I decided I wanted to try something new and had Frank lay on his back. After putting on a new condom, I got the KY and slathered up my cock. Then, after having him pull his knees up to his chest, I used my coated fingers to rub his asshole, spreading it slowly. He loved that (and later told me he is more of a bottom), so I decided to replace my fingers with my cock. He moaned as the head of my dick passed into his hole. After that, my shaft slid in easily. I didn't know it then but Carol fucks him with a strap-on (and I want to try that with them next time), so we were quickly fucking away. At his insistence, I was soon fucking him with all my strength, grabbing him by the ankles and pulling him to me. We did this for a long time, sometimes taking a break to stroke his cock. I was amazed that I was lasting as long as I was (nerves?) but we kept going.
I eventually pulled out and he went to wash up. Carol, who had been cheering us on as she fingered herself, was ready for some more attention. I ate her pussy hungrily, taking breaks to lick her asshole from time to time. She was soon screaming again and was pulling my head harder into her pussy when Frank returned. I was on my knees between Carol's legs as I felt him playing with my asshole. I moaned, hoping I knew what was coming. I could hear the condom wrapper ripping and redoubled my licking of Carol's cunt. Frank's lubed fingers slowly explored my asshole and I had to pull my mouth away to say how good it felt. Then, for the first time in my life, I felt a cockhead slowly entering my ass. Damn, it felt good. He was so big but thankfully took it really slowly. Soon, he was buried balls-deep in my ass. I just had to lay my head on Carol's stomach, repeating over and over the same things: "Fuck me!" "Harder!" "YES!" It was so good and Carol loved it too. She was squeezing her nipples in one hand and fingering her cunt with the other.
Frank fuck me for what seemed like forever (though it was probably around 15 minutes or so). He eventually pulled out and ditched the rubber. He said he had to cum and asked Carol where she wanted it. Though I didn't say it, I would have loved for him to fuck Carol and then have her sit on my face. Alas, she said she wanted me to lay down on my back. Then, with him on my left and her on my right, she told him to cum on my chest. It was so great watching him stroke and I would occasionally lick his cockhead. Soon, he was panting and said he was about to cum. The first stream of cum shot out, all over my hairy chest. Carol almost screamed as she continued fingering herself. I don't know what came over me but I leaned up and, after missing a shot or two, wrapped my mouth around his still-shooting cock. Carol yelled "YES! Fuck that is so hot!" as she then came too.
I couldn't bring myself to swallow the small amount of cum I had captured, so Frank bent down to kiss me again. He sucked his cum out of my mouth. It was then my turn to cum. They slowly stroked my cock, gaining speed as the minutes passed. Carol then asked me if I would make myself cum and I was more than happy to. I was soon moaning and, after sucking and fucking for hours, shot a HUGE amount of cum into the air and passed my own nipples. It was almost like a porn star and both Frank and Carol loved it. Fuck, what a great time.
After that, I did feel a little silly (that post-orgasm guilt) but it quickly passed. We cleaned up and talked for a little while. I was glad to find them really fun, sane, normal, kinky people. We are talking about getting together again, perhaps with a girlfriend of Carol's. I want to see that and we also have her strap-on to try out.
So, it is all true. Only the names have been changed to protect the innocent. If you hated it, please don't bother commenting. If you like this story, PLEASE let me know. This was a