This was a stand alone story I originally published as "The Tutor" - but is also a crucial chapter in Sarah's story. So for those of you reading the "Impact" series I posted this reworked and expanded version as 10½ (where I feel it best belongs within the chronology).*
Special thanks to HaltWhoGoesThere for proof reading this chapter for me - repeatedly.
Impact of Rebekah
I had seen Sarah around, had heard guys talking about her. She was very pretty and had made a bit of a splash on campus with some of the upperclassmen guys at the beginning of the year - my ex among them. But I really hadn't given her much thought beyond her looks until I started tutoring her. The truth is I'd assumed Sarah was dumb. I know that sounds harsh, but in my defense I was hardly alone. She looked like an airhead.
Don't get me wrong. I don't spend a lot of time obsessing on the looks or native wits of freshman girls, but I was living with three guys in a rambling Victorian off campus and regularly sleeping with a fourth. With all that guy energy in the house it was hard not to hear the scuttlebutt - and like I said my ex in particular had been way too interested in her. In his defense she was everything I wasn't. She and I are about the same size, but she had a wonderfully thick head of pale wavy red hair with big bright blue eyes and big boobs. My hair is black, my eyes are dark brown under thick dark brows, and my boobs are tiny little cones. Sarah wasn't the reason I broke up with Kevin, but his fascination with her definitely contributed to my decision - 'if that's what he wants, he's not for me,' my thinking went.
Still, she really was striking, so even without Kevin and the boys, I'd have noticed her. But I still would have thought she was dumb.
It was her expression that made her look stupid. I remember some snark saying she had "resting ditz face" - harsh I know, but not entirely off the mark either. Those big empty pale eyes and slack pout... which Kevin had described as "perpetual blowjob mouth" to one of my housemates when he thought I couldn't hear. Picture a strawberry blonde Sydney Sweeney.
Part of what had made her a standout when she first arrived was the poor thing had seemed to spill out of whatever she wore. It was almost comic. But as the weather cooled she had disappeared into her clothes and some of the buzz around her had disappeared with the change in costume. It was a big enough change that when she'd first come to work with me in February I'd assumed she had gained the "freshman fifteen", but I quickly realized she was hiding; disguising herself with oversized sweatshirts and sweaters and such. It made me reassess her, like her more.
And after tutoring Sarah for a month or two my opinion of her had done a one-eighty. First, she turned out to be super smart - not just book smart, but wickedly fast and surprisingly thoughtful. She wasn't at all assertive however. I found I had to draw her out. It took me a couple weeks of gentle encouragement, joking and some well deserved flattery, slowly but surely, however, I was able to do it. At first I thought Sarah was just shy, but that wasn't it. She had the power to transform herself - almost like Clark Kent into Superman. She could go from quiet Sarah with bad posture and a vacuous look to the Homecoming queen with the piercing eyes and sharp insights in a flash. It was almost like a magic trick. And like Clark Kent, the airhead-Sarah seemed to be a brand of protective camouflage. I dedicated myself to being her Lois Lane... or Jimmy Olsen... or whatever; someone she could show her Superman self to.
"You are a worldshaker in waiting," I told her, making her blush crimson. "I mean it Sarah, you are so beautiful and so smart, you need to let people see that!
And it's funny to admit, but even as I worked to build up her own sense of self-esteem I found myself more than a little intimidated by her Homecoming Queen Superman.
On the day it all started we were having our first really warm day, the sun was out and everyone on campus celebrated by dressing as if it was 110 out.
I was thinking about Sarah's Superman trick as I watched her arrive from the deck outside my bedroom window. Spring has sprung and like everyone else she had shed her winter gear. She was walking up to the house in shorts, a t-shirt and sandals. Her hair was pulled back into a thick ponytail. I remember looking down on her and being struck by her figure. Not only was she not fat, she was a twig of a girl - except for her boobs, which stood off her chest like they were perpetually at attention. She had her backpack on over both shoulders, that made them all the more outrageous looking. And yes, I felt guilty for objectifying her that way, she didn't know she was being watched, but I couldn't help myself. Her thumbs were hooked in her shoulder straps and her head was down. She was talking to herself - not out loud, but her lips were moving.
Did I mention she was also a huge nerd? It's like she was lost in the woods as a baby and raised by awkward misfits and clumsy weirdos. I wondered what her home life was like.
My bedroom windows opened onto the roof of the front porch, my friends and I sometimes sunbathed on the little deck - at least twice, I may also be a nerd. Still the deck was a huge perk, but it also blocked my view of our front yard. The only way I could see who was coming and going in front of the house was if I was outside. I climbed back in through the window and closed it, took a last look around my room, wanting to be sure everything was ready.
I was nervous.
I'd lived in Hill House since my sophomore year, and this was my second and final year in the old master bedroom at the front of the house. It had three big windows onto the deck, a deep closet and its own bathroom. I had a queen size bed, a beautiful mid-century modern teak desk and dresser, but even so the room felt wonderfully empty. It was that big; the whole front end of the house. I'd inherited the lease and most of the furniture in the house when all three of my roommates graduated at once. In it, I'd weathered a change in majors (many tears), half a dozen break ups (not as many tears, but some), a terrible case of mono, and an abortion (so many tears).
Kevin, the most recent of my exes and one of the ones to get absolutely no tears, had been Sarah's TA for her creative writing class. When he'd sent her my way I'd been angry, had felt like it was some sort of passive aggressive jab, but I'd also needed the money and hadn't turned her away. I was glad I hadn't; like I said, Sarah wasn't who I assumed she was.
I really liked her, but something strange had happened that I'd been struggling with.
The last time she'd come to work with me we'd set up at my desk as usual and had been going through her work when I'd gotten a call from my dean that I needed to drop off paperwork asap. I'd felt bad and excused myself, and rushed out. When I'd left Sarah was in full blown Homecoming Queen Superman mode, but when I had gotten back, I'd found Clark Kent Sarah, nervous and flush, and my room had smelled like... sex.
We had finished studying but I'd been distracted and so had she. After she'd left I'd wondered if I'd imagined it all. But I had made my bed that morning and remembered smoothing out the covers and fluffing the pillows. But when I'd gotten back from my dean's, my bed looked like it had been laid in, the pillows were dented... and again the room had smelled like sex, like
pussy.
I wasn't sure, wondered if I was imagining things, but it bothered me. And as much as I'd tried, I couldn't let it go.
The next week I'd emailed Sarah and asked if we could meet a couple hours later. She'd agreed saying the new time was actually better for her. For me it meant all my housemates would be gone. When she showed up I'd let her in and brought her upstairs. I remember I complimented her on her outfit, saying how good she looked. It was so nice to see her with her hair pulled back so I could see her eyes, in something that wasn't baggy.
Sarah had been embarrassed by my compliments, but thanked me. We'd gotten settled at my desk and started working when I'd told her I'd gotten a text from my housemate Don and he needed me to bring something he'd forgotten to campus.
"But don't worry," I told her, "there's no one else here, you've got the house to yourself and won't be disturbed."
I'd made a show of rushing out and making a noisy exit. And then, kicking off my shoes, I quietly snuck back up the stairs, careful to avoid the squeaky steps.