Mary was both the things you wanted in a girlfriend and those you would run away from. On the one hand, she was a gorgeous creature. As a member of the volleyball team, she had developed a butt to die for. Adrian had met Mary when she asked me to take her to one of her training sessions. In his own words, he liked her "because she looked innocent and horny". Truth is, she had been my first time when we finished high school, and my friend was not aware of that. Some time before, she had tricked me into getting drunk and given me her V-card in exchange for mine. That was Mary, the girl who would do whatever it took to get whatever she wanted.
When Mary's words made Adrian drop me on the bed, I woke up from a dream. My heart was racing as hell, and my ass was gaping painfully. Adrian reached out for the lights, only to find Mary sitting next to me on his bed, a can of beer on her left hand and a keyring on the other.
"Guys, you forgot I have a key to enter here!" Adrian was the palest I had ever seen him, and so I should have been. She was sporting that smile that she had used ever since we were children to let us know she had something evil in mind.
"Let me explain..." Adrian muttered as though those words had not been uttered over and over in many films forever. "We were just playing and..."
"You have been fucking each other since you returned from swimming," Mary interrupted. "I was here to ask you out, thinking of surprising you. However, the surprise was for me." My head was just inches from her lap, so she dragged me to rely on her as she went on. "Question is how long have you been having fun this way? Please don't tell me this is a night of firsts"
"Well, it... it is indeed," I stuttered, feeling the weirdest with my head on her lap. Her smooth tanned thigh was under my right cheek, making me realise she had come back from her volleyball training in the rain. I turned to look at her and her hair was still moist.
"Ok, let's say it was the first time," she murmured seductively in my ear. "Why should I keep it a secret, ladies?" Her sarcastic note let me know we had to bargain for something the quickest unless we wanted to be in trouble. At that precise moment, Adrian got his hand to his butt. My cum was slipping out of his anus and he had to deal with the evidence too. I extended my hand to caress Mary's face and had her look at me as I tried to divert her eyes from Adrian.
"What if you play with us?" I asked as nonchalantly as I could. That was the cue for Adrian to go back into the bathroom as I whispered carefully. "He still does not know I was your first. You are hurt, or offended; but you love him." Mary's eyes got fixed on mine as her mind raced to find an answer to my suggestion.
"I'll tell you what," she muttered, trying to keep it between us. "You both lose more than I do, although I don't want to destroy but to build." I looked into her eyes as she paused, sipping from the can and keeping me anxious. I cannot lie. I was very nervous, but I tried to seem calm enough to negotiate. "Finish what you were doing in front of me. Neither of you can touch me, but I will satisfy my curiosity." Mary paused as dramatically as she could, perhaps feeling it was a film, only to go into her grand finale. "Then, you will fuck me the way I ask you and having no objections."
I got mute as I was not sure what I was bargaining myself into. Mary and I had attended school together for 14 years and she was, somehow, one of my closest friends. However, she always seemed vicious and ready to hurt others. I needed to buy time for Adrian to leave the bathroom and make the call with me.
Nevertheless, my mind played a daring treat on me, having me imagine Mary's nipples as I had seen them in our only encounter, surrounded by chocolate areolae and crowning her perky globes. Unfortunately, my cock seemed to react too quickly and started growing. Mary noticed it (how could she not?) and ran her finger to my right nipple, rubbing it with the tip of her index as she confirmed.
"I see we have a deal," Mary sighed as she kissed the tip of my lips. Just a few seconds later, Adrian returned with a mortified expression in his face. His penis hung down, but beautiful for me. Mary pushed me up and commanded:
"Keep your word."
I got up the bed, my hard on waiting for pleasure and spread my legs for Adrian. He looked at us in puzzlement as Mary explained.
"You two finish what you were into. I look, I touch, but you do not touch me or complain," she started. "Once it is over, you both fuck me as I instruct. No questions, no refusals. We will seal a deal or I will spill the beans, starting with that gossip girlfriend of yours, Alain."
I looked at Adrian, wondering what he would say, and fearing Mary would break her deal. Adrian said nothing else, but knelt in front of me, trying to regain pleasure from kissing my cock. Still, he did not seem encouraged at all. Mary noticed it and stood up, standing behind him and bending to massage his shoulders. Adrian stopped touching me and leaned her head back against her lap.
Mary guided her hands to his nipples, rubbing them the way she had done that first time with me, massaging them with her thumbs. With her own weight, she led Adrian to lick my cock, which he evidently had never done. His mouth felt warm, but his teeth grazed the head of my cock more than once. However, Mary was there to rise moods.
I felt a slim appendage rubbing my anus, only to realise Mary had decided to help Adrian finish what he had started in the bathroom. She guided him to stand up as she kissed his back. Adrian was enjoying that, so I tried to help by grabbing his balls, and pleasuring them. My friend soon showed he was having a good time as I saw precum leaking out of his massive eight-incher. I was more than eager to taste him, but Mary had other plans for us and guided his cock straight into my ass.
Once again, I felt the tip of that gorgeous cock pleasuring my anus. How can I explain that sensation to someone who has never had a cock in the back door? It is not like a cold toy or vegetable. The smoothness of the head and the warmth it has is captivating indeed. I was not in a position where I could get more than what I was provided with my back on the bed and my legs already on his shoulders. Adrian had evidently tried better with Mary since he was more careful to open me than what I had been. He simply moved in circles, pushing his cock slowly as it reached my ring. The sensation was painful again, but he managed well to keep me safe.
Mary knelt behind him and reached for his ass, rimming him and occasionally licking his balls. However, the position and our rising momento did not allow her to do much more of that. Honestly, I wish there had been mobile phones back in those days to record every angle of that night. I can imagine Mary reaching for Adrian's ass, or his cock pushing into my ass. There is only one thing that I could see at that moment: Adrian's moment of bliss. His eyes were closed and that is when he slowly, but unstoppably moved inch by inch into me. He seemed to push one inch and withdraw half of it. My ring was burning, I could not do anything but close my eyes and imagine his cock into my ass. It is not easy to explain how something that painful can provide so much pleasure. Truth is, his cock was not as thick as mine, which I could only imagine as something more painful.
When I finally felt his hairy balls tickling my ass, I did not know if I wanted to have him in or out. It was Mary who brought me back to reality when I turned to look at her. I had thought she was still behind Adrian; instead, she had spent the previous minutes removing her volleyball shorts and whatever underwear she had been wearing along with her tennis shoes and socks. She climbed the bed on my left side and spoke for the first time in minutes.
"Well, baby, we are the way you wanted to be with my best friend (I get shocked)," she said. However, I came here to get well-fucked to release all the pain in my body after the training, so here is the thing: You will do to him what I wanted you to do to me; but I will get my pleasure from Alain. Then, he will have to do to me what you do to him."