corrupting-the-pony-girl
LESBIAN SEX STORIES

Corrupting The Pony Girl

Corrupting The Pony Girl

by arifoxsmith
20 min read
4.57 (7900 views)
adultfiction

The warm late-spring sun shone down on the lush meadows stretching out between wide bands of trees which broke up the scenery and made it look like there was nothing in the world except for nature in its most friendly and beautiful form. Truly, there couldn't have been a better time and place to lie in the grass naked, tied and gagged.

As nice as the day and the scenery might be, though, Rylee couldn't help being annoyed at herself. She was supposed to be the best pony girl in the herd, and yet she'd been one of the first to be caught in this year's cowgirl competition.

It hard started out so well, with her staying easily ahead of the pursuers, doing her best to break away from the bulk of the other pony girls so everyone would choose to hunt them instead of her. One of the cowgirls had pulled a fast one on her, though. She'd stayed back while her colleagues ran after the herd, only to circle around to where she guessed Rylee would ultimately escape to. And she'd guessed right. Rylee had just broken out of one of the stripes of forest when a lasso around her legs had made her smack down on the grass in the most undignified way.

It wasn't that Rylee had a problem with being bundled up and left behind while the rest of the cowgirls and pony girls continued their hunt. That was part of the game. It rubbed her the wrong way, though, that it had been a fresh upstart of a cowgirl who'd caught her, and so quickly at that. Stupid beginner's luck! Now everyone would think that she was the hot shit, and they'd wonder if Rylee had lost her spark.

Well, for now there was nothing she could do about it except gnaw on her bit gag in annoyance. It was one of the soft rubber ones, at least. The usual steel ones wouldn't be safe for this competition, given how the pony girls were pretty much expected to collide with the ground in a less than controlled manner at some point. Nobody would profit if they lost a tooth or two in the process.

As much as Rylee was loathe to admit it, that young cowgirl knew her ropes. While the bondage was nothing fancy (wrists joined with rope cuffs behind Rylee's back, her legs tucked in, ankles tightly bound to her thighs), it was as effective as could be.

While caught ponies were supposed to lie there and wait until they got collected at the end of the hunt, Rylee had sneakily tried to break out of her bonds, to make it look like the cowgirl had screwed up the bondage. It might help her save face if she could show that her captor coasted along purely on trickery with no skill to back it up. But despite her best efforts it was impossible to get to the knot of her rope cuffs with her fingers, and rubbing them against a stone had only earned her some scrapes on her wrists. And while she could almost reach the ropes on her legs, it remained at this infuriating "almost".

A rustle in the nearby trees caught Rylee's attention. Was the hunt over already and they were coming to get her? It seemed too early. After all, Rylee had been caught barely half an hour in, and she could have only been lying there for another half an hour or so. Usually these hunts lasted for several hours. Then again, maybe the other pony girls had delivered a similarly pathetic performance. Not that her own performance had been pathetic, of course, since she'd only been caught by blind luck.

Turned out, it wasn't a cowgirl. The woman with the bright blond hair appearing from between the trees was just as naked at Rylee, though instead of a bit gag she wore a collar with a short chain attached as a leash. One of the dog girls that had been brought along to assist in the hunt, only that this one had apparently gotten separated from her owner. Or had run away, more likely. Rylee didn't remember the names of all pet girls on the ranch, but she knew Daisy here, for the simple fact that she had to be the laziest and most badly behaved dog girl in history.

"Now look at that. Oh how the great have fallen." The fact that Daisy didn't make even the slightest attempt to stay in character was further proof that she was acting on her own accord. Instead of helping to round up the remaining pony girls like she was supposed to, she'd put it into her pretty but otherwise useless head to go gawk at Rylee instead.

"Is it true that a total newbie did you in? And so quickly to boot? Bet you don't feel so high and mighty anymore, now do you?" She knelt over Rylee, then dropped down in swift swoop so she sat on Rylee's belly, momentarily pushing the air out of her lungs.

Rylee growled. With the gag in, that was about the only way for her to express what she thought of Daisy's behavior. Not that she'd have had anything to say to her even if her mouth had been free. Daisy simply wasn't worth the time of her day. She only hoped that the poor gal who'd received Daisy as an aid would come for her soon, give her good thrashing to remind her of her place, and be off again with her in tow.

