You should first read Payson's original story and my Chapter 2 continuation. Payson's original is less than two pages long. I plan to post this before I see Chapter 2 on Literotica, but I assume my Chapter 2 is about four - five pages long.
**********
Andrew
Liz called on my cell. I was a bit surprised. We did not have a house phone, I knew Amy had talked to her about swapping and swinging, and I assumed Liz would call Amy's cell. After my brief greeting, Liz whispered, "Can you talk?" Amy wasn't home, so I answered, "Yes, I'm alone and ready to talk." I said it loudly enough so Liz would know I was probably alone. She quickly got to the point by telling me they were 90% "all in." Incongruous? I asked her what she meant. She responded, "Phil and I have talked. He's out of town until Friday and we'd like to have a sit down with you and Amy to talk about the rules and some other things he and I will think through before he gets home. Once we are a little more comfortable with where this is going, we'll be all in. Her voice returned to a whisper as she added, "Between you and me, I'm already 100% all in. I'm just humoring Phil. Why don't you have Amy give me a ring and we'll set a time." Before ending my side of the conversation, I said, "I'll tell Amy." I hesitated, then added, "Liz, I'm really looking forward to you being all in." She giggled and disconnected.
Amy called Liz and they worked out the details -- it was to be a clothing required meeting. That meeting turned out to be no big deal. Phil asked most of the questions. They weren't much different from the things Amy and I had discussed before we started partying. Amy was able to answer some of the questions, based on things she and Penny had already discussed. When Phil said, "We're all in," we started discussing the rules -- no anal for moi -- and planning our first party. Everyone opted for "the sooner, the better" choice. I suggested the next night, Saturday, and glanced at Amy. She nodded as Phil asked, "Can you be ready that soon. We don't want to impose." I was in rare form as I replied, "Swapping and swinging parties are never an imposition and we can be ready in about 23 seconds." I was looking at Amy's attire as I said "23 seconds." Phil asked Liz if she could find a sitter on such short notice. Liz nodded and then asked what they could bring. I knew Amy had bought plenty of new towels so I let her handle that conversation with Liz.
Lauren called Amy on Saturday morning. After trading information regarding Lauren's conversation with Penny, Penny's with Amy, ours with Liz and Phil, etc., Amy switched to speakerphone and told Lauren I was also "on the line." Lauren started asking Amy some basic questions, when I interrupted by piping up, "We're partying with the Scotts tonight. You and Fred are welcome to watch if the Scotts agree." Amy yelled,"Shut up" at me, but she was smiling. Lauren declined my invitation. Lauren eventually signed off by adding, "I want to talk with Liz after you guys get together. And, strange as it may sound to you, I want to talk to Fred's ex-wife too." That was surprising, but I assumed Lauren thought she had the kind of relationship with the ex allowing them to have such a conversation. Amy and I gave each other high-5's At this rate, we'd soon be renting out the old armory building!
**********
Amy
Andrew and I spent a little time Friday evening getting the house ready for the next night. We don't leave messes so it wasn't a big deal. I had some Saturday appointments, but I resolved to avoid any for that night. Unless they were really, really important. I was NOT going to be the one responsible for Liz and Andrew missing their first screw-a-thon. Having seen Phil's wet swimming suit-induced bulge, I was a bit anxious to see how my night would turn out.
Phil wasn't a wine drinker, so they had volunteered to bring plenty of stuff for rum and cokes and gin and tonics. Andrew and I agreed we needed to watch each other so we didn't drink too much. This shouldn't turn into an all-you-can-eat buffet. The party was for a different kind of partying. Phil and Liz were obviously apprehensive when they arrived. Phil appeared to have been drinking. Andrew took charge of the situation by taking the drink stuff, while saying to Phil, "It looks like you've gotten a head start; why don't I make three drinks so we can catch up?" Phil had no comeback. We gave Andrew our drink orders and sat in the great room to get more comfortable and prepared for the festivities.
