Loyalty Test Surprise Ch 04

Loyalty Test Surprise

by Lacey O'Shea

Chapter 4

They go to Tessa's closet - she's pretty sure it's buried in there somewhere. Natalie is peeking in the dozen or so shoe boxes stacked in one corner, commenting on the high heels she finds inside each box, and putting aside the ones she wants to borrow. Tessa goes through the baskets of clothes in the other corner, knowing she didn't put that silly rubber penis in any of those baskets, but she couldn't be one hundred percent sure she hadn't moved it at some point.

It's almost impossible to concentrate with Natalie right next to her totally naked, while she has no clothes on herself. She wants to grab her, wrestle her down, and have her way with her. She plans her line of attack, then she spots her old, green TravelPro carry-on bag that she hasn't used in years. That sparks a memory. She unzips the front pouch with shaking hands, reaches in, and comes out with a flesh-colored rubber dick. She alerts Natalie with a whoop of success.

"Awesome! It's perfect. It's got balls and everything! Your sister is such a whore!"

"You don't know the half of it. She fucked so many guys before she got engaged it was ridiculous."

"Is that why you're such a prudish goody-two-shoes?"

"Am not," Tessa protests, worrying that she might be right. "Look at this thing," she says, holding the dildo up. "It's fucking huge!"

"You think that's huge? Obviously, you've never been with a black guy."

"You know I haven't. And neither have you!"

"Well...there was that party at the frat house you didn't want to go to..."

"You said nothing happened!"

"Well, it's not like I was going to just come right out and admit that I was gang-banged by half the football team. You wouldn't want to be my friend if you knew I was like that."

"So much for never keeping secrets from each other!"

"Okay, but you never told me you let Josh fuck you in the ass."

"How do you know about that?"

"I didn't, but I do now!"

"You tricked me! You're such a stinker!"

Natalie snatches the rubber penis from her. "So does that mean you don't want me to fuck you now?"

"No. It just means I'm going to fuck you extra hard, you dirty slut."

"Don't threaten me with a good time, bitch."

They laugh and fall together in a passionate kiss, their naked bodies pressing tight together.

"Let's move this to the bed," Tessa suggests once things heat up to a fever pitch.

~ ~ ~

"Lie down and spread your legs," Natalie instructs. Tessa likes the sound of that so she does it without question. Josh is the only one she ever fucked in this bed, now it looks like she's going to be able to put another metaphorical notch on her bedpost after tonight.

Natalie just looks down at her for a long moment, her eyes roving over her naked tits, her bare thighs, her smooth belly, and her hairy puss. She can see the lust in her eyes. She likes being the object of desire in this new way. That ache is getting stronger by the second. Tessa can't wait for something to happen.

"Do you want to fuck me?" she asks demurely.

Natalie's eyes flash with a devilish craving. "No...I want to make love to you." That sounds strange to Tessa. If Natalie were a guy it would make sense, but she wasn't sure if it works in this context...two girls...

Natalie kisses the tip of the big dong and puts it aside. She lies down on top of Tessa, her baldness pressing against her furry mound. Reflexively, Tessa wraps her legs around her waist, not sure exactly what is happening. All she could think about was the dreamy sensation of Natalie's big boobs pressing against her modest chest. She could stay like this for hours.

"What now?" Tessa asks, her heart thumping hard in her chest.

"I don't know," Natalie answers and kisses her friend on the lips softly. "I saw this in a porn once and always wanted to try it." With that, she presses her mound against Tessa's.

"Oh...okay...that's something..." Tessa croaks as Natalie lets off the pressure a little.

"Really?"

"Yeah, totally. Do that some more."

Natalie presses into her again, then eases off. She repeats that a few more times. It reminds her of when she was a kid and would hump her stuffed animals. Who knew that was really just training for lesbian sex all along?

"Is that okay for you?" Natalie asks, unsure.

"More than okay. How is it for you?"

"Pretty damn awesome," she says with a giggle. "Maybe we don't need a dick after all."

"Shut up and fuck me...sorry, I mean make love to me."

Natalie gently humps her pussy against Tessa's, grinding her clit against her friend's pubic bone. It's better than any stuffed animal she'd ever used. She lifts up and dangles a nipple in front of Tessa's face. She doesn't hesitate to take the hint and captures it between her soft lips. "Shit, yes, suck my tits," she whispers hoarsely, then switches so she can suck her other nipple. "Nice."

