her that she'd seen the other woman have multiple orgasms just a week prior without her knowledge.
She hurried into her apartment, flinging her things down and tearing off her clothes. Standing in front of her closet she debated what to wear as if she were going to an important event rather than just to visit a neighbor. She finally settled on keeping things low key, pulling on cutoff jean shorts and a V-neck tee before sliding her feet into sandals and walking out of her own apartment.
Standing outside Kate and Devon's apartment door, she braced herself for what could come next. This was either going to be an innocent friendly visit or Kate planned to confront her about her invasion of privacy last week. Assuming she even knew about it. Taking a deep breath she knocked gently before opening the door and stepping inside, ready to face whatever the night may bring.
Lyndsey found Kate in the kitchen, putting together a small charcuterie plate and sipping wine. "I thought you might be hungry too since you just got home. Can't drink on an empty stomach." Kate winked as she slid a glass of red wine across the counter towards her.
Smiling, she took a sip and followed Kate to the couch in the living room where she curled up one side and gestured for Lyndsey to sit opposite her with the plate on the table between them. As they snacked and made small talk, Lyndsey felt herself relaxing and enjoying the other woman's company. Kate kept the wine coming and before long Lyndsey was feeling a little buzzy as the two were chatting like old friends, gossiping about work and life.
After a brief pause in the conversation, Kate casually swirled her wine around in her glass before taking a sip. "So, Lyndsey, did you enjoy watching Devon and I fuck on the balcony last week?"
Lyndsey nearly choked on her wine, narrowly avoiding spewing it all over Kate's beige ottoman. Her eyes were wide as she stared at Kate, fearful of where the conversation was going to go and unsure what to say in response. The other woman had been lulling her into thinking this was an innocent chat, but it was not.
Laughing, Kate handed her a napkin as she said "Don't worry, I'm not upset about it. Quite the opposite really. I enjoyed the fuck out of it once I realized you were there. I wish I could have seen more of you, but knowing you were there watching us made it even hotter."
Lyndsey was at a loss for words, just staring at Kate with her mouth agape. What the hell was she supposed to say?
Kate sat her wine on the end table and moved what was left of the charcuterie plate beside it. She scooted closer to Lyndsey gently taking her wine glass as well. She turned back to her and leaned a little closer, her voice dropping slightly. "Did you know that I saw you watching us?"
Lyndsey shook her head as she found her voice. "No. Well, I thought you might have, but I wasn't sure." She covered her face with her hands. "Oh my gosh I am so sorry. I shouldn't have watched but fuck you guys were so hot together and... it's just been so long for me."
Prying her hands from her face, Kate laughed. "Breathe, girl. Like I said, I'm not upset. It was hot." She shrugged. "But I am curious--did you touch yourself while you watched us? It was too dark for me to be sure but it turned me on to think you might be."
Lyndsey pulled her bottom lip between her teeth, debating whether or not she should answer this truthfully and dig the hole any deeper. But Kate said she wasn't angry so, fuck it. "Yes, I did. And I have every night since thinking about it. It was one of the hottest things I've ever seen in my life," she confessed.
"You should have joined us." Kate said with a devilish grin, making Lyndsey choke on air. She reached over to pat Lyndsey on the back, trailing her hand up and over her shoulder like it had been the excuse she needed to touch her. "You were already sort of a part of things, and we've definitely thought about it all week as well." Her fingers began to lightly trace the V of Lyndsey's shirt. "I've made myself come so many times imagining what it would have been like if you'd joined in...."