"You know, you could try being a little nicer for once. No wonder nobody likes you."

Rylee made an exasperated huff. What was this girl on about? Rylee was a nice enough person, nicer than most people around her deserved, even. If anything, the reason the other pony girls looked at her funny was that they were jealous.

Not that they would have anything to be jealous about if only they'd put in the work to get better at their job. Rylee wasn't a natural genius. Anyone could achieve her level of strength and grace, the others were just too lazy to make an honest attempt at it, preferring instead to spend their time at "stable parties", as they called their endless orgies.

And in a way Rylee got it. She, too, had needs. Had an itch between her legs that wanted to be scratched from time to time. But like a good pony girl she impressed her owner to earn some sexual attention as a reward, instead of going for the cheap thrill of humping the next best pony she saw. Or make use of one of the many dog girls running around, their sloppy tongues eager to lick absolutely anything you presented to them.

"What's that? Still think you're something better than me?" Daisy tilted her head as she looked down on Rylee. "Don't think I haven't noticed the way you look at me. To you I'm just some dumb mutt, ain't I?"

"Hmpf." That noncommittal sound was the best Daisy would get. While Rylee wouldn't have called her a dumb mutt to her face, she had been thinking about Daisy along those lines. Still, it wasn't wise to openly antagonize her while she was in a position of relative power. A very temporary position, but someone like Daisy might abuse this chance with no regard for the punishments it would earn her later.

"Fair enough. After all, for the longest time I only thought of you as this dumb bootlicker with no life."

Rylee snorted. It was rich for a dog girl to call someone else a bootlicker. Then again, Daisy was the kind of dog you wouldn't trust with your boots for fear that she'd shred them to pieces.

Daisy sighed. She put her hands on Rylee's breasts and idly played with her nipples. "You know, you're such a pretty girl. You'd be the star of the stable if only you took that stick out of your ass and let the others play with you."

Rylee growled again. She tried to shake Daisy off, but between the dog girl's weight and her bondage she could barely wiggle her body, let alone get away.

📖 Related Lesbian Sex Stories Magazines

Explore premium magazines in this category

View All →

"What's that? Got a problem? You're a pet girl, for fuck's sake, start acting like one!" Daisy let go of Rylee's breasts. Despite her harsh words, though, there was a strange softness in her eyes. "I just want to help you have a little fun for once."

Rylee grumbled and turned away as she realized that the look Daisy gave her was one of pity. It was so stupid. Daisy was the worst pet girl on the ranch by a long shot. By what authority was she making any kind of judgment call about Rylee's life?

"Come on, don't be like that!" Daisy make Rylee look at her again. She did it with her closed hand, and it felt like she was secretly holding something small. "I'm serious! I only want to help you. You might be a bit of a bitch, but hey, technically so am I, so we already have that in common."

Daisy gave Rylee a moment to react to the word play, but she only got the silence she deserved. "Anyway, I gotta admit, I feel a little sorry for you. You know, with how you don't really fit in. But if I confronted you about it any other time, you'd just tell me to mind my own business, so I thought, there's no day like today. You can't brush me off now, so you gotta at least listen and give me a chance to get through to you."

Rylee groaned and threw her head back into the grass. She regretted her own theatrics when the sudden movement made some drool dribble out of the corners of her mouth and run over her cheeks. The bit gag made swallowing possible for the most part, but it was still a bit of a struggle.

To her surprise, Daisy wiped it off her cheeks with gentle fingers. "I think you're a pretty cool person deep down. You're strong, you're smart, you're determined. And sexy, can't forget that. People just can't appreciate it because you make them feel like you're something better. But if we proved to them that you have a wild, fun side, that you're not above enjoying some raunchy adventures here and there, they'd see that you're just like them, and I'm sure they'd come around to you."

Daisy leaned in, her face hovering right above Rylee's as if she was letting her in on a secret, even though there was no one around to listen anyway. "Just imagine what would happen if there was a rumor that you got caught on purpose because you had a deal with me to meet you for some dirty fun. You'd be the talk of the stable. And it would totally fit. Like, you only play the haughty girl because you're embarrassed about the others seeing the real you, but in secret you're a slut like everyone else."

Rylee didn't know if she should be angry or amused by Daisy's ramblings. The idea was preposterous. No one who knew her would believe for even a moment that she'd have some secret sex deals with the most useless dog girl around.