"Can you get a little lower?" Tessa asks, trying to angle her hips up better. "Rub your clit against mine...yes, just like that."

Okay, that's an improvement, Natalie thinks as Tessa lets out a happy moan beneath her. This is really going to work. "I'm going to fuck you with my cunt," she insists. Tessa nods and keeps suckling.

"Do it...fuck me...fuck my cunt..." It feels weird saying that word out loud, but also extremely liberating. It isn't her fault, Natalie started it! And she's glad that she did - it makes everything they're doing feel so dirtier!

They hump themselves together for a time. Apparently making love is out the window and they're fucking now instead. Only the sounds of them breathing hard and the subtle noises of cunt against cunt can be heard, along with the occasional rapturous groan.

"I think I'm going to cum," Natalie says as if this surprises her.

"So am I. It doesn't seem possible. Who knew this would even work? I love it."

"Porn wouldn't lie to us, would it? No wonder guys like fucking us so much, Natalie rationalizes, this feels amazing. No one has ever wrapped their legs around her like this before. It's wonderful."

Tessa strains up from below and kisses her on the mouth. "You're wonderful...now really give it to me...harder...that's right...that's what I want...give me what I need, slut!"

Natalie is losing control. She's smashing her pussy into Tessa's crotch. It feels really good, but not in a direct kind of way. Her clit is being stimulated, but not like when she fingers herself. It's a bit maddening, but she knows she's going to get there. And hearing her friend's building moans is getting her there all the faster.

"Fuck, I'm going to cum," Natalie gasps and grinds more intensely. "Cum with me. I want us to cum together!"

"I'm right there, keep fucking me! Fuck me hard! Oh, yes! Yes, yes, yes!" Tessa cries, pulling her friend in tight with her legs. She holds her breath, and then, with a big gulp of air, she screams out. Electricity pulses through her whole body. She's actually cumming just from another girl fucking her with her pussy. It's beyond incredible.

Natalie adds her own screams to hers. She's cumming too. God, she looks so beautiful when she orgasms. Tessa can't stop humping, and neither can Nat. They're like when you turn the key off in an old car and the motor keeps chugging. They're chugging away at each other, each knowing there are more orgasms to come. Tessa gets there first.

"Oh, my cunt...make my cunt cum again...do it...make me cum, you slut!" Natalie begins circling her hips as she grinds into her. That feels even better than when she was just banging into her. They should start with that next time. And Tessa is sure there's going to be a next time.

"You like that? You like getting fucked. you little whore? You nasty pussy licker." Natalie rears up, jamming her cunt hard against Tessa's, and lets out a plaintive wail that echoes through the empty apartment. Tessa pulls her down into a hug and they stay like that for a long time.

After a while of just holding each other and trying to come to terms with what they've done, Tessa stirs. "I want you on your hands and knees."

"What?" Natalie mumbles, not sure she heard her right.

Tessa reaches for the big dildo. "You heard me bitch, I want you on all fours."

"Doggy style? You remembered my favorite position?"

"How could I not? You tell me about it every time we talk about sex. Now it's time for you to prove it. Show me that ass, slut."

Natalie shifts and does as she is told, moving to the center of the big bed, getting on her hands and knees, and wiggling her ass to indicate she's ready. "Like this?" she asks, trying to sound as innocent and virginal as she can.

"Just like that," Tessa growls, once again admiring her friend's perfect body. They should have gotten naked together like this long before now. "Is that pussy wet for me?"

"Yes, mistress. My cunt is ready for you. Please be gentle...don't hurt me."

She isn't expecting that, but it gives her an odd tingle at the base of her spine. Is this going to turn into some kind of BDSM thing? This isn't the time to question it. She moves behind Natalie, admiring the curve of her luscious ass, her puffy lips peeking out from between her thighs, and the needful arch of her back. She wants this...bad.

Tessa caresses her firm butt cheek. There's more persuasive wiggling. She gives her friend's rump a sharp smack. Natalie lets out a squeal, but it's a grateful one. She always liked it when a guy slapped her ass. It looked like Nat appreciated it as well. She pushes one of her cheeks aside and is treated to a peek at her tight, little asshole.

"Spread your knees wider," she commands and her friend instantly obeys. She can get used to this. Tessa uses both hands to separate Natalie's butt cheeks. She never really thought about anyone's butthole before, not even her own, but it really is a beautiful thing. Is she into anal now?

