gias-choice
LESBIAN SEX STORIES

Gias Choice

Gias Choice

by ann douglas
19 min read
4.72 (13000 views)
adultfiction

Author's Note - Although ratings are nice, nothing beats a comment or two about what you liked or disliked about a story. Please take a moment to leave one. Thank you.

October 1984

"Dean, have you ever been with a man?" Gia Antonelli asked as she lifted her body off the chest of the similarly naked man beneath her, the movement causing the thin sheet around her to drop away, exposing well rounded breasts and light brown nipples.

"What...?" the burly forty-nine year old stammered as he too lifted himself upward, the question having shocked him out of the post-coitus bliss he had been drifting in.

"Have you ever been with a man -- sexually?" the raven haired twenty-four year old repeated, adding the emphasis at the end as if she felt the need to clarify her question.

"What would make you ask that?" Dean Baxter asked, his mind now suddenly clear.

"Oh, I'm just curious, that's all," Gia, whose full name was actually Giavanna, said as she ran a hand through her short bob cut, brushing aside an errant strand before adding, "So, have you?"

"No, I've never been with a man," he said.

"Not even a little blow job?" Gia then asked, the addendum having been meant as a joke.

This time, however, Dean didn't answer as quickly. A delay that caused the Italian woman to wonder if perhaps he had, a thought reflected in her change of expression.

"Are blow jobs really even considered sex anymore?" the athletic instructor chuckled, a response that came across as more evasion than answer.

"They most certainly are," Gia stated firmly, not having ever considered them as anything else.

"Well, I guess, in that case, the answer would have to be yes, but it was just one time," Dean admitted reluctantly. "I mean, it was no big deal."

"If it was no big deal, then you can tell me about it," Gia pointed out.

Again Dean paused, finally saying that he would if she would explain this sudden curiosity.

Gia agreed.

The relationship Dean and Gia shared wasn't based on romance but merely one of friends with benefits. They served as each other's plus one at social events and occasionally shared a bed. A situation that would've outraged the younger woman's traditionally minded family back in Bensonhurst. The chances of them finding out that she was regularly fucking a man nearly her father's age were slim, however, given that they rarely spoke to her since she'd broken her engagement to Paul Giordano, a neighborhood boy she'd known since high school. That three years had passed since then, during which Paul had married someone else, didn't seem to matter.

The two teachers had met at a faculty function at the beginning of the last school year, right after the younger woman had been hired as an Instructor at the Burroughs Academy, a private high school on Manhattan's Upper East Side. At five four and a slim hundred and fifteen pounds, Gia looked more like one of the students in her Mathematics course than its teacher. Which had led to her having been asked out by more than one upperclassman, one of whom had even repeated the offer after learning her actual status.

Dean, a former professional athlete who'd played minor league baseball, had been divorced nearly six years ago, ending a marriage that had lasted four times that. He had two grown children, including a daughter older than the naked woman across from him. They seemed an odd match, but the arrangement worked.

"It was a couple of months after my divorce," Dean began, "back when I used to live down in Tribeca."

Gia nodded her head; the area was close enough to her own part of Manhattan for her to be familiar with it.

"One of my neighbors used to invite me over to watch the Mets' games on his twenty-five inch console, which, seeing as I only had a thirteen inch portable in my own apartment, I usually said yes to."

Gia again nodded her head.

"Well, one night we were having a few beers and watching the Mets go down in flames in a 14-3 massacre," Dean said, "when, out of the blue, Carl asked me what I'd been doing for companionship since the divorce, pointing out that he hadn't seen me bring anyone home since I'd moved in."

"Wasn't that a rather personal question?" Gia said. "I mean, you were just neighbors, right?"

"Yeah, but like I said, we'd had a few beers," Dean replied. "I wasn't drunk or anything like that, but probably had just enough to discuss my sex life, or rather my lack of one. I pointed out that I'd been pretty much preoccupied with putting my life back together, and getting laid hadn't been high on my list of priorities."

Dean paused and took a long, deep breath.

"Carl said he understood, and I thought that was the end of it," Dean continued. "But as I turned my attention back to the game, he said that if I ever needed a little relief, he'd be more than happy to help out -- with no reciprocation required."

