"Soooo. . ." Maddy said to me, as she rubbed her hand over the outline of my morning wood through my cotton boxers as we lay in bed together that Sunday morning.
I smiled because I already knew where this was headed.
"Yeah?" I answered slyly back.
"You wanna text our neighbor and see what he's up to tonight?" She had a mischievous grin spreading over her lips like little league snack bar sour licorice.
I grabbed my phone from the nightstand and she cuddled up close to me as we sat back against our pillows on the headboard and played this new game that we were all consumed by.
I tried to sound nonchalant in the first text:
Me: "Hey man, you busy tonight by any chance?"
He texted back only seconds later.
Tom: "Actually, I think I'm fairly free tonight. Why? You wanna get together for a good run or, did you have something else in mind?"
He had left it open-ended. I still FELT open-ended after what he'd done to my buns just two nights earlier. My ass tingled from its fresh stretch.
Maddy was currently running her hand up and down my bulging boxers, rubbing her fingers just under the head of my penis through the fabric as I was dying for her to take me out and hold my hard-on like she would do when she teased me.
"What should I say?" I looked down at her and she looked at me with those naughty eyebrows that were always dancing with sexy intention.
"Hmmm, I think you should be totally upfront with him," she said.
"Okay. . .so. . .what should I say?" My heart was beating fast as I held the phone in front of us.
"You should say. . .that your very horny wife came home early from her weekend getaway and that she knows all about your sexy fun and that she would very much like an encore performance."
I felt my cock pulse as she rubbed me through my front boxer pouch. I was ridiculously hard.
I typed out the message to Tom—a message I knew she would like very much.
Me: "So, my wife Maddy came home early and she knows about our fun from the other night, and we thought it might be fun if you came over tonight and the three of us could have some sexy fun together."
She giggled a little as she read what I wrote because it was almost verbatim. We were both so excited by this now as our bodies rubbed against each other teasingly.
Maddy was only wearing a pair of thin, white Calvin Klein thong and one of my old t-shirts that fell down over her shoulder revealing her freckled skin. I felt her rubbing her pelvis against me as we continued our text convo with Tom.
Tom: "That sounds like a lot of fun, actually. But before I say yes, I want you to both tell me what you want."
"Holy fuckkkkk." Maddy moaned as she looked up at me. "This guy is fucking hot, FUCK." She had no idea how hot he truly was. But she was definitely going to find out.
"Well, what do we want, baby?" I asked her now in a naughty voice. We were both so horny and honest with each other and we'd clearly opened up an amazing new box of fantasies that was absolutely thrilling for us both.
"I think we want to be his sluts, right baby?" She said this to me in the sexiest and yet, sweetest way. It was so suggestive. I could practically feel her words hooking like smoke and dragging the hairs of my neck backwards into her web of kink.
I moaned when she said that because she had taken my cock out of my boxers and her soft hand felt so good as she started to stroke my morning wood with her years of focused expertise.
"Yeah." I said to her. I did want that. And it turned me on so much to think that we both wanted that.
"Tell him," She responded.
Me: "We want to be your sluts for the night."
I sent the text and I gulped. Maddy grinded her body against me as we both held our breath and waited. This whole thing insanely turned us both on. It felt like we were landing on an unknown planet together. What if that wasn't what he wanted? The phone buzzed again.
Tom: "Good. That's all I needed to hear you say. I'll see you guys around six, okay?"
We put the phone down and made out like teenagers for the better part of an hour. I wanted to fuck and cum so badly but Maddy wouldn't let me. She didn't want me cumming until Tom came over that night. She wanted me on the very edge of my horniness.
We spent the day cleaning the house and then did some Yoga together. We took a long bath in our tub and I watched as she shaved her legs and pussy.
Then she grabbed her hair trimmer and had me open up for her. She manscaped my private areas and trimmed all the hair from my ass, even stopping to give my exposed taint a cute little kiss with her plush lips. When I moaned, she leaned in and licked me a little while longer. My cock felt like it was on boner-pill-cocaine. We got out of the bath and dried off and she grabbed her most expensive lotion and made sure we were both very lathered and smooth and sexy as could be.
When five o'clock rolled around, Maddy and I made us some drinks and then started deciding on what to wear.
"What do you think would turn Tom on the most?" She asked me, and now we were both fully submerged in the direction this night was going.
Her lingerie drawer was an absolute Candyland of fun and colorful outfits. She chose a pink and black trimmed frilled Jade Split Cup naughty bra and panty set from Frederick's that she was obsessed with. She always told me it was her favorite outfit for when she was feeling incredibly slutty. She put these on and then chose a cute pair of jean short overalls and a white tank top, which clearly showed off that she was wearing lingerie underneath. She put her hair back in a simple, cute ponytail. Then she got to work on what could only be called the slutty girl-next-door makeup look. It was flirtatious and fun and at the same time, delectably submissive. Her pale pink lipstick puffed her perfect lips in a way that made you just want to tell her to go down on her knees and start sucking. She could've been your favorite babysitter or the daughter of the preacher that cares more about the biggest-dicked deacon than the diatribes of Deuteronomy.
"And what are YOU gonna wear, babe?" She asked me as I rubbed more lotion into my body. I was getting nervous with anticipation.
"Hmmm, I hadn't thought of that." She strolled over to my underwear drawer and looked through my various boxer briefs. That's when I saw her grab a comfy black jock strap I had owned from an old baseball league. She dangled it from her finger with a raised eyebrow. I wanted to say no, but I could see this was what she absolutely wanted, so I put the jock on and then put on a comfy pair of jeans and a t-shirt.
He would be over soon.
We were very excited. We made out and shared a bong on the couch while lightly touching our hands and talking about what he might do to us.