After what Natalie did to her ass, she can't deny that she's more curious than ever. And she also can't deny that she's irresistibly tempted by her friend's cute, little bunghole Tessa leans in and gives it a quick lick. Natalie yelps, then wiggles, indicating that she wants more.

She is pretty much obligated. I'll suck you off if you suck me off. That was the deal, right?

Tessa leans in and plants her lips on her exposed anus. More squeals of delight. Tessa commits to it and begins tonguing her back door with gusto. The idea of it is gross - licking someone's asshole - but the reality is unexpectedly pleasant. Tessa presses her face into Natalie's butt crack and probes with her tongue, wanting her friend to feel what she felt.

She finds her rear opening with the tip of her tongue and presses it in. Natalie giggles and relaxes her asshole - having learned from her experience back there. Tessa forces her tongue in deeper. She can't get it in too far, but she knows it's enough to put someone over the edge. But, she doesn't want her to cum...not just yet. She pulls her face away and admires her rosy butthole, now wet with her saliva.

She comes out of her daze and shifts her attention down to Natalie's pussy...down to her bald cunt. Tessa goes in and gives it a sniff, and is unable to resist licking that gorgeous clit. It almost looks like it's pulsing. It must just be her imagination.

"I've never seen a pussy up close like this before," she says, mesmerized.

"Oh? How does it look?"

"It looks...great. It's the most beautiful thing I've ever seen. Your lips are perfect. Your clit is amazing. And your hole is...your hole is so fucking wet."

"It looks even better when it has a cock in it," Natalie says, and Tessa gets the hint.

She sucks the tip of the big dildo and aims it directly at Natalie's fuck hole. There's no way it's going to fit. But she did say she's had black guys who were bigger in there. She pushes the rubber cock forward. Natalie's asshole flexes a few times and relaxes. The head of the dildo penetrates her slowly. It's happening.

"Take it, bitch. Take my cock," Tessa snarls trying to sound like a guy. She slides the rubber phallus in more, and Natalie takes it. There's some resistance, but it fits. She'd be screaming in pain if this thing was going inside of her pussy, but her friend seems to be loving it. She is going to have to start practicing with this toy, she has some catching up to do.

"Oh, yeah...that's what I want," Natalie whimpers and moves in time with the thrusting dildo. "Get it in there...nice and deep...yes...I love it!"

"You like getting fucked? You like the way I fuck you?"

"So good...damn, I wish you had a real cock right now."

"I'd fuck you so good," Tessa declares. "I'd grab you and pound that tight, little pussy until you cried for mercy."

"That's what I want. I want you to own me. To own my pussy."

"This pussy is all mine, bitch. This is my cunt, do you understand?" Tessa is letting her power corrupt her...she never felt this way before. It's a lot of fun!

"Yes," Natalie pants. "Yes, mistress, all yours. Fuck me hard."

The view was unrivaled. She's tempted to go in and lick her cute asshole some more, but she holds back. She doesn't want Natalie to think she's obsessed with her butthole or anything like that. Although, maybe she is.

"Oh, yeah...I'm going to cum. I'm going to cum all over your cock. Give it to me. I want it," Natalie moans and bucks against the penetration. Tessa works her pussy hard and fast, loving the sounds it's making. Also, the sounds Natalie is making. She's made plenty of guys cum before, and that was all well and good, but knowing that she's about to make another girl cum is a special kind of privilege. It feels like a real accomplishment. Guys are too easy.

Natalie's arms go stiff. She presses her whole body back into the dildo, and shrieks with guttural satisfaction. She's cumming, for sure. Tessa slows things down, easing the dildo in deep with a slight twist. Natalie rotates her hips to match her deliberate thrust, her body convulsing as she does, "Oh...oh...shit...yes...that's it...oh, God...that's the fucking stuff..."

Natalie collapses, her arms going limp and her shoulders hit the mattress. Her butt is still up in the air, and Tessa slowly works the dildo in and out a few more times before withdrawing it entirely. Natalie whines when she does, wiggling her ass again as if to say she wants it back in there. Tessa decides to leave her wanting, and instead just smacks her ass to let her know she's done.

Natalie flops down and rolls over, opening her legs wide. Tessa can't help but admire her beautiful nakedness, and those perfect pink lips, all swollen with excitement. Again, she's tempted to go back in mouth first, but instead, she slips her hand down between her own legs. She loves masturbating to porn, and what better porn is there than the real thing?

