This is a somewhat autobiographical story of my first time with another girl. It was such a crazy good experience that I've been wanting to write it all out for some time now. I've told some of my closest friends what happened, but never with any details. Not like this. I'm finding it incredibly exciting to actually put this out there and share it with people. I've changed some of the details, including names. I've added and removed parts to make the story flow smoothly and hopefully make it as sexy as possible. The spirit of what really happened is there though. I'm no novelist, so please excuse any poor writing techniques. I welcome any feedback in the comments, or you can message me on here. I did my best to capture my experience, and I hope you enjoy it.
"Oh my god. That was amazing!" Hailey closed the cabin door behind her as I collapsed face-forward on my twin bed.
I buried my face into the large fluffy pillow. The sides curled up and enveloped my head to the point where I could barely breathe. I rolled onto my back and clutched my stomach. "Why did you talk me into dessert? I can't believe I ate all that."
Hailey laughed. "I told you to be prepared, silly. Cruise ship food is always the best."
She was right. She had repeatedly told me how good everything would be for the past several weeks. It was only the first night of the cruise, but so far everything was living up to expectations. It had been a whirlwind trip up to this point. Between the flight, boarding the ship, the sail-away party, and dinner, I hardly had a moment to stop and breathe.
"So..." Hailey sat down on the bed next to me. "What do you want to do now? I can't wait to see what else is on this huge ship."
I groaned and rolled away from her. "You go on without me. I need a minute to let all that food digest."
Hailey slapped my shoulder. "Aw, come on. It's Spring Break! You can't stay in!" She pulled her iPhone out of her jeans shorts pocket. "And it's still early! Let's go to a show or something."
I stood up and arched my back. I knew she was right. It was early, and sitting around in this cramped interior cabin didn't exactly scream
Wild Spring Break Party
as I had promised her.
"What else is going on?" I asked.
Hailey glanced back down at her phone. She scrolled through the endless activities on the Carnival HUB app looking for something appealing to two senior college girls. I was about to ask her again, when she finally stopped scrolling. Her eyes light up. "Oh my god. I found the perfect thing!"
"What?"
"There's a singles mixer at the
Alchemy Bar
. It's just about to start."
I rolled my eyes. "You've got to be kidding me. If anyone shows up at all, it'll probably be just a bunch of horny old men."
Hailey laughed. "You never know! What better way to start our
Wild Spring Break Trip
than to hook up with a couple of cute guys? We gotta try at least. And I saw some of what you packed. I know you threw some sexy dresses in your suitcase."
I shrugged. "I guess. But I was saving those for formal night or something better than this."
Hailey leapt from the bed and placed both of her hands on my shoulders. "Yeah, but think of it this way. If there is a cute single guy onboard, wouldn't you want to meet him on the first night? Think how much fun this trip could be. You'd have him to yourself for the whole week! And it's been forever since you broke up with Austin. You're due!"
I sighed. Once again, Hailey was right. I hadn't had a boyfriend, or been with any guy for that matter, since the start of last semester. "Fine. Let me get changed. I don't know how you talk me into these things, but I could at least use a drink."
"There's the Katie I know!"
We both changed as fast as we could. Hailey threw on a cute little black dress, while I opted for a pink and white floral print cami dress. I hate walking in high heels, but I'm only 5'2", so I put on a pair of white sandals with ankle straps and three-inch heels. They were cute and matched well with my dress. Last, I threw a white cardigan over my dress.
"What's up with the cardigan?" Hailey asked as we headed out the door. "You don't attract hot guys by covering up."
"Yeah, well, it covers up my bra straps. And it's freezing on this ship. I'm not going to be attracting anyone if I'm sitting in the corner, shivering the whole time."
Hailey gave me a wry smile. "Oh come on. Skinny, long blonde hair, blue eyes. You're fucking hot. You just got to show it off."
I didn't feel hot though. I was still stuffed from dinner, and the ocean's humidity was messing with my hair. All I could do on short notice was pull it back in a ponytail.
We rode the elevator all the way down to Deck 2. I was surprised when we arrived. The
Alchemy Bar
was busy. Every seat at the bar was taken, and only a few random seats were open throughout the lounge. It was loud. People were talking and laughing, and just having a good time. A violin trio stood on a small stage, playing violin covers of modern pop songs. I wasn't sure how many people were actually there for the
Singles Mixer,
but it was already better than I had feared.
