The holidays were just around the corner, and Lisa absolutely loves to decorate. We had huge storage boxes full of garland, tree decorations, lights, shelf ornaments, tree ornaments, silly Santa hats, and a ton of other things, and she intended to use them all. Now, I love decorating too, but not to the extent she does. But it's Lisa. She's special, and I just can't refuse her.
I just finished with the house lights, and I came inside to find Lisa on the phone. She waved me over excitedly. "It's Rita!" she said cheerfully.
"Oh." I grinned. "Hey, hot stuff!" I called.
Lisa giggled. "She says, Hey Stud. Here, let me put you on speaker."
Lisa put the phone down between us on the couch. "So, you were saying?"
"Right. Well, let me start over for Willy. Hey stud brother!" she said again.
"Hey hot sister." I grinned. "Oh, that's so weird. You're my sister."
"In Law!" she shouted. "Don't leave that part out, or it's just weird." She huffed. "Well, okay. So, do you remember Christina from back in our day. She used to work at the Jager in Queens, remember?"
I thought back and nodded. "Oh, I think so. Tall redhead, big tits. Legs forever. Pretty face. On and off with Big Bob a lot, right?"
She giggled on the other end of the phone. "Geeze, she has a name too, asshole."
"Well, I never spent much time there." I scoffed. "But that's her, right?"
"Yup, that's me." Said another voice.
"Oh, shit." I groaned. "Rita, you bitch."
I heard laughter and Lisa joined in. "That was a good one, sis!" she giggled. "You should see his face. I didn't know he could blush like that."
"You and your sister." I groaned. "Bitch squared."
She stuck her tongue out at me.
"You live nearby, Christina?" Lisa asked.
"Call me Tina, and no. I still live in New York." She said. "I'm down for a conference in Orlando, and Rita invited me to visit while I was in the neighborhood."
"Nice!" Lisa smiled.
"So, anyway..." Rita continued. "Turns out the old gang are planning a big Holiday party in a couple weeks at the Jager."
"That place is still open?" I asked, a little surprised.
"Yep! Under new management." Tina said with a hint of pride I thought. "And we can have the place to ourselves on the thirteenth. That's a Wednesday."
"We can fly up together and share a hotel room." Rita chimed in quickly. "You know... to save a little money."
Lisa and I both waggled a brow at one another. "
"That would be perfect, Rita!" Lisa said eagerly.
I shrugged. "Sounds great. I've got some vacation time saved up." I said. "We can fly up on that Wednesday, spend the night there in the city, then maybe hit up Long Island to visit with Rich until Saturday, and fly back Sunday."
Lisa beamed at me. "Oh, could we? That sounds great. Think he'll have us?"
I scoffed. "Oh, I'm pretty sure."
She stifled a giggle.
"Awesome!" Tina said and Rita made a little squeak of excitement.
"How many are coming?" I asked.
"I'm hoping to see about forty of us from the original gang, and there are some new faces too." Tina replied. "Of course, not all will show, but still, it should be a nice crowd. Scott and Alex are really hoping you and Rita can make it."
"Scott and Alex Anderson?" Lisa asked tentatively.
"Yeah." Tina said. "They said you'd remember them."
Lisa smiled nervously at me. "Oh, yeah. I remember them."
"Great! They'll be really excited to hear you two are coming."
We chatted a bit more, made plans to meet, then said our good-byes and hung up.
"So, what's with Scott and Alex?" I asked.
Lisa balked at me. "What do you mean?"
"Come on." I smirked at her. "You know. That reaction you had when she mentioned them."
She smirked back at me. "You read me too well sometimes. You know that?" She huffed and sighed. "Okay, fine. You know I was dating Scott for a while."
"I didn't know, but okay." I said.
"Oh, well. It was like ten years ago. Anyway, umm... I sort of cheated on him... with Alex."
"His twin brother?" I lifted a brow. "But you were, what... fifteen? What was cheating at that age? Kissing?"
She rolled her eyes and blushed even brighter. "I, sort of... let him take my V card."
"Wait. So, you were dating Scott, but you lost your virginity to Alex?"
She sighed and nodded. "A heat of the moment thing." She said a little regretfully. "Scott was so pissed at Alex. Caused some bad blood between them for quite a while. He got over it eventually, but I still think about it."
"Wow." I sighed. "I always knew you were a heartbreaker, but damn."
She snickered and swatted the arm I had around her. "I was fifteen... just a kid. I had no idea what I was doing."
"How did it happen?" I asked.
She sighed deeply and made a little painful groan. "I was at their dorm when they were attending college, and we had some weed. Scott had a little too much and fell asleep, and Alex started making out with me. The next thing I knew, we were getting into some heavy petting, and he got my panties off. Right there in the same room with Scott as he slept. I just thought it was so scary and hot. Before I knew what we were doing, he was between my legs and I got my first."
