Author's Note: This is my first piece and its taken a lot of input and encouragement from some very special friends to finally publish it. Your comments and feedback are really appreciated!
Special thanks to Sam and Erin for their time editing.
Finally, Chris, you rock my world.
----
I turned the corner, walking down the street towards the bar we agreed on.
I had chosen my clothes with care, a short but otherwise fairly innocent looking sundress with a little tie around my waist, hoping to show off my curves. We had exchanged photos the night before so I was fairly certain I would recognize him when I saw him
I definitely recognized the nervous butterflies in my stomach. It had been so long since I had experienced anything resembling a "first date" that I was feeling a little apprehensive I wouldn't impress. As I walked to meet this stranger I met online, I squeezed my husband's hand. He squeezed mine back.
I did in fact see Alex first, recognizing him immediately. He was about my husband's height and build, but his hair and eyes were dark compared to Chris's blonde hair and blue eyes. Both the men had on short sleeve button down shirts and shorts, both in their mid 20's like me. I stood in the middle in my little red sundress, my ginger hair left down because Alex had specifically said he loved the color.
I gave Alex a hug, feeling my stomach flip from our first contact and introduced him to my husband. We all stood there for a beat; he knew this was strange. We felt strange. We shared a nervous laugh.
I took a breath and turned to the bar, noticing for the first time that no lights were on. This place was known for being open early, even at 11 am when we had agreed to meet, but it looked closed this morning. Maybe they were off for Labor Day? I felt a little moment of panic that this would ruin any chance of...anything, but the boys weren't as concerned. Chris suggested we start down the next street. Something had to be open for lunch.
As luck would have it, the pizza place with a nice bar was open and serving. We all sat at the bar and ordered a beer. I finished mine quickly, letting the bubbles tickle my throat and drown my nerves. No one wanted any food; we passed the time talking about our jobs, our interests. Minutes flew by as we laughed, all leaning towards each other.
I left to use the bathroom, giving my husband some alone time with this stranger, letting him get a sense of how they felt about each other. Alex had assured me he was interested in us both but they deserved some time to see if they had any chemistry.
I washed my hands and dabbed them on my collar before drying them. My cheeks were flushed, my eyes bright. I smiled at my reflection in the mirror, taking a moment for myself to consider how well everything had gone thus far with our first meeting, excited to see where it would lead.
I came back to the bar to see the men sitting close, smiling.
Chris took his turn going to the restroom, as if he knew why I had left and was giving me the same chance. I probably blushed, sitting down at the bar with a man who wasn't my husband but still on a "date" with me. Who knew that the other patrons were thinking, maybe they just saw a group of friends catching up.
Maybe they saw a slut who was meeting a stranger at a bar with her husband to arrange a threesome. I started to get fidgety.
Though my nerves were getting to me, Alex was blessed with boldness that day. He confidently put his hand on my knee and squeezed, smiling at me. I relaxed some, asking if we could leave soon to see if the other bar was open and he agreed. He paid the tab, insisting that he always pays on the first date.
But then the skies opened up, so by the time Chris had returned and we were ready to go it was pouring. The three of us were stranded under the small outside awning, thinking about our vehicles parked several blocks away.
Alex struck a smile, asking if we were up for the adventure. I felt in that moment that I would wade through a literal river to earn that smile again, and though I wasn't looking forward to running through sheets of cold rain, I agreed happily. We dashed through the rain, turning corners and splashing through puddles, the boys shaking water from their hair when we reached a crossing. My dress had definitely suffered the most, clinging to me everywhere. The cold water chilled me, pebbling my nipples and making them stand out through the wet fabric.
Suddenly my "innocent" clothing choice was pretty revealing. Oddly enough, it made me feel bolder.
Instead of going to another bar, I bluntly asked if Alex wanted to come back to our place. He said yes, immediately, but wanted to change his clothes. We agreed to split up and meet again at our house, about 20 minutes outside of the city.
Back at home my husband helped pick my second outfit. A pair of high waisted drawstring shorts made of a thin gauzy cotton, a cut off white t-shirt, and my pale purple lace bralette with a matching thong. The overall effect was casual with a layer of sexy hidden underneath, if anything more happened.
Alex arrived not long after, also having changed into casual shorts and a t-shirt, looking much drier than before. I played hostess and showed him the whole house, then we gathered in our living room.
We sat on the couch together to watch some uninteresting movie, agreeing it seemed like an easy way to relax together. I was in the middle, my husband Chris on my right side, and Alex on the left. I started with my hands tucked in my lap shyly and it evoked the memory of sitting next to a cute boy at the movies. Had I developed any courage since 7th grade? Would I extract my nervous hands from the vise grip between my thighs this time?
I snuck a peek at Alex out of the corner of my eye and saw he was completely turned to face me, ignoring the movie, leaned against the arm of the couch and smiling knowingly. I flashed my eyes at Chris, and he glanced at me with a smile, but turned back to the movie. I blew out all the hot air that I had been holding in and bravely stretched my hands out to lay one on each of their knees.
Settling my hands on two warm knees from two different men, I flexed my fingers to let them lay comfortably. My thumb rubbed in light circles on one leg, though I can't recall now who I was caressing. From there it wasn't nearly as daunting to slide my hands up their thighs, and then further. My fingers brushed lightly through soft leg hair as I explored. With Chris, my husband, my hand found his shaft through his shorts easily, familiar and semi hard, but responsive as always to my touch. I wrapped my hand around him and gave a gentle, loving squeeze as he started to swell.
With Alex, this new man, I just let the back of my hand rub against his bulge. Simply grazing his hard cock, I continued to fondle my husband and reveled in the new sensations. Chris's cock twitched and I knew then that he realized what I was doing, sandwiched between the two of them and touching them. Alex stretched behind me to rest his arm across my shoulders. I leaned against him, my other hand continuing to lightly stroke Chris.
Alex reached up and cupped the back of my neck, squeezing gently with his large hand, absolutely melting me. My head tipped back into his hand, and he tilted me towards him. He was looking at me with such lust, his dark pupils huge. My heart started beating harder and my thoughts started getting fuzzy.
I wanted to kiss him - I hadn't felt that way about another man in years. I sat up, and kissed Chris instead, trying to tell him through that kiss that Yes, I wanted this, more than anything, and I was ready. He broke from my lips and nodded towards Alex, who had been watching us closely. I turned my entire body towards this strange new man and pressed my chest against his, cupping his face gently with my hand before kissing him. I could feel myself shaking gently with nerves and adrenalin. Our lips met and it felt very...wrong at first. Unfamiliar. Alien.
We kept testing the waters, exploring each other until we found a rhythm that worked for us both. I felt his tongue slide against my lips and I pressed against him harder, wanting to be closer. He gently held my hair, tangling his fingers in the curls and rubbing them like strands of silk. Sinking into the corner of the couch, torso to torso, we let our bodies fulfill the lust filled promises we had exchanged over heated texts. When we broke for air I turned to Chris, exuberant, primed to laugh and say something stupid or funny as is my reaction when passion is high.
When I did though, he brushed past me and kissed Alex, who had already started moving towards him once our lips parted.