Tessa leans back against the headboard, legs wide, knees up, and fingers herself while never taking her eyes away from Natalie's well-used cunt. "So..." she starts, her voice thick with lust, "Tell me all about your big gang-bang."

~ ~ ~

Natalie looks and sees what Tessa is doing. She loves how much closer they have become in less than an hour. Her hand goes to her own clit and she begins rubbing it lightly. "It was at the Phi Delta house. I was only there for about ten minutes when a guy came up to me...one of the defensive ends I think. He was tall, very black, and handsome as fuck. He handed me a drink and we talked. He asked me if I wanted to go downstairs. I asked what was down there, and he just said 'the playroom.' I knew what that meant, or I thought I did, and so I followed him down."

"You didn't even know this guy and right away you were going to fuck him?" Tessa asks, using her other hand to slide a finger into her pussy while unashamedly strumming her clit.

"Judgey. See, that's why I never told you this story before."

"Okay, sorry. I'll shut up...then what happened?"

"We got down to the playroom, and there were six guys down there...football players. Most of them were black, but there were a few white boys. They were already naked, and they all had hard-ons! I don't know what they were doing before I got there, but one of the white guys was kind of little so I think maybe he was sucking their dicks to get them ready. I loved that."

"What about the guy who brought you down there?"

"I turned around and he was taking his clothes off. It was a little scary, but all those hard cocks looked too good to pass up. I went down to my knees and they all gathered around. I started sucking dicks like crazy. Sometimes two at a time with one in each hand!"

"Why didn't I go to that party with you?" Tessa laments, trying to picture the scene and feeling major FOMO.

"While that was happening, they pulled my clothes off and I was getting groped everywhere. I was so fucking wet."

"I don't blame you. Look how wet I am just from hearing this story." Tessa spreads her lips wide to prove her claim. Natalie takes a good long look and nods with a smile.

"So, I got into doggy position, obviously, and the guys lined up behind me. Believe it or not, I wasn't even drunk yet! The guys took turns on me, pulling out and cumming all over my ass. Others were jerking off in my face. I got flipped over at one point, and that's when I noticed some guys were getting back in line to take a second turn with my pussy. That was flattering."

Two fingers disappear into Natalie's hole and she fucks herself for a few seconds. Mostly for the sake of getting those fingers nice and wet for her clit. She quickly goes back to jerking off. "Then, somewhere along the way, another girl came down. A tall Asian chick - she looked like a cheerleader or something. I lost some of my customers to her, but I always had at least four cocks in or around me shooting cum all over my body. It was some of the best sex I've ever had!" She blushes and looks across at her friend. "Until tonight."

"I doubt that. No way I can compete with a room full of big, hard cocks."

"Don't sell yourself short, girl. The gang-bang was fun, and I'm glad I did it, but I wouldn't do it again. This is way better, and I want to do it again and again."

"I'm glad you said that because so do I."

The two of them watch each other in silence for a minute, each fingering her own pussy, paying close attention to how the other one does it. They're not even touching and it's the most intimate experience either of them can imagine.

"You know what this party is missing...?" Natalie says wistfully.

"About a dozen hard cocks?"

Natalie has to laugh. "Kind of, but after sex, I usually have the taste of cum in my mouth...guy cum. That somehow makes it feel more real - like I really had sex. I mean, I love the taste of your cunt, but it's not the same."

Tessa smacks her lips. "You're right. I liked eating your ass, but without there being any sperm, it feels...incomplete."

"We're lousy lesbians." Natalie scootches a little closer, putting her legs over Tessa's. They are facing each other, pussies just a foot apart, fingers working furiously in concert as they chat.

"I'm going to order us a strap-on," Tessa says with confident certitude.

"That's a good idea! So, that means you seriously want to do this again with me?"

"Are you kidding? Of course!" Tessa pinches her own nipple, pulling on it at the thought of becoming lovers with her best friend.

"Should you order two? One for you and one for me. Or would you rather share?" Natalie stops working her clit and gives it a couple of thoughtful taps. "And could we invite a guy to join us the next time we get together? Just so we can get some of that sperm we both need so much?"

"Sure. You have someone in mind?" She asks as Natalie begins humping her own hand. She's getting close, Tessa can tell. Then again, so is she.

"I do," she confirms with a wink.