"Same room." I shook my head and chuckled. "You ever do it again?"
She sighed and nodded. "I kept dating Scott for another month or so and fucked Alex every chance I got. I went with Scott to his basketball practice night, and while Scott was on the court, I pulled Alex into the locker room to give him head, and one of Scott's friends caught us." She sighed again and made another sad groan. "I wanted to be with Alex after that, but he felt bad about doing that to his brother, so he said we couldn't. At that age, I was really heartbroken."
"I guess that makes sense." I said. "Well, sort of. Will seeing them be a problem?"
She shook her head. "No, we all got over it." She said cheerfully. "It was years ago. I guess Scott and I might have a little unfinished business, but nothing to ruin a night. I'll be fine."
We left it at that and made plans for our trip up north.
We met Rita at the airport and boarded the same flight. It was quite fun as both girls were competitive flirting with me almost from the start. They had me sit in the middle seat, and they made a game of trying to dominate my attention. It was silly fun, but also a little exciting.
We got a cab from the airport and checked into our hotel with hours to kill. Once we got up to the room, Lisa launched herself onto the nearest bed and called "Dibs!"
Rita just rolled her eyes at me. "She's such a child." She giggled.
"I think I'll have a shower." Lisa said. "Give my hair time to dry."
"Works for me." Rita blew her a kiss. "Have fun."
Lisa looked at her sister, then at me, and winked. "You two have fun as well."
Rita gasped excitedly. "Really?"
Lisa nodded. "Really." She blew me a kiss. "Save some for me, baby."
I was a little shocked, but in a very good way. Rita shoved me down on the bed and was frantic to get my pants off. Then she wriggled out of her clothes and straddled me as we kissed.
My cock was not quite at full mast, so she gave it a little stroke with her hands and groaned.
"Oh, this won't do." She purred and slid down until she could take me in her mouth. She showed off her oral skills for a while, deepthroating my whole length with remarkable ease. After some time, I urged her to straddle my face so I could eat her while she sucked me.
A few minutes later, Lisa emerged from the bathroom, and made a little moan as she saw us going at it. "Hey, slut." Lisa said in mock indignation. "That's my husband you're sucking!"
Rita slurped her lips off my cock and flashed her a smile. "Yes, and he's delicious."
Lisa dried off, then hopped up on the bed with us. "If you're going to fuck my sister, I want to watch." She said softly.
I let her direct the action from that point, and she got Rita to spoon with me as I fucked her on her side. Lisa enjoyed the show and rubbed her pussy as she watched. Rita climaxed soon after. Then Lisa shoved her sister aside so she could mount me and rode my cock until she came as well. It all happened so fast, I hardly recalled much in the details. Two hot girls. Great sex. That was about all my mind registered.
We lay on the bed a while, joking about what a strange family we made, but what a sexy thing it was that I could fuck a pair of such hot sisters. They seemed to like that, and they took turns sucking my cock until I groaned out my orgasm all over Rita's face. She wiped some with her finger, licked it clean, then wiped more and stuck her finger into Lisa's mouth with a giggle.
"Well, now I really need a shower!" Rita got up and I got to watch her adorable little ass wiggle away into the bathroom.
Lisa snuggled with me a while, and we kissed and touched and talked about nothing in particular. In a lull of talk, I asked, "Do you think Scott will be okay with tonight?"
"Like I said," Lisa assured me, "it was a long time ago."
I shrugged. "I don't know. Ten years wouldn't be nearly enough to get over you."
"Oh, baby! That's so sweet. But it'll be fine." She sighed. "What about you?" She asked. "Will us sharing a room with my sister be too weird for you?"
"Probably." I nodded. "But I should be able to keep track of which of you I'm fucking."
She giggled and leaned over to kiss me. "Good." She rolled out of bed and started to dress.
When Rita emerged from the bathroom, she was using her towel to dry her hair, leaving the rest of her naked and lovely. She walked by me, pausing to give me a kiss. "Thanks for the quickie." She winked. "Maybe when we get back tonight, you can give me and my sister a proper screwing?"
"Hey!" I gave her bottom a little spank and snickered. "You spoiled my surprise!"
She smiled brightly. "Great minds think alike."
I hurried through my shower so as not to miss too much, and it was worth it. Lisa was still in the green panties from her lace lingerie set she wore for me once before. They were crotchless, and I could see her bald pussy as she continued brushing out her hair with a blow dryer. Rita was still topless in just a tiny thong, as she laid out her dress on the ironing board. They were spoiling me with too much to feast my eyes on.