Phil seemed to be less at ease than at any time I could remember. That seemed a bit strange. I gave it a little thought and concluded, if the rumors were true, he did his thing by picking up strange out-of-town women or by seducing discrete married women closer to home. He had trained himself to do those things. This was new to him. He may have participated in group sex before, but assuredly not with his wife and friends. I was interested to see how he reacted to the things Liz and Andrew did. I guess part of my good wife role was to keep Phil distracted enough that he couldn't be too jealous.
My G & T went down way too smoothly. Patience. Liz and I had already discussed girl-on-girl. That was not on her list of things she'd do. I told her I would never press the issue, but I suggested she watch girl-on-girl action in some mild porno movies. I also pointed out she'd likely witness some when we started having larger parties. She and I had decided to begin this party with our clothes on while we danced slowly with our temporary partner. Andrew had selected the music. I knew it would be perfect. It was. The four of danced like two high school couples who planned to have a good time at Prom, but were also antsy to get on with the after-dance nudity.
I glanced at Liz and Andrew. They had their arms wrapped tightly around each other while their lips were locked together. Liz was really pushing her tummy into Andrew's rager. The way they were starting I suspected they would be expressing and displaying their pent-up feelings for each other. Hell, it might resemble something akin to romance, maybe love. I was ready for their physical activities; their emotional activities, however, might be too much. Can't worry about that now. Now is the time for Phil and me to give each other what we want. I gave Phil my best lip lock. I'm not sure whose tongue got into whose mouth first. It could have been a tie, or, at the very least, too close to call.
I started undressing Phil, and he, me. Andrew or Liz noticed and they began to follow suit. I had to occasionally watch. Predictably, they both did it lovingly and gently touched and stroked each other's body as they did. Once naked, they continued to dance while I dropped to my knees and sucked most of Phil's cock into my mouth. No, it wasn't huge. Andrew, Robert, and Phil packed about the same kind of equipment. Phil threw back his head and groaned. We were off to the races!
**********
Andrew
God! My first time naked and virtually alone with Liz! I think I can now write a book about what heaven must be like. I suspected Amy had a pretty good idea how strongly I felt about Liz. It was like, "If anything ever happens to Amy....." Did I covet my friend's wife? Yes, but, in all fairness, I considered Liz a much better friend than Phil. It didn't make much difference because, for now, they were a couple and I knew I would never cheat on Amy. We continued dancing, kissing, and caressing. I whispered to Liz, "Are you alright?" In response, she cooed, "Couldn't be better." I continued the soft talk with, "I don't mean to sound crude, but I'll check in with you from time to time to see if you have, in fact, become better." She sighed, relocked her lips on mine, and removed one of her hands from behind my neck. An instant later, I felt a softly firm grip on my dick. I sighed.
I told Liz I was planning on lots of soft and gentle, but she was at her first party and I wanted to give her anything she wanted. She gave my cock another squeeze and asked, "Where do you want to lie down together?" I wasn't thinking about Amy and I hoped Liz was not thinking about Phil. I didn't even want to glance at the other two. Liz and I lay on the carpet and continued kissing while we caressed each other. Some of that touching was sexual, but mostly it was sensual. We also spent considerable time looking into each other's eyes and smiling. When I occasionally came out of my trance-like state, I thought Phil might yell at me because I wasn't fucking his wife. All in good time, my friend. All in good time.
I wanted quality, not necessarily quantity, with Liz. We twisted our bodies, staying on our sides, and eased into a comfortable 69. After a bit it seemed to me Liz was not skilled in the art of deepthroating. No biggie. She was giving me fantastic head with her tongue and she'd occasionally take about half of me into her mouth. Additionally, she was using both hands to the utmost. Her bush was appropriately trimmed to stay contained in her briefest swimming bottoms. I softly used my tongue, lips, and fingers to explore every part of her nether regions. Once, I took a lubricated finger and pressed it against her anus. She tensed and squeezed my cock. I had no intention of entering her sacred place, so I quickly removed my finger and she relaxed her grip on my long boy. I made a mental note to ensure I told her I was sorry for the anal surprise and I hadn't planned on going any further. Lesson learned, if the rules aren't clear, ask first.