"You didn't know he was gay?" Gia asked.

"Well, that wasn't the sort of topic that usually came up when we were watching a game," Dean said.

"But now that it had," Gia said, "what did you say?"

"At first, nothing," Dean replied. "I was too stunned."

"Well, eventually you must've said something, since you accepted his offer," the younger woman stated.

"Yeah, I did say yes, but not without giving it some serious thought," Dean said. "I finally decided, what the hell, a blow job's a blow job, right? And, to be honest, I guess I was a bit curious about how it might feel, seeing as he knew what it felt like to be on the receiving end and all."

"And how did it feel?" Gia asked.

"Fuckin' phenomenal," Dean said as his face suddenly lit up with the memory of how it had felt. "I'd never had a blow job that good before."

The words had barely left his mouth when Dean, looking at the expression on Gia's face, realized that might've not been the best thing to say to someone who currently sucked his cock on a regular basis.

📖 Related Lesbian Sex Stories Magazines

Explore premium magazines in this category

View All →

"That's not to say that you aren't really good at it too," Dean offered as he misinterpreted her expression. "It was just different, that's all."

"What did Carl look like?" Gia asked out of curiosity, not seeming to have been offended by Dean's comment about his skill.

"Have you ever seen 'The Odd Couple' on TV," Dean asked, "the original one, not that remake they had on last year?"

Gia said yes, having seen the show he was referring to in syndication.

"Well, Carl reminded me of the actor who played the fussy roommate," Dean stated, "same physical build."

Gia knew who Dean was talking about, picturing the performer in her mind. Not exactly her type of guy, but not bad looking either. Putting the image aside, another thought occurred to her.

"If it was so good," she asked, "then why was it only once? You did say that he implied it could be a steady thing."

"I did consider it," Dean explained, "especially since Carl said reciprocation wasn't part of the deal. But the more I thought about it, the more that didn't seem fair. You know me, I always like to return the favor."

Again Gia nodded her head, recalling how often she'd had Dean's head buried between her own legs.

"So, if it did become a regular thing, I knew I'd have to... well..." he continued.

This time Gia just smiled a little, picturing that image in her head.

"... and if I wound up doing that, who knows where it might lead?" Dean added. "I mean, once you become intimate with someone, things can get out of hand pretty quickly."

That Gia well knew, seeing as how, in the space of a single evening, she'd gone from making out with Dean on his couch to sucking his cock and then spreading her legs for him. She'd later blamed it on the fact that she'd been celibate for nearly a year before that.

"You know that I'm pretty open minded, sexually speaking," Dean added, "but there are some things I just can't imagine myself ever doing."

"Like what?" Gia asked, her curiosity sparked.

"You know..." Dean replied, hesitating in mid-sentence.

"Oh," Gia responded, thinking of how, after he'd finally put an engagement ring on her finger, she'd let Paul fuck her ass, only for him to prove so inept at it that she refused any second attempt, no matter how often he asked.

"... kissing," Dean finally finished. "I could never kiss a guy."

Gia had an urge to laugh, but managed not to.

"Okay, now that I've bared my soul, can you explain this sudden interest in my sexual history?" Dean asked.

Now it was Gia's turn to hesitate, but also only long enough to collect her thoughts.

"I haven't mentioned it before, but I've been seeing someone," she said. "It hasn't become serious yet, well, at least not serious enough that it might've precluded the two of us tonight. But I think that's about to change."

"Gia, that's great," Dean said, his excitement for his friend momentarily eclipsing everything else. "Who's the lucky guy?"

"Actually," Gia said, pausing for a very long breath between words, "it's more like the lucky girl."

"No fuckin' way!" Dean exclaimed loudly, Gia never having struck him as the sort of girl who might go for something like that. "You're shitting me, right?"

The look on Gia's face said she was dead serious, and once Dean realized that, he apologized for his reaction. Then he asked who the woman was, quickly adding, was she anyone he knew?

"I'd rather not say," Gia answered, "at least not without her okay first."

That told Dean that it was a woman he knew, or at least someone whose name he would recognize. Which also meant someone at school, since that was the only place their lives overlapped. He felt his curiosity roar into overdrive as, even if she didn't want to share the woman's name, it didn't mean he couldn't silently speculate.

