Author's note: If you're reading Chapter 3, I hope that means you're enjoying the story. I've kindof forgotten about balancing the story with description and action, and just let my memory flow. This part's a bit longer, but I had to tell it like it was. I hope you enjoy. And please comment.
***
It took a few agonizing days before a situation presented itself when Jill or I could begin our evil plan. I actually didn't give a damn about teasing Missy, I just wanted to seal the deal. But if Jill wanted to fuck with her friend a bit, before we fucked with her, I wasn't about to argue.
The plan was pretty good, and Missy was pretty gullible. So as long as Jill didn't mess it up, we knew we'd drive her crazy. I also knew it was going to take way too long. So, rather than beat around the bush, I figured I'd give Missy a taste of her own medicine. She was standing at the kitchen counter in her nightshirt, making herself breakfast.
"Good morning," I said, "What are you making me?"
As I walked up behind her, Missy replied, "I'm not making you anything."
"Well, that's not very nice," I told her as I stood directly behind her, "...considering what I was gonna do for you." Her long red curls drew me in, and I put a hand on her hip, slid it under her shirt, and pulled her hipbone towards me.
As I pressed myself against her ass, she resisted, "What are you doing?"
"Same thing you did to me." I told her as I slid my hand down over her panties.
"Uh...Jill isn't here! It's different!"
"Of course...you're right." I said, and I retracted my wandering hand. "I should wait for her to come downstairs before I flirt with you."
"That's not what I meant."
"Oh, because I was just going to give you a nice massage," I coyly replied.
"Sure you were."
"I swear," I continued, "I swear I wasn't going to wrap my arms around you, and let my hands wander all over your body."
Missy turned to face me, and leaned against the counter. She was blushing. I leaned in close to her.
"I swear I wasn't going to kiss the back of your neck...or press my fingers between your legs and rub you until you begged me to get you off."
I quickly turned and walked over to the refrigerator. I grabbed the half gallon of OJ, and took a long pull straight from the container. I slammed the door shut, and as I walked out of the kitchen I noticed that Missy hadn't moved as she stared with her jaw on the floor.
Apparently, later that day, Missy asked Jill if she was mad at her about the blow job games. Jill had assured her that she wasn't mad, as long as Missy remembered that I was Jill's boyfriend and not her's.
A couple days later, it was Jill's turn to screw with Missy's mind. Jill proceeded to tell Missy, in confidence, that we were thinking about having a threesome. Missy reacted with excitement at first. Then Jill told her that I had made a comment about another girl at work, and that Jill was thinking about a threesome with this other girl. At that, Missy had quickly changed her tune, and discouraged her. But now Missy had her dilemma. And Jill and I were secretly playing her from both angles.
The reaction from Missy was almost immediate. She barged her way into the bathroom that night while I was showering, and closed the door behind her.
"What are you doing?" I asked, as Missy peered around the curtain.
"Just looking."
"You better get out of here." I pretended to be disinterested. "Jill should be home any minute."
"I don't think she'll mind...Trust me."
"No, you were right." I almost laughed as I teased her, "We shouldn't do anything like this when she's not around." I pulled the curtain closed.
"What, I'm just having a little fun." Missy was getting frustrated.
"No way. I'm not doing anything that would piss her off."
Missy stormed out of the bathroom, just as I was about to burst out laughing. I wasn't sure how much longer I could keep up the game.
The next morning, Jill and I were lying in bed, enjoying each other's naked bodies once again.
"Missy asked me about the threesome again last night," Jill said. "Did you hear us?"
"No."
"Oh my God...I almost blew it." Jill laughed as she started to tell the story. "I had to bite my lip to keep from laughing.
I rolled to my side, and groped Jill's breasts. My hand glided up and down her body from her shoulders to her thigh. Her wild brown curly hair splayed out on the pillow was a favorite sight for me.
"She didn't know whether to discourage me or tell me to go for it." Jill recapped, to my amusement. "Then she started asking all about what I thought you really wanted..."
"What'd you tell her?"
"I said I didn't know. And that you seemed unsure," Jill continued, "Then she asked if I really wanted to if you were into it."
"You've got her all fucked up." I laughed.
"What do we do next?" Jill asked.
I instinctively jumped up to my knees, quickly pulled Jill's leg over my shoulder, and plowed my hardened cock into her.
"Ugh," she groaned as my thrust squeezed the air from her lungs, "I mean what do we do with Missy?"
I held still for a moment as Jill's pussy settled around the base of my shaft, "We'll see."
***
The next steps with Missy were guided by the influence of alcohol. It was probably inevitable that it would all go down sooner or later. Such was college life. But with all three of us drunk and hanging out together on a weekend night, the game of teasing Missy was quickly forgotten. We had been at some party in another building in the college apartment complex. We were all pretty rocked, and at some point Jill and I started walking back to our apartment. I truly don't remember how it happened, but about halfway back, I suddenly had a girl on each arm. Missy must have noticed that we'd left, and caught up to us. Despite scheming with Jill for days, I think I was too drunk to even think about a threesome at first.
But when we finally got back to our apartment, the girls crashed into a giggling heap of flesh on the couch. From there, things just happened. I stood over the girls, beer bottle in hand, and pulled Jill's top over her head. The two of them were basically sitting next to each other on the couch, and as Jill's top came off, she leaned over and collapsed onto Missy. Jill grabbed the bottle from my hand, and took a meaningful swig, the way drunk girls do. Missy was not to be outdone, and proceeded to remove her own top. Then she took the bottle from Jill, and took her own gulp. You know you're drunk, when you aren't fazed by two topless girls giggling in front of you. Instead, I turned and mumbled something stupid about needing another beer, as I wandered toward the kitchen. That was when the girls were suddenly quiet, and I turned back to see them running up the stairs, bare breasts bouncing along the way.