Hailey and I managed to find an unoccupied sofa in the back corner of the lounge. It sat low to the ground, and when I plopped myself onto it, I sank even further. It was comfortable enough though. I scanned a QR code with my phone to see the drink menu. The
Alchemy Bar
was known for exotic cocktails. It took forever to look over the whole menu. As it turned out, we had plenty of time to peruse. It was that busy, and the bar was understaffed. When a server finally came, Hailey ordered some kind of variation on a Pina Colada. Maybe I was still in a sour mood, but I went with a passionfruit margarita. We were still waiting for our drinks to arrive when two guys approached us.
"Are you two here for the
Singles Mixer
?" the first one asked. I exchanged a glance with Hailey. The boy seemed nervous, but not nearly as nervous as his friend behind him. His friend was keeping his distance and looking down at his feet.
Hailey smiled. "Why, yes we are!" She patted the sofa cushion to her left, inviting him to sit down next to her. I shifted to my right to allow him enough room to join us.
"Thanks," he said as he sat down. "I'm Matt, by the way. And this is Tyler." He gestured toward his friend. Tyler sat down in a separate chair next to me.
Matt was kind of cute, and I could tell that Hailey felt the same way. I'd been friends with her long enough to know her type. He had long, dark hair. The sleeves of his blue polo shirt squeezed tight against bulging muscles. You could tell that he spent some time in the gym. Part of a tattoo protruded out from under his sleeve, although I couldn't tell what it was. He and Hailey struck it off right away. Tyler was nothing special though. He barely spoke. He wasn't ugly or anything, but he was a bit overweight, and it looked like he hadn't shaved in a couple of days.
By the time our drinks arrived, Hailey was doing some hardcore flirting with Matt. She had inched herself over to be right up next to him. Her hand was on his shoulder, and she laughed at everything he said. I tried talking with Tyler, but it was awkward. I was completely driving the conversation, and he kept giving short one-word answers. He was the definition of boring. At least my drink was good. It was really sweet and not as sour as I had expected. Even the tropical aroma was fitting for a cruise vacation. I just sipped on my margarita to fill the awkward silence with Tyler.
As I neared the bottom of my glass, Tyler excused himself and got up. I didn't try to stop him. There was no chemistry between us, and I just wasn't interested. I was glad to see him go. I sat there for another few minutes, but it was even more awkward than it had been before. My drink was empty, so I no longer had that to distract me. Hailey was all over Matt, so I was quickly becoming the third wheel, sitting right there next to them. I pulled myself up from the low sofa and straightened out my dress. "You two have fun. I'm going to go and get another drink at the bar."
Hailey smiled up at me and nodded. She didn't need to say anything. We had an unspoken language. She was glad I was leaving. And I didn't mind. Not really. I was happy for her, but part of me wondered what this trip was going to be like if she was hanging around Matt all the time. It wasn't going to be as much fun on my own.
The bar started to empty. Plenty of people still lingered around, but some other event must have started elsewhere on the ship. Large swaths of people left, leaving several stools open on the far side of the bar. I chose one and quickly ordered a second passionfruit margarita.
"Striking out tonight?" The question came from behind me. I turned in my chair to see a girl who was probably only a couple of years older than me. She looked absolutely stunning in a purple halter dress with a deep V-neck that showed off her breasts. Wavy brunette hair with purple highlights cascaded just past her shoulders. The highlights perfectly matched her dress. She even wore a thin pair of purple open-toe sandals. Everything was color-coordinated.
"I didn't strike out," I said, turning back to my drink on the bar.
The girl sat on the bar stool to my right. "Looked like it to me. You were talking to that guy, and he just left. I was watching."
I turned toward her, trying to hide my surprise. "You were watching me?"
She laughed. "Well, kinda. Yeah. You were pretty hard to miss. You looked fucking miserable talking to him."
I sipped my drink. "Yeah, well...he wasn't exactly my type. Good to know that I looked so bad that you couldn't help but notice though."
"Oh no! That's not what I meant. I never said you looked bad. I said you looked miserable. There's a difference. You look super cute in that dress. That guy is either blind or an idiot to be missing out on you." She paused. "I'm Ashley by the way."
"Katie."
Ashley smiled. "Well, nice to meet you, Katie. You mind if I hang out and chat for a bit? I've had less luck than you. No one bothered approaching me."
I couldn't believe that she hadn't gotten any attention. She was by far the prettiest girl in the room. "Sure, I wouldn't mind the company. My friend basically ditched me."
Ashley craned her head in the direction of Hailey and Matt. "Yeah, seems like your friend is getting along with that guy just fine."
"Yeah." I didn't even look. I didn't need another reminder of how Hailey was getting along.
Ashley pointed at my glass on the bar. "So what are you drinking?"
"Passionfruit margarita."