Or so she'd like to think. Though, truth be told, none of the other pony girls knew her all that well. While Daisy was spouting unholy amounts of bullshit, she was correct insofar as that Rylee didn't have any real connection with her fellow pet girls. They were likely to believe pretty much anything about her if it came from the right source.

"Look, I even came prepared!"

Rylee's eyes grew wide as Daisy showed her what she'd been hiding in her hand: A tiny vibrator, the kind that was made to blast your clit until you sang Hallelujah.

Pets weren't allowed to have any toys. They might at times get given some, but only so they could put on a show for the entertainment of their owners. Stealing one for unsupervised use was a serious crime, one that earned you a lot more than a smarting ass. If they were found in the possession of that thing, they might very well spend the evening bound to the whipping post.

"I already had a test drive with it," Daisy continued, utterly unfazed by the kind of trouble she might get the two of them into. "And I can tell you, it's every bit as amazing as you think it is. With this I can make you come like you've never come before. So what do you say? Are you in for a little adventure?"

To her horror Rylee realized that she actually considered it. Only for a moment, of course. Daisy's proposal was absolutely crazy. If they got caught, not only would she have a real painful punishment to look forward to, her status as the best pony girl in the stable would be seriously jeopardized. And for what? For an orgasm and some street cred? Certainly not!

Even if it would be an amazing orgasm.

Given to her by a woman who was, despite all her flaws, admittedly pretty hot.

And it was kinda nice to imagine the other ponies giving her impressed looks when they heard what kind of naughty shenanigans Rylee had secretly been up to.

A dirty grin grew on Daisy's lips. Fuck, she'd hesitated too long! Rylee shook her head energetically, but it was too late.

"Don't try to deny it. We both know that you want to find out what it's like to live a little. Though I have to admit, it's hot to see you so conflicted."

Daisy leaned in. Due to the bit gag she couldn't properly kiss Rylee, though that wasn't her intention anyway. Daisy might be the world's worst dog girl when it came to behavior, but there was a reason she'd become a terrible dog girl instead of a terrible pony girl, a terrible maid, or any other kind of badly performed submissive role. Her personality profile was on point, and so were her sloppy dog kisses. She licked all over Rylee's lips, making her squirm in a weird mix of discomfort and arousal.

"I know it's gotta be hard for you to commit to doing such a bad thing when you see yourself as this perfect good girl. But maybe I can help you get over yourself." Daisy playfully tugged at Rylee's lower lip with her teeth. All her previous efforts to prevent Rylee from drooling over herself were more than undone by this point. "How about this: We both act as if you're not to blame. You just lie there, all bundled up and helpless, and then this crazy dog girl comes along and has her nasty ways with you. You can't stop her. What's happening to you isn't your fault, even if you end up liking it."

"Hngh?" Rylee stared back at Daisy, deeply confused about how to feel about any of this. The wet tingle on her lips and having Daisy's pretty face so close to her didn't make it easier to think calm, rational thoughts, either.

🛍️ Featured Products

Premium apparel and accessories

Shop All →

"That's a deal, isn't it? I'll even take full responsibility in case we get caught. Like, you've got all the plausible deniability in the world here. If they see you bound and gagged, like you're supposed to be, while I'm in a place I shouldn't be holding a toy I shouldn't have, it won't take much to convince them you're innocent. Oh, and just so you know..." She leaned in even closer, so her lips were right at Rylee's ears as she continued in a sultry whisper. "I kinda have a thing for seeing innocence get corrupted. If you let me have this, I'll be your bitch tomorrow. Just think of what you could make me do. And how impressed the other ponies are gonna be when they see that I let you order me around."

Rylee's breath caught. She knew that she should stick with what she knew was right and blow Daisy off. Whatever stupid sexy promises Daisy might make, they weren't worth losing her reputation as the best pony girl. And yet she couldn't help but fantasize about the things she'd be able to do if Daisy really became her bitch for a day. Especially since Daisy was the sluttiest pet girl around, which was a high bar to cross.

This would be the chance to try out all the things Rylee had always been kinda curious about but would have never been comfortable approaching someone with. For example, she'd like to find out if having your ass licked was as amazing as some of the others hyped it up to be. Knowing Daisy, she'd do it in a heartbeat. And who knew, if Daisy's plan worked and all this indeed broke the ice with the other ponies, maybe she might be able to unlock some other fantasies in the future...

