Jay and I were sitting around his house one night, tipping back a few cold ones and watching the game. We'd done this hundreds of times before. We had been friends since grade school and this was not a scene that was new to us. We'd shared our hopes and dreams. We'd shared our feelings and experiences. I thought we had shared just about everything. I was to find out this wasn't exactly the case.
As the night progressed, and the game came to an end, the drinks and conversation began to flow, maybe even a little more liberally than normal. As Jay flipped through the channels to find something else to watch, he happened upon a Skinimax movie that looked like it was shot 30 years ago. OK, so even though the women all had big hair and high-waisted panties, I don't know too many guys in our condition that wouldn't stop to take a look.
On screen, a smoking hot blonde girl with oversized implants and feathered hair was having simulated sex with some dude while her husband watched anxiously from the corner. It must have been called "Voyeuristic Fantasies 5" or something. I didn't think much about it and focused my inebriated eyes in on the woman's jiggling breasts.
"I almost did that one time." Jay said nonchalantly.
"What, fuck a girl in the 80's" I said facetiously.
We both graduated high school in the late 80's and although we weren't exactly Tom Selleck or Kevin Bacon.
"No, watch another guy fuck MaryEllen." he said with all seriousness.
MaryEllen had been Jay's girlfriend for 3 years. She was a shy, unassuming girl with an ordinary face and a mound of black curly hair. She was the type of girl that you might just walk by on the street without giving a second glance. But if you did give her that second glance, you'd notice that 5'9" tight body girl included smallish but nicely rounded tits, long lithe legs and a beautiful ass that were better suited on a swimmer's body.
I didn't know MaryEllen well. It was hard to know MaryEllen well. She was the epitome of the quiet bookworm. Pensive, reserved and subdued. Having said all that, it was that hair that always always gave me the impression that she might have a wild streak. It was dark, curly and wild. It seemed to have a mind of its own.
MaryEllen seemed almost prudish...there's no way could be into this type of thing, I told myself.
Apparently that wasn't the case. I pressed on.
"Oh yeah," I said, trying to hide my interest and the quickly growing bulge in my pants, "how did that happen?" I didn't want to seem too eager to go down this road. We were talking about his girlfriend after all. I tried to show a little decorum.
"Well, we were on our trip (Jay and MaryEllen had taken a 6 month driving tour of the US a couple of years ago) and staying with Scott (a mutual friend). I had always had a fantasy of getting MaryEllen fuck another guy. One night, I tried to convince her to go into Scott's room while he was sleeping, slip into bed with him and fuck him."
I was floored...but veru interested. I took a long sip of my beer as he continued, trying to will my dick to an unnoticeable level of attention.
"I almost got her to do it too, but she kept thinking Scott would freak out and it would be a bad scene."
"So was she was into it?" I inquired...not so innocently.
"Oh yeah, she's totally into the idea. She's actually a bit of a freak." he assured.
Now, I know a lot of guys have the fantasy of seeing their woman with another man, but it's slightly different to hear it first hand from your friend. It's pretty surreal. I certainly had more than one sexual thought about MaryEllen, but since she was my best friend's girl, I would quickly suppress these fantasies. This conversation seemed to have thrown all of those self-imposed boundaries to the wind.
"So, what gave you this idea in the first place?" I found myself interested in the motives that went along with this fantasy.
"I don't really know how it started." he said "I think it's a mental thing I guess. The thought of her receiving pleasure and at the same time pleasing one of my friends...I guess it's a turn-on."
I could understand that, I guess. At least that's what I told myself.
"I think the jealousy factor heightens the fantasy because you have conflicting feelings."
OK, I could buy that. I guess.
I would be lying if I told you I was thinking of anything at the time other than impaling MaryEllen on my dick, but I played along.
"So, you never wemt through with it?" I asked, loving where the conversation was going.
"No, we never really got the chance after that. Too bad really, I know she's really into the idea, but it just didn't work out." he said with more than a little regret in his voice.
There was an awkward pause as we both lingered on the unusual conversation between two longtime friends.
"Too bad you didn't say anything sooner, I would have fucked her."
The crassness of my comment cut straight through to the point. Under normal circumstances I would have been a little more diplomatic but the beer and the thought of MaryEllen sucking my cock must have affected my verbal filter.
With that, and a little chuckle from Jay, the conversation ended. We watched a little SportsCenter, I sobered up and went home.
The next day I got a call from Jay. "Hey, remember our conversation last night?" he said excitedly. "Yeah, of course. I don't think I'll forget that one anytime soon." I joked.
"Well, I got to thinking...and I talked to MaryEllen. She's definitely interested in making this thing happen."
There was silence on my end while I gathered my thoughts.
"Really...." not sure exactly what to say next. "How are we going to do that?"
With that, the plans were laid. The details weren't divulged to me but we would meet that night at Jay's house. MaryEllen would be over around 7:00 and I would come over around 7:30. Jay was a little evasive on the details, but he said he would fill me in on the rest when I got there. That was OK by me.
The day dragged on. The excitement was building for what was in store that evening. It was beginning to get to me. There was no concentrating on work. I had always been attracted to MaryEllen, there was something sexual about her that was hard to pin down. On the surface, she was extremely conservative. Of course, as I was beginning to find out, looks can be deceiving. I had sexual thoughts of her every once and a while, but they were quickly dismissed since she was my best friend's girlfriend. She was with my friend, and that was enough to make her off limits, even if the fantasy started to take off every now and then. Now, I was faced with the reality that this might actually be happening. What was even more exciting was the fact that Jay not only approved, but his fantasies seemed to fit right in with my depraved idea of a good time.
I arrived at 7:30 sharp. I'm not always the most punctual person, but I wasn't going to be late for this night. I walked in to find Jay and MaryEllen in the living room, both smiling at me with devilish grins. I could see the cocktails had already been flowing and I might have to do a little catching up. MaryEllen was wearing a black button-down shirt and a tight black mini skirt. Her blouse seemed that one button too many might have been unbuttoned. Was it my imagination? She stood up and gave me a big hug. I wrapped my arms around her waist my hands rested where the small of her back and my fingers met her ass. I noticed that I couldn't feel any panties underneath. I guess the game is on.