The despair that took shape in Elisha's heart since Athena's dismissal was of a new kind.
No longer was she indifferent towards the world nor its effects or her fate. Now, for the first time in months, she was suffering because she wanted something and didn't have it rather than pure apathy.
She couldn't sleep after their encounter. Instead she stayed up, waiting on the off-chance that when her father came home, he would bring Athena back to her.
If nothing had solidified the belief that she did, in fact, want Athena in a sexual manner, then seeing her with her father did. Elisha heard them come in at precisely 4:34 a.m. (she was watching the clock), and snuck out of her room into the dark hallway, hoping to catch a glimpse. The two had made their way into her father's den rather quickly, and were talking about their evening.
Elisha's stomach roiled as she approached the open door, all too aware that either of them giving a careful glance her way would reveal her. But by the time she was watching them through the opening, all talk had ceased, and they were both occupied with each other.
They were engaged in deep kiss, and as awkward as it was to witness her father "in action," it turned her on to see Athena being kissed like that, and she took comfort in the fact that her father was a blood relation, taking vicarious pleasure in the act as if she were the one doing it. In time, her father's gnarled and liver-spotted hands made their way from Athena's small waist to the ends of her dress, and lifted it up.
Elisha was well aware that her new crush had a big ass, but seeing it it pulled up by the dress and then drop down with the pull of gravity was dazzling. It was huge - almost ridiculous, in the same way that young kids with huge backpacks look like aspiring turtles, so too Athena's booty seemed attached. Even her panties caught the eye: pristine white once again, just like her dress, with lacy frills at the back, and a big ball of fluff meant to look like a rabbit's tail.
"Who's my good little girl?" her father asked.
Athena sniffed incredulously. "I am, Daddy. Only me."
Daddy.
The word made Elisha nauseous and guilty, but she couldn't look away...
"You were bad tonight."
"I was good, Daddy."
"You were flirty."
Athena grinned. "How's that bad?" She leaned in and kissed him again, moaning softly.
Meanwhile her father spanked Athena's ass, each slap sending her brown butt rippling and bouncing with a loud crack.
It looked so soft.
God...
Like the cringe-worthy idiot she was, Elisha tried gripping her own butt; but there was barely anything there to play with. .
The the wrinkled old hand belonging to her father sank into the brown flesh completely, his claws kneading it with violence. Both of them moaned, and soon he added a second hand, while Athena wrapped her arms around his back and started... unlatching her heels just by using her feet.
Elisha stifled a laugh.
Next level.
And then the fun was over. The door slammed closed, the suddenness of it all throwing Elisha back against the wall.
Was she spotted? No, that was unlikely. Athena's eyes were closed. And plus, she wasn't in the light. It was unlikely...
Now she couldn't hear a thing, not even muffled noises.
Fuck.
Elisha crawled back to bed and, satisfied that Athena would likely be there when she woke up in the morning, went to sleep.
However, upon waking up she found herself cuffed to bed, with Athena sitting at her side. And Athena looked different now. She wore white sneakers with bright blue laces, jean shorts, and a floaty blue top. She wore an NYC cap, a black ponytail sprouting from the back.
"What are you doing?"
But Athena was too busy with her phone to answer. At length she laughed, then showed Elisha a video of a dog licking a laughing baby. "Isn't that cute?"
"That's very cute... Why am I tied to the bed?"
"Because you've been a bad girl, baby. Spying on us last night... what's wrong with you?" Elisha winced. So she did see. "And then I kept thinking last night about how we left off. You were such a buzzkill. And I was so nice to you. You even made that dumb comment about me being a gold digger."
"I said you
weren't
a gold digger."
Athena rolled her eyes. "Whatever. That's not the point."
"I know. I'm sorry."
"I know, I know you're sorry... But that doesn't make it right."
Did that mean there was a way to make it right? She very much hoped so. "What can I do?"
Athena bit her lip naughtily. "First, tell me... Did you like watching me being with your dad last night?"
Elisha hesitated a moment. "Yes."
"I bet you would've wanted to see more. What happens before closed doors."
"Kind of... Yes..."
Athena got up and started circling the bed. "Maybe I should tell him to add you to the mix. Just you, me, and Daddy. Wouldn't that be nice?"
"I-"
"
I don't know?
That better be out of your fucking vocabulary after last night."
"It will be."
"You're lucky I'm even here, you know. At first I thought:
Man, fuck this ungrateful hoe.
But then I thought:
She's shy, it's all new to her, she was being remorseful when I left...
So I decided to give you another shot. Do not fuck this up!" Athena yelled, and kicked the bed. "You feel me?"