Me and Ana were 3 months into our relationship and it couldn't be going any better. She was a cute freshman from a small town who I met while attending an event on campus. We talked for a few months before finally dating but never really mentioned anything about our past. One morning at the dining hall, Ana and I were finishing up our breakfast when Michael, a guy who lived on my floor, walked by and looked over at her and then gave a weird sinister smirk as he acknowledged me. Michael and I weren't that close but I knew he lived on my floor because he was a 6'3" black guy on the basketball team.
As Michael continued to walk to the table he was sitting at, parallel to our, I noticed he was sitting with the basketball team. I couldn't help but continue to glance over at their table and each time I took a look, it seemed as though they were talking about us. I started to feel like something was up but shrugged it off as I went to get more water.
While walking back, I saw Michael and his friend Elijah standing by our table hovering over Ana while speaking with her. I was shocked that she already knew some people from the basketball team since she seemed to be such a shy girl. Seeing Michael and Elijah's big muscular bodies hover over her made my cock twitch but also made me start to realize that Ana may know way more about these guys than just basketball. I sat down and they ignored my presence as they continued to talk to my girlfriend as if I wasn't there. Finally, they headed back to their table and me and Ana left the dining hall.
On the walk back to my room, Ana said she left her wallet on the table at the dining hall and that she was going to go back and get it then head to her dorm which was a few buildings over. I didn't think much of it but I did remember seeing the table be clear as we left the dining hall. I thought maybe she dropped it out of her pocket or something so I let her go on without questioning it.
A few hours later, I received a text from Ana that said, "I'm so sorry, I haven't been honest with you. Can we talk?" My heart started to race because this was the first time in our relationship that there seemed to be an issue. I walked over to her dorm and saw her sitting on her bed and it seemed as though she had been crying. I asked what was wrong and she then told me that Michael and Elijah were both guys that she had fucked before we met and that she went back to the dining hall to meet up with them and get fucked again but that she "changed her mind" because she felt bad. I couldn't believe what I was hearing even though I had the suspicion. I started to get insecure and felt like my cock wasn't good enough for her. I asked her who else she had been with and she proceeded to name 3 other black men who were close with the basketball team. She then said that it was all within the first month of her being at the school.
Knowing she's been on birth control since her last relationship, I couldn't help but ask if they had used a condom. She shook her head and I instantly knew that these men were laughing at me from the other table because they creamed the girl that I was beginning to fall in love with just a month before I had met her. I loved it but didn't show it. Instead, I pretended to be upset and kept asking questions so I could get more out of her. She told me that Michael and Elijah both fucked her at the same time in the Men's bathroom in the science building. This suddenly made me snap.
"I want you to text all 5 of them and tell them to come over right now," I proclaimed.
She looked so confused and stuttered when asking what and why. She thought I wanted to fight them all when I knew damn well I'd get killed if I even tried. What I really wanted to watch them all fuck her right in front of me.
