Abby was up early the next morning. I had tossed and turned all night, but finally seemed to be knocked out, and she didn't want to wake me, so she got out of bed and headed to the kitchen. She hadn't slept well either, but neither of us discussed any part of the evening when we got in bed that night. She knew this would be the second awkward morning in a row. In any many ways, last night was even crazier than the first. They went to the swingers' club with the general idea that they might hook up with another couple. But Abby could have never expected that last night would end with her husband having a 7-inch black dildo in his ass and having what seemed to be his most intense orgasm ever because of it. She knew the first night had been humiliating for him, but she didn't know what to think about the previous evening. Would he be humiliated again? Embarrassed? What if he loved it? What did that mean for the future? Abby did not consider herself a dominate person. While she was fascinated by Sam taking control of the room and surprised by what other areas of Anthony's body incurred pleasure from, Abby felt like she didn't know anything about this type of play. Last but not least, she couldn't help but wonder why Reggie had organized this whole thing.
As she was sitting on the couch deep in thought, her phone buzzed and startled her back to reality. "Speak of the devil" she thought to herself as she picked up her phone.
"Hey girl, it's Reggie. Sounds like last night was interesting at your place. How we move forward from here is complicated. I only play if I make the rules. I'm not trying to be an asshole, I'm just stating the facts. I know you enjoyed the experience Friday night, and I'm sure you want that again, but the ego of most husbands gets in the way. Last night was about taking that ego down a notch, but also teaching him that there is still pleasure that comes from not being in control. At this point you have to decide if you are on board. The opportunity is there for both you and Anthony to experience pleasure like you've never had, but it's going to take effort on your part to steer the ship. Husbands typically don't just hop on. Hit me back and LMK. If not, I wish you luck in your future escapades."
Abby's reaction towards Reggie's assertiveness was completely different than Anthony's. She was drawn to it. She immediately got butterflies in her stomach and Friday nights feelings rushed back over her. She had never had sexual pleasure on that level. While she still felt a small twinge of guilt admitting that he was right. She did want him again. Reggie was the best fuck of her life. She had seen the other attendees at the club that night. No one had sparked her interest at all. She knew if she and Anthony tried again, she would never find another man that could make her cum like that.
Reggie's ultimatum had her mind racing. He knew exactly what he was doing by planning the previous night, and he knew that pulling the proverbially rug, or "cock" out from under her would make her want it even more. What did he mean by "his rules" though?
Right then she heard the toilet flush in the bathroom. I washed my hands and came into the living room.
She felt her heart thumping as she was still looking at the screen on her phone. "There's coffee in the kitchen if you want some." She managed to say. She quickly put her phone down as I went to the cabinet and got a mug to pour some coffee.
It felt like déjà vu. The same awkwardness as the morning before, but the tension was even more palpable. Abby finally decided that humor might be the best way to clear the air.
"So how's your butthole this morning?" She quipped, smiling at me.
"What the fuck, Abby?????" I snapped back.
"I'm sorry! I literally have no idea how to break the ice this morning. I'm just trying to add some humor to the situation." She replied
I sat back on the couch, sulking slightly, but about what, I wasn't exactly sure. Not even 8 hours ago, I had experienced the most intense orgasm of my life in this exact spot. Was I scared because I might have to admit that in the ensuing conversation?
"My butthole is fine. Thank you for asking." I finally replied
They sat in silence for another minute or so.
"I couldn't sleep last night Abby. I would like to have an open conversation about the actual encounter last night, but my main question is why did Reggie set me up like that? It's just fucked up."
Abby just nodded in agreement, not quite sure how to respond. As she was about to speak, she was hit with another twinge of guilt. Earlier this morning she felt guilt about being so honest about how good the sex was with Reggie. Now she felt guilt for the lie she was about to tell her husband.
"I don't know why Reggie would do that." She said as she looked me directly in the eyes.
Abby had never been a selfish person. But just now she had lied directly to me in hopes that it would mean she could keep getting fucked by Reggie. She didn't know how that made her feel in that moment, but she had done it anyway.
"I need you to be 100% honest with me Abby. Did he tell you what he had planned?" Anthony asked
"I promise you, he did not. He really seemed sincere in his text yesterday." Abby replied
"Last night was interesting though. Did you want to talk about that at all? I promise I'm not judging you about anything that happened. I want to let you know also that I'm sorry that I've never pinched your nipples or rubbed your taint before." Abby continued. She didn't want to mention the dildo unless I brought it up first.
"It's fine." I replied. "Don't get me wrong, it was fun, but it's not like our normal sex isn't intense too."
I always prided myself on being an honest person, but I too had just lied to my spouse. I was going to need more time before I could admit to anyone else the amount of pleasure I had experienced the night before.
"Ok, well just know that we can always talk about it if you want. I don't want to pressure you at all though. I'm going to get cleaned up and make the grocery run. Maybe we can relax and watch a movie this afternoon?" Abby asked
"Sure, that sounds like a good plan after the last few days" I replied
Once Abby left for the store, I flipped on the TV to watch some football and hopefully distract my mind for a bit. It didn't really help though. I just couldn't get over how intense the feeling was with the dildo inside me last night. I vaguely knew what my prostate was, but only in the joking manner that it was mentioned when one of our buddies turned 40 and had to go see the doctor for his annual checkup. The fact that it provided such pleasure was totally new to me.
I grabbed my phone and did a Google search. I quickly found quite a few medical based articles that lended credibility to the fact that the prostate can provide pleasure to all men. Why I felt the need to validate that, I wasn't sure. About halfway down the page he came across an article from Men's Health titled "The Male G Spot is Real". I clicked on the article and found that my experience definitely wasn't unique. Men across the world seemed to be exploring their prostates regularly. Again, this made me feel more comfortable for some reason. I had never questioned my sexuality, but the thought of getting off with something in my butt just didn't sit right until now.
As I continued to read, the article listed off a ton of toys that men used to explore this sensation. The article also alluded to the fact that some men came from prostate pressure alone. Last night was such a blur that I didn't know exactly what made me cum. Was it the dildo, Sam's rubbing, or her gorgeous rack? I couldn't really be sure. Curiosity had the best of me now though. I hopped on XHamster, to do a search.
Not quite sure what the best term was, I typed in "Dildo Prostate Orgasm". When the search fully loaded, I couldn't believe it. 1500 videos matched that search. Obviously the rest of the world knew more about this than I did. I began clicking on videos to see what I could learn, and I quickly found out that men were indeed having massive orgasms from anal penetration alone.
The more I watched, the more I became turned on. I could tell this was pretty close to what I experienced last night, and that made my dick hard. I also couldn't help but notice that the men in the videos cumming the most were using very sizable dildos. The one that Sam used on him really seemed to be the minimum size. Also, like last night, most of the men seemed to be using black dildos.
One of the related videos from the search caught my eye. The thumbnail was nothing but a great set of tits. The title read "Strapon Wife Pounds Hubby to Orgasm". Just like the prostate exams, I had been aware of strapons obviously, but always from a joking manner. I had never put much thought in to their use until seeing Eden come out of the bathroom with it on Friday night.
