It Could Have Been Anyone - Pt. 4
By Cal Bishop
Author's Note
The previous two chapters each picked up where the one before it left off, but this one is different: it overlaps with the one before it. We'll get Ben's perspective on the party here, Alicia finally finding out who she spent the night with, and everyone's experiences the morning after.
One question for readers in the comments: If this wasn't in the Group Sex category, what would it be? Future chapters follow Ben and Alicia, but not necessarily all other characters, or even any other characters. Plain old Erotic Coupling? Loving Wives, given that there are established couples and sex taking place outside them? Does the prominence of blindfold use make it BDSM, Fetish, or something else?
In the Basement
For Ben, an exciting sex life had been simply the sort of thing that happened to other people.
He lost his virginity a week after his eighteenth birthday with his longtime high school girlfriend. That relationship lasted until about three weeks after they started college in different states. He had only two girlfriends between her and Alicia, eight years later, neither relationship lasting very long. Until Alicia.
Alicia was very sexy, with long, flowing light brown hair, breasts that made a pleasant handful with nipples that came to a point easily, and curvy hips she worked hard to keep in shape. They had even used the L-word a few times, but if Ben had one concern, it was her unwillingness to or simply lack of interest in experimenting sexually. She would just laugh or grimace if he suggested anything racier than sex in bed with the lights off. In this she was like his exes, so he didn't think anything of it. He knew his friend Gene and Gene's wife Vivian were more adventurous, even kinky, but the time never seemed right to ask about it.
But he was forced to deal with it when he suggested Gene and he swap costumes at a Halloween party, and Gene wound up having wild, primal sex with Alicia. Ben was surprised to find out how much he liked watching that, and began to consider the possibility of having that sort of lifestyle with Alicia, if he could persuade her to try it out without using costumes.
When she put a blindfold on and said he could have anyone he wanted fuck her, he realized he had succeeded beyond his wildest dreams. He decided to do it himself, in midair in a sex swing, with eight more people in the room, although most of them were distracted by their own pleasure or that of their partner.
The room had swiftly become a lust-swamped orgy. Gene and Vivian, the hosts, were taking turns giving "John" (everyone was wearing masks, and everyone but the hosts were using aliases) a blowjob as he sat on the couch. Ben (going by "Jack" for the night; Alicia was "Sarah") had been told in passing that Gene had a bisexual side, but even so he was a little surprised to see Gene go to town like that on another man. Gene seemed into it even more than Vivian did; as he watched, Vivian stood up and started making out with John, tangling her hands in Gene's hair as his head bobbed on John's cock.
"Jim" and "Susie", a married couple who Ben understood were new to these parties, were fucking on the bed, Susie riding Jim's cock, while they both talked dirty with "Curt" and "Stephanie." Curt had just had a handjob (from Alicia!) and Stephanie had just had a moaning orgasm from Vivian going down on her, but they were each masturbating the other leisurely, and with the sights and conversation they were enjoying, Ben suspected they'd be ready for more soon.
The only person in the room not indulging in their own carnal desires was "Shawna," a beautiful woman with chocolate skin, frizzy hair, and red lingerie, and even she wasn't just watching. As Ben first entered Alicia on the swing, Shawna pinched his butt devilishly. As Alicia moaned, Shawna walked around her legs and whispered something in her ear; something good, judging by her grin and Alicia's moans, but Ben didn't know the details. Then she returned to him and kissed him eagerly, hungrily, standing to the side, almost behind him, not standing between him and Alicia.
He caressed Shawna's tit with one hand while the other held Alicia's hip in place. Shawna gasped and gripped as he pinched her nipple gently, embracing him with one arm while fingering herself with the other.
Ben thrust harder, more wildly, using Alicia and Shawna for his pleasure at the same time, overcome by the lust throughout the orgy, a situation he had gone from barely believing in to being in the middle of in mere minutes. "Don't stop! Don't stop," Alicia moaned.
He broke his kiss. "I'm going to cum soon," he whispered to Shawna. "She'd probably want to know."
Shawna agreed. She slid out of his arms and walked around Alicia's leg to speak in her ear again.
"He's close to cumming too," Shawna said, her eyes on Ben's the whole time, twinkling. "Do you want him to cum in you? He's not wearing a condom..." she intoned.
"Yes, Yes, yes, I already said he could fuck me however he wanted, just don't stop now, not now, keep fucking me!" Alicia cried wantonly.
"You heard her," Shawna said, and he resumed pounding Alicia's pussy, focusing both of them entirely on their animal urges.
"Oh god oh god oh god!" Alicia squealed as they both came.
