I knew she liked Sees Chocolates, country and western music, and cowgirl, probably in equal parts. I understood she'd been sexually active before me, loved getting and giving oral sex, and struggled with monogamy our whole time together. I also knew she loved me, would never sneak around, and was incredibly frustrated sexually. She was pretty honest about masturbating regularly, did not try to hide her attraction to other men, but grappled with staying faithful almost constantly. In other words, she was the perfect wife, with that one small caveat.
More than anything, I wanted to show her how much I loved her, appreciated her efforts with being faithful, and was willing to give up to be my wife. I also wanted her to know what I would give up for her: the dream of being the only man a gorgeous woman wanted. I am a normally insecure American male, with a standard level of possessiveness, but more than anything I want to help make her life better and not have her pining for freer times and more bed mates.
It came down to the question, could I be more open sexually? I struggled as much with that as she did with going from a multiple-partner person to a faithful, single-mate individual almost over night.
I read all I could about open marriage, swinging, polyamorous relationships, and multiple partner marriages. I asked friends if they'd had any experience with it, I even asked my sister what she thought.
"You considering a life as a swinger?" she asked as sisters do, like a teacher asking why your homework is so late and messy. I told her I had just read about it, that I was just curious, but she saw right through that and asked if Claire was having some problem being a faithful wife. She knew her before "us" and was aware of her single lifestyle, that's a polite way of saying she knew she was promiscuous and fucked a large part of the male population.
My sister was not a prude, and had probably tried just about everything. I doubtlessly would be shocked at the things my sister has done. Her husband is a surgeon and most likely has bedded many of his colleagues, a bunch of his friends, and even a patient or two.
"If you do try swinging, be sure both of you is on board," she said, the voice of experience I was sure. Sally seemed to know everything about the lifestyle and Claire's history, so I decided to to come clean.
"You know Claire was pretty active in her previous life, so I have been thinking about suggesting we open things up," I said using terminology I had just learned. She turned to look at me skeptically.
"You? The dictionary definition of a possessive husband. You think you could?" she asked directly, mincing no words. "Could you handle her fucking other dudes as you read a book?"
"If I were fucking other chicks," I said, only believing part of it. My sister and I had always been able to talk about anything. She was the one I went to when I started to masturbate.
"Jacking off?" she had said with a grin. "My little brother beating off under the covers." I wondered how she knew it was under the covers. When I first had sex I went and told her.
"Broke your Cherry, huh? Well, good for you. Now you'll probably be beating off more in the bathroom with the door locked and Playboy laid open on the floor." So, how in the hell did she know about the Playboy on the floor? Good guess, I hoped.
After my first date with Claire I told Sally about going out with her and she asked if I knew much about her. It seems they had known each other back in their wild days, and Sally wanted to tell me without traumatizing me over dating a woman who had been with more men than a army barber.