But wouldn't she be a giant hypocrite if she broke the rules with Daisy, after shunning the others because they chose the cheap thrill of sex over being good ponies?

"So what's it gonna be? Do you want me to corrupt you?"

Rylee whined. Yes, in some way she wanted it. But she also wanted to be a good pony, and she wouldn't throw everything overboard like that. With a heavy heart, she shook her head.

"Thought so." Daisy didn't seem disappointed. In fact, her grin only grew wider. "Let's see how long you can keep lying to yourself."

Rylee froze as Daisy dragged her soft, wet tongue over her cheek, eyes shining with mischief. She must be thinking that Rylee's (admittedly not very convincing) head shake had been an act, a way of Rylee pretending not to want this, so Daisy could fully immerse herself into her corruption fantasy. Rylee should have cleared things up right away. Even with the gag, there were ways to make it unmistakably clear that she wanted to Daisy to back off.

But did she actually want her to? Or did she just want herself to want it?

This already shaky train of thought derailed completely when Daisy reached between Rylee's legs. It was embarrassing how easily two of her fingers slid into her. Embarrassing, but also so, so pleasurable.

"What's that? Flaunting your virtues when your body is just as slutty as everyone else's? You need to stop kidding yourself and admit that you're no better than us in any shape or form." Daisy curled her fingers inside Rylee, making her gasp. But while her mocking words stung, there was no malice behind them. Daisy might be calling her a lowly slut, but in her world there was genuinely nothing wrong with being a lowly slut.

Rylee tried to get it together and work up the strength to tell Daisy off. But that would have required blocking out how good her fingers felt inside her. Daisy might be nothing but a stupid mutt most of the time, but she knew how to hit a woman's weak spots. Maybe Rylee could enjoy this for a few seconds longer before putting an end to it...

"Already giving in? I expected you to put up more of a fight. Then again, it's not like you can argue against how much your body wants this." Daisy ripped her fingers out and held her hand up to Rylee's face. Her fingers glistened in the sun, and there were even some sticky strands forming between her index and middle finger. Was Rylee really this wet?

"It's time to really rub it in what you are." Daisy wiped her fingers on Rylee's face, and she did indeed really rub it in. She made sure to spread the raunchy wetness all over, onto her cheeks, her nose, her lips, even her tongue as she shoved her fingers between the gag and Rylee's teeth.

Rylee growled in indignation. She tried to twist away, but Daisy had her too completely under control. She exhaled sharply but couldn't dislodge the sticky droplets at her nostrils that filled her nose with her sweetly smell. And no matter how much she tried to swallow, thanks to the gag she wasn't able to get rid of the taste.

It wasn't that she had a problem with tasting herself on principle. She even liked it when her owner made her do it, but in those occasions it was a refined, sensual affair. Being treated in such a dirty manner by a random dog girl was humiliating.

"Don't like it?" Daisy asked with mock sympathy. "It's not healthy to dislike your own body. You're clearly lacking some self love. As a medical professional, I prescribe at least two self love sessions a day for a month, one in the morning and one before bedtime. That should help you get over these hangups."

Rylee huffed and tried to bite Daisy's fingers. Unsuccessfully, of course.

"Time to show you how good it can feel to be a bad girl." Daisy picked the vibrator back up and turned it on. Its buzz was surprisingly loud. That sound had to carry pretty far. Rylee could only hope that the hunting cowgirls wouldn't hear it and come looking to see what was going on.

Wait, what was she thinking? It was bad enough how tempted she was by Daisy's indecent suggestions. Was she really hoping for Daisy to get away with it? She might not be able to help herself from getting turned on, but as a good pony she should still be happy if Daisy was caught and brought to justice.

Ideally only after she'd gotten a taste of that vibrator, though.

Yes, those weren't the thoughts of a good pony, either, but damn, that thing sounded like hell of a ride. It had been years since Rylee became a pony girl, and while her life had been so much better and hornier for it, some aspects of having left her sex toys behind with her old life haunted her. As the best pony she earned herself lots of rewards, so it really wasn't like she languished in sexual frustration, but as nice as all those strap-on fuckings and the manual attention were, they didn't give her the same sharp pleasure as a vibrator on her clit.

Enjoyed this story?

Rate it and discover more like it

You Might Also Like