It was now my turn to get fucked and Jimmy lubed up and pushed in. I screamed out in pain as Jimmy started thrusting with his huge cock. Jimmy must've lasted 20 minutes before he pulled out and came all over my face and mouth. I cleaned my face off as Jenny told us we had been good boys. Sarah and Jenny left laughing and Terra and Mandy came over to comfort us. She told us that her sister was sick and twisted and they were sorry we forced to do those things. They admitted though that it was very exciting to watch and made them both very wet.
Over the next couple of days we didn't talk about it much until one day Terra confessed they had been thinking about how nice our cocks looked and that they would like to lose their virginity to us. We all undressed and started kissing. Terra is an overweight girl but has nice big tits and Mandy has an average to overweight body style and very small tits. Terra and I ended up together and Mandy with Jimmy. We decided not to use protection as they were on the pill. We started off with a little oral sex but we really just wanted to get right to penetration. Mandy screamed out "Oh my god" as Jimmy thrust his big cock inside of her. It wasn't long before there was a lot of moaning in Terra's basement and soon Jimmy and I were both filling them with cum. Terra then suggested a swap of partners so they could feel the different size cocks and some oral sex. Since we had already been eating cum we didn't even balk as we switched partners and got into a 69. It wasn't long and all of Jimmy's cum was cleaned out of Mandy and she had cum twice. I then climbed off and pushed myself into Mandy's tight pussy. We looked over at Terra as Jimmy grunted and filled her mouth with his cum. I came inside of Mandy and licked her clean as we all just sat around kissing and caressing for the next couple of hours. The next couple of weeks were spent as horny kids exploring each other's bodies. Jimmy and I took turns with both Mandy and Terra. One day we decided that oral sex would be more fun if we were all shaved. We took turns shaving each other smooth and loved it. I loved seeing the girls' smooth pussies glistening with their juices when they got excited.
Towards the end of summer Terra and Jenny's parents took a trip. Jenny and Sarah decided to throw a party for all of their girlfriends before summer was over and somehow Terra, Mandy, Jimmy and I were invited. There was a lot of alcohol and the four of us were as drunk as all of the girls. Sarah and Jenny invited everyone into the basement to watch a sex video. Sarah explained the video shows 2 geeky guys being humiliated and forced to do some very taboo things. The video started and of course to our humiliation we were the video. It showed our afternoon early in the summer when Jimmy and I were forced to perform.
The girls were laughing at our humiliation and it wasn't long and all the girls were demanding a private personal show. We undressed as Terra and Mandy were forced to remove their clothes and come over to watch closer. Several of the girls brought out their cell phones to take pictures. The girls laughed at our shaved cocks and pointed out how small mine was but were impressed by the size of Jimmy's. I was quickly forced to suck Jimmy's cock and a couple of the girls took turns forcing me further down his 8" cock. When he was ready to cum they directed him to Terra's tits. He came a lot all over her big tits and I was forced to lick them clean. Jimmy was then forced to suck my little cock and it wasn't long I came all over Mandy's small tits and Jimmy licked it up. I was then laid back on the Ottoman and Mandy was forced to lube me up. Jimmy pushed in gently and started fucking me. It was about 20 minutes and Jimmy pulled out and came all over Mandy's shaved pussy. Jenny then told me to lick her pussy clean and make her cum which I did as commanded.
We were then allowed to leave and get cleaned up. As the 4 of were talking over another Jack Daniels shot we decided that as much as they had used us for their entertainment that we enjoyed every minute of the humiliation. Terra, Mandy, Jimmy and I continued our 4 some dating for the next couple of years before we all went our separate ways. Jenny never bothered us anymore as she became engaged later that year and married in the spring.