To Dean's knowledge, there were no openly gay women at school, although there had been rumors about a few. He'd learned long ago, however, that most gossip usually wasn't worth the breath it was shared with. A case in point being Gwendolyn Morrison, a forty-something English teacher about whom half the staff would've bet good money that she was playing for the home team. A wager they'd have lost when it came out that she'd been sleeping with the much married head of the department, for nearly five years. It was the married aspect that made it a scandal, with both parties resigning soon after. Burroughs was a pretty liberal institution, but that had been over the line.

If he counted support staff, more than a hundred women worked at Burroughs, Dean thought, making him realize it was impossible to guess the identity of Miss X without more to go on. Given the example he'd just cited to himself, he hoped that it didn't turn out to be Mrs. X, although he didn't think Gia would get involved with someone married. Then again, five minutes ago he couldn't imagine her with another woman either.

A more frightening possibility suddenly entered his mind, one that actually caused him to shudder. Remembering how Gia had often been mistaken for a student herself, could this mystery woman be one? Fearful of the answer, he nevertheless asked the burning question.

"Gia, we're not talking about a student here, are we?" Dean asked, thinking that she taught three senior classes, in which many of the students had already crossed into legal adulthood.

"No, not a student," Gia quickly said, as if she had been expecting the question.

Which in a way she probably was, given the number of times she'd pointed out to Dean that he was sometimes too familiar with his own female students. She never went so far as to accuse him of improper conduct, but, given his often flirtatious manner, the possibility had to be considered.

It didn't escape Dean's notice that Gia had said 'not a student', and not 'no one at school,' pretty much confirming that it was.

"Nor is she married," Gia added, recalling Dean having once told her the story about Miss Morrison and the department head.

Both statements filled Dean with a sense of relief.

🛍️ Featured Products

Premium apparel and accessories

Shop All →

"I have to say, I had no idea that you were also interested in women," he then offered.

"To tell you the truth, it came as a surprise to me as well," Gia admitted. "I mean, I've had close girlfriends before, but this is different. There's a sense of desire that I've never felt before."

"So, it's this particular woman, and not just women in general," Dean stated.

"I guess that's the best way to say it," the younger woman agreed. "Although I also have to say, it has affected the way I look at other women as well. I notice things about them that I really wouldn't have paid attention to before."

"Sort of like when you first discovered boys?" Dean suggested.

"I hadn't thought of it like that, but yes," Gia responded.

"Gia, if this is what you want, then I'm glad for you," Dean then said, "but what you've just told me has me confused. If you're interested in this woman, then what are you doing here with me?"

That, Gia had to admit, was a very good question, one that she had been asking herself for the last half hour. Taking a long, deep breath, she tried to explain her reasoning.

"When I asked to come over, I really didn't envision us winding up in bed," she began. "I just wanted to talk and get your take on what I was feeling. Then, once I was here, I began to wonder if the intensity of those feelings might be due to the fact that I hadn't been laid in over two months."

Two months, Dean knew, during which he'd been involved with a woman from his gym. A relationship that had started fierily enough, but then eventually burnt itself out. That was one of their ground rules; they didn't go to bed with each other if one of them was involved with someone else.

"So, I decided to see if I still felt the same way once my ... my needs had been satisfied," Gia added.

"And you don't think your 'friend' would have a problem with that?" Dean asked.

"Well, right now, friend is all she is," Gia said, "and until that changes, both of us are free to be with anyone we want."

Dean wasn't totally sure he agreed with that, but it was their concern, not his.

"So, what's the verdict then?" Dean asked. "Are you still hot for this woman?"

"More than ever," Gia said, before thinking the reply might be considered as much a faux pas as Dean's comment about blow jobs.

"It's okay, I get it," Dean smiled. "What I don't get is, what's the problem?"

"I'm not sure," she admitted after a long pause. "There's still something holding me back, a feeling that this is a line that I shouldn't cross."

"You still hear the nuns from that parochial school you went to talking in your head, don't you?" Dean offered.

"And a few other people," Gia said, thinking of her family and friends.

"Well, I've been out of that world for much longer than you," Dean said, "but, as I recall it, a lot of the things we've done together were definitely on the verboten list. You don't seem to have any problem with that."

