I'm Jon, a relatively average boy from upstate New York. I've got dirty blonde hair, broad shoulders and a relatively small dick unless I get a hard on. Despite having been really shy especially around girls, I've been getting pretty lucky lately.
Despite my newly formed unhealthy relationship with my sister, and my less taboo one with my friend's older sister, I unexpectedly was a romantic interest for two of my friends who just happened to be twin sisters.
I mean really, when would I meet an only child who was interested in me? Just kidding, I didn't care as long as I was getting some, and boy was I.
The twins were really hot, one excelled at many things and the other always tried to one-up her, so there was a bit of competition between them. For example, Sylvie would get her ears pierced and Goldie would get double the amount of piercings, or Sylvie would get an A and Goldie would make sure to get that A+.
Anyway, apparently the twin sisters had both had crushes on me since middle school and at that time I think the feeling was mutual, but I was too shy and oblivious to that sort of thing, so I was a bit taken aback when they both confessed to me during the same week.
My reply to the first sister, Sylvie, was simple: "I like you too, let's hang out this weekend." However, when her twin, Goldie, confessed, I had to admit that I had already told her sister that I liked her, but that I really liked both of them. Either way I could never have predicted what would happen next.
The following day while I was opening my locker, I saw one of them walking in my direction down the hall after classes had ended, then the other appeared from behind her, and they were wearing identical outfits: black long sleeve T's with white striped sleeves, denim vests and denim skirts over black stockings, accompanied by leather boots.
Not to mention their mirrored hairstyles, platinum blonde straight layered bobs with side swept bangs, each with their namesake's highlights; silver for Sylvie and rose gold for Goldie.
Boy did I think I was in trouble, watching them approach me with their ice blue eyes highlighted by their dark eyeshadow. I considered whether this would be a scene from a horror flick or a male fantasy, I guess I was hoping for the latter.
"We've discussed it." they said in eerie unison.
"Actually, we've always talked about you and how cute you were." Goldie added, eliciting a sigh from Sylvie.
"It's true, and we don't see why we can't share you on a date." Sylvie suggested.
"At least until you decide on whom you like better." Goldie said with a wink.
"Oh, um, alright by me." I said in my apparent shock at the idea of going on a date with two girls at once. Despite having had sex before, this would actually be my first real date.
"So, we're going to dinner and a movie tonight, pick us up at 6, the movie's at 8." Goldie instructed.
Sylvie rolled her eyes and told me "Don't be late for our first date."
They blew me a couple kisses and left as I grabbed my stuff from my locker. I drove home, showered off the smell of PE and school, and then picked out some basic clothes, jeans, an undershirt and a light grey long-sleeved henley T. After getting ready for my date, I felt nervous about what would happen because I had no idea about anything and I didn't want to hurt my friends. My mind wondered as I drove to pick them up, I suggested a nice restaurant, but they insisted on a local diner which was ok with me.
"Shotgun!" Goldie called out playfully, while still being deadly serious about it though as she rushed into my car to claim the passenger seat.
Sylvie shook her head at her sister as she walked slowly to the car and I opened the door and moved my seat forward so she could get in, and I caught a slight sign of jealousy from Goldie as she glared.
"Thank you, Jon." Sylvie said with a smile.
"No problem." I replied.
Goldie took charge of the conversation which meandered through topics, such as when I might get a new car, and other simple stuff, but that changed a bit once we were at the diner and it seemed they were getting more competitive.
Both gave me compliments and asked about my interests and likes trying to steer them towards themselves, but I didn't want to fall into any traps, so I did my best to entertain them both equally. However, Sylvie definitely appeared to be my preference as I tried to include her more while Goldie made sure to include herself in every part of the conversation.
Since we knew each other pretty decently, conversation became more about thoughts and secrets. Some things learned included the fact that none of us were virgins anymore, and none of us were really interested in committing to long term relationships right before starting college and whatnot.
I couldn't help but smile at them sitting beside each other, across the table from me. Then, seemingly out of the blue, both began to play footsies with me, each rubbing one of their stocking-clad feet on my legs, their toes finding the hem of my pant leg and sliding it up to caress my bare skin. I stretched my legs towards them, as my dick began to grow in excitement at the illicit activity.
My phone vibrated, it was a text from my sister. "Oh, shit, we should go." I said flashing them the time on my phone screen, the movie would be starting in a few minutes.
"Ok, let's go." they said together as I threw money on the table and we slid out of the booth. I tried to inconspicuously hide the bulge in my jeans as we left and got into my car, luckily the cinema was in the shopping plaza across the street, so I got out and let them both out my door and closed it.
I held the door open for them as they happily walked in and I went up to buy the tickets while they waited. Fuck, Bridget, my friend's sister that I've fucked was working here, I had had no idea. Awkwardly, I said "Hi, um, I think I'm here on a date, is that ok?"
Bridget giggled, "Yeah, of course, we only role-play when we're alone, right?"
"Yeah, I guess." I smiled back.
"So, two?" she asked.
"Actually, three." I said and Bridget looked behind me at Goldie and Sylvie conversing with each other.