He stepped back, staggering, his cock still hard but spent for now. "Can someone help me down?" Alicia asked.
"Oh, sure," Ben said.
Then they relaxed, basking in the afterglow just like back home, except for the fact that they were in a room with eight other people and the only piece of clothes between them was her blindfold. She seemed pleasantly surprised to find that it had been Ben.
He was relieved that Alicia had gone through with trying something wild, and even more importantly, enjoyed it. He was a tiny bit worried about what might come next. Everything he had seen so far tonight looked awesome, and he loved the idea of trying it, but in his post-coital relaxed clarity, he had to admit that a million things could still go wrong.
Just because she liked me fucking her with people watching, liked the idea of doing it with someone else, doesn't mean she'd actually be okay with it
, he thought.
Would she actually have a threesome, like Vivian, Curt, and Stephanie over there? I've asked to try something like that before and she just laughed
.
He got up to get them drinks. When he got back, Shawna had joined them. She let him sit next to Alicia but stayed on the couch, not exactly joining their conversation but not giving them privacy either.
"So how are you feeling?" Ben asked.
"Amaaaaazing," Alicia said, leaning back into his shoulder again. "I don't believe we did that and I don't believe how good it felt!" she leaned over and puckered up for a kiss. He found her lips. She snuggled closer to him as she kept talking. "I thought you were crazy suggesting we go to this, or just being careless about trying to get some stupid porn fantasy fulfilled, but I have to admit, I'm glad we came. To the party."
"I told you so!" he sang. "Ow!"
"Oh come on, I barely touched you," she said. "This time. Consider it a warning."
He chuckled, and so did his neighbor on the other side.
"Do you want to play around with someone else?" Alicia asked. "You know, I might have been OK with it before I even gave Curt that handjob. Everything seems so open here, it's just... different."
He answered casually and continued to make small talk, but his mind was racing.
Anyone? Shawna here, if she was interested. Vivian. I've wondered about her before, snuck glances at her cleavage, and now I wouldn't even have to be sneaky about it. That could be me in the bed there under her instead of Curt...
His cock stirred as he thought about wishes that might be fulfilled tonight. Before he had come to a decision, Stephanie approached. She had got just finished her activity with Curt. She wasn't wearing even lingerie or a robe, just casual in her nakedness, and leaned over him, bringing her breasts enticingly close. She whispered in his ear, "You think your date would like if it I went down on her?"
Ben almost laughed in glee at the thought of it, but restrained himself, not wanting to tip Alicia off. He addressed Alicia carefully. "Wow. Uh, honey, this is interesting. Would you like someone to go down on you?"
She blushed. "Thanks for the offer, but I'm still kind of sore from my session in the swing. I'm not up for sex any time soon."
"I'll bet I can change her mind," Stephanie whispered. "I'll be gentle."
"I don't think you have to worry about that," Ben said out loud. "I'm pretty sure this offer does not come with the intent to have intercourse with you. In fact, it might be a sort of 'kiss to make it better' sort of thing."
"Seriously?" Alicia asked. "Well, OK, if he really wants to, I guess we can try that. Thanks."
Ben stood to make room. Alicia scooted forward to give her mystery partner easier access. Ben took a deep breath involuntarily as he watched someone else sink their face into his girlfriend's pussy for the first time, pleasure her in ways only he had in years, watched her enjoy a woman's intimate touch for the first time ever, and without even knowing it!
But she figured out her lover's gender soon enough, and if she had any qualms, they were clearly overwhelmed. He watched as she recovered from her surprise and was soon moaning and squealing as Stephanie expertly teased her pussy. When Stephanie led her to the bed, she accepted as if in a trance. Ben followed and sat on the stairs, facing the bed, with a perfect view between Stephanie's legs, fascinated by what Alicia was doing for and with her.
He vaguely noticed Vivian saunter over to him, smiling, a smoldering sexpot and happy to flaunt it. But he was so engrossed in his girlfriend and her new lover, Vivian didn't get Ben's attention until standing right in front of him. Her bodysuit had been lost somewhere along the way, so he was eye level with her bellybutton. He looked up, aiming for her face, and got stuck partway.
"Ben," she purred, "Are you really going to just watch this?" She put one hand on his shoulder and gently reached between his legs with the other, feeling his dick, now partway erect despite what he'd done just minutes before, and gently, lazily stroked it. As she did so, she leaned forward, kissed him, and then asked, "Wouldn't you rather watch it while someone sucks your cock?"
"Fuck yeah," he breathed.
"Great! Then come on over here," Vivian said, curling a figure to beckon him. That might not have got him to stand on its own, but the twist of her hips showing off the curve of her ass did the trick.
