It's pretty lengthy, and I tried to make it semi-realistic, even if convenient best friends like Holly are hard to come by. It was meant as a bit of fun for my boyfriend and I. It's a little silly in places, but in an ideal world this is how it would happen for me. :)
*
This is a story about a threesome, a first for all those involved. It features couple Lex and Dylan, and their conveniently gorgeous, bi-curious and single friend Holly.
Lex and Dylan had been together for several years, and they'd been friends with Holly for nearly as long. The two girls told each other pretty much everything, as girls will do. Holly told Lex all about her many adventures with various man-boys, and Lex told Holly about her most recent sexy discovery with Dylan, who was willing to try just about anything. They were never bored.
As is the nature of close female friendships, Lex and Holly were quite affectionate with one another. Hanging out inevitably involved hugging, play fighting and roping Dylan into it whenever possible. Lots of girls do this.
The group went swimming each week, and the girls often got a lot of odd looks as they posed on floats, had loud, giggly water fights and chased Dylan. Again, normal girl behavior. It annoyed everyone else in the pool but so did the other teens.
Here is where the trouble starts. Lex was very definitely bi, Holly was 'adventurous', and while she had never said so, it would've been a surprise if she wasn't willing to have a go with another girl, and Dylan...Dylan was a teenage guy, in a swimming pool with scantily clad girls, both of whom he knew swung both ways to some degree.
It didn't take a genius to work out there was a lot of tension here. Fun often appeared flirtatious, and affectionate often outright sexual. But everybody toed the line. Just. It's a wonder how it took so long to get to the 'hey, let's have a threesome' stage really.
Here was the problem. Lex had worked out she was bi and had been happy with that for a long time, but as she had a boyfriend it wasn't really a case of going out and flirting with girls until she got lucky. She needed someone that understood she was looking for fun, not a full time lesbian relationship, and they had to be cool with her boyfriend joining in. Difficult.
Holly had fun, with lots of different guys. She didn't shout about it, and so didn't get labeled a slut, and the guys didn't shout about it 'cos she was good at it. While it was a secret (for now) Holly had long wanted a see what being with a girl was like, even if just for fun. But you couldn't pull girls just for a good time like you could guys. And no matter how good she was, if she did pull a girl just for some fun, then the girl would be hurt, shout about it and Holly would forever more be labeled slut. Also difficult.
Dylan's problem was being pretty much powerless to shift things along in a situation where he could clearly see a threesome just waiting to happen. When you're the guy involved, you have to wait for the girls to get it together, otherwise he would look like he was pressuring his girlfriend, or it would look like he had been trying to come on to Holly behind Lex's back.
One of the girls had to be brave enough to stop pretending she didn't want to get off with the other. And then they had to get Dylan on board.
Naturally, this happened at swimming, after a particularly flirtatious session which involved swimming between each other's legs and having Dylan carry them both around. Eventually they got out of the pool, quiet and tired. The pool had male and female changing rooms, but within that divide they were open. The best sort.
The changing rooms were empty. As they slowly got dry and got their clothes out, Holly noticed Lex's eyes kept drifting over to her and the flashes of skin that appeared between towels and clothing. Holly didn't say anything, she did it too sometimes. All three of them tried not to in the pool, but on several occasions Holly had seen Dylan looking like he was trying very hard to look somewhere else. When they were tired afterwards, both girls found it a little harder not to stare.
Then it happened. Holly stopped pretending not to notice.
"Hey, I caught ya lookin'," said Holly quietly, smiling.
There was a pause, then Lex simply said "Maybe so." There was no denial or embarrassment, they both knew it to be true. But where from here?
"Why you looking?" Holly ploughed on, knowing that now the conversation had started it could not stop. If it did stop, the three of them would not be the same. If it didn't stop, the three of them still wouldn't be the same, but in a much better way. Stood there in her jeans and not much else, she didn't even bother to face away from Lex. There was no longer any need.
"Because... because you're gorgeous, Holly," said Lex bluntly. She didn't say anymore, in case she was going the wrong way. Although she had privately known before this was right, this was definitely going to happen, now she was actually in the situation, doubts filled her mind. That's always how it happens.
"You know, if you keep saying things like that we're gonna have to do something about it sooner or later," Holly said, trying to lead the conversation on faster. What if she was wrong? What if she read her wrong and Lex wasn't really interested at all?
"You know, I think we might have to. Now we're stood here gawping at each other half naked." Lex let her eyes wander over Holly's body for a few seconds, freely for once.
"Well, I'm glad we sorted that out," Holly said, relieved, "and I think Dylan will be too. Save him a lot of discomfort."
The girls laughed suddenly, both glad the really serious part was over. They turned away from each other and kept getting changed. Normal time resumed. They had said it without really saying it, but then again they didn't really need to.
"Um, I'm guessing you know this, but we need to be on the same wavelength really. You know I want Dylan to be involved, right?"
"Right. Makes two of us,"
"You know I'm not looking for anything long term, right?"
"Right. Long term isn't really me anyway, you know that."
"This will be our dirty little secret, right?"
"Damn right."
"Finally, you have a plan, right?"
"Ha, no. I'm as clueless as you are."
"I thought so somehow. We'll come up with something."
The girls picked up their bags and made for the door. Holly stopped suddenly, making Lex nearly run into her.
"Actually... I may have a plan," Holly said, lowering her voice, "so I would suggest you don't mention any of this to Dylan quite yet."
Lex made a 'hurry up' motion with her hands.
"Well, it's his birthday soon, right? How about we get him that threesome you said he wanted?"