"No, but I think that was because I know other girls who've done the same things," Gia reasoned. "Even my mother's version of 'the talk' was basically telling me to do whatever made my husband happy once we were married."

"But nothing before that," Dean jibed.

"Yeah, she did say that," Gia laughed, "but I didn't need my math degree to figure out that my sister, Maria, was born less than seven months after my parents were married."

Dean just smiled, thinking he and his own bride had raced the stork to the altar as well.

"Look, Gia, if you want my opinion, and that's what you said you came here for," Dean said, "then I say go for it. I know that might sound a little hypocritical, since I tried to hide my encounter with Carl, but you know what, part of me regrets that I didn't take him up on his offer. I'll always wonder what it might've been like, really being with a guy. Oh, I know I could've hooked up with someone else in the years since, but sometimes you just have to seize the moment and not care what anyone else thinks. In the end, you don't need my or anyone else's approval."

Gia didn't reply, at least not with more than a small smile. Instead, she grabbed her small carry bag and headed for the bathroom, closing the door behind her. Dean heard the sound of the shower and when she later emerged, she was fully dressed. She then crossed the room and, after kissing him on the cheek, said her goodbye.

-=-=-=-

The following Friday, Gia found herself sitting on a barstool at Clayton's, a small bar and grill in Greenwich Village. Located only a few blocks from Washington Square Park, it was close enough to her apartment in SoHo for her to feel comfortable, yet distant enough that she didn't have to worry about running into a neighbor. It was still early enough in the evening that there were few patrons, allowing her to keep a wary eye on the entranceway as she sipped her white wine spritzer. She had been sitting there a half hour, having taken the subway downtown right after her work day had ended, fearful that she'd have a failure of nerve if she didn't.

As she waited, Gia almost felt like she had on first dates back in high school -- not that there had been that many of those. Oh, boys had asked, of course, but few managed to get past the inquisition that was her mother; especially if they weren't Italian -- and even then, the right kind of Italian. Which in her mother's eyes meant boys that still respected the old traditions. Not many qualified, but luckily for Gia, some who did, did so not because they were 'good boys', but simply because they'd become quite skilled at making themselves appear so. Paul had not been the first boy to get her into the backseat of the family car.

The clock on the wall finally reached six-thirty, the time they had agreed on -- then continued on to ten minutes to seven. As the bar began to fill, Gia wondered if, rather than simply being delayed, her date might've had a change of heart. But then, only a few minutes later, a well-dressed blonde in her late thirties stepped through the door.

Four inches taller and nearly thirty pounds heavier than the trim Italian woman at the bar, Darlene St. Claire had shoulder length hair that she wore tied back in a bun during business hours. A style that went well with her light gray blazer and matching knee length skirt, as well as the green, short sleeve popover blouse that she'd added for contrast. It was a conservative ensemble as befitted her position, yet one that managed to emphasize rather than hide the shapely body beneath. The most noticeable attribute of which was a bust several cup sizes larger than Gia's.

Darlene paused just past the entranceway, surveying the room with an anxious look on her face. An expression that turned, first to relief, and then to excitement as she spotted Gia. With determined steps, the tall woman strode toward the end of the bar.

"I'm so glad that you're still here," Darlene said as she reached Gia. "The meeting ran long, and as much as I wanted to, I couldn't simply walk out of it. I swear, some people just love to hear the sound of their own voices."

The thirty-seven year old had been head of Burroughs' Drama Department for the last six years and frequently served as the school's representative at various conferences. The one today had been a city-wide event, held on the main campus of NYU, a location that made Clayton's an ideal place for the two of them to meet up afterward.

"That's okay, I understand," Gia replied with a broad smile, one that hid the fact that she had been on the verge of leaving.

"Love the outfit, by the way," Darlene complimented as, putting the apology behind her, she slid into the empty space next to Gia. "I was hoping to head home and change first, but then worried that if I did, I'd miss you."

The red and white floral patterned dress Gia wore was the result of a half dozen changes the night before. Short sleeved with a hem that extended halfway to her ankles, it hugged her slim form just enough to show off what was underneath.

Enjoyed this story?

Rate it and discover more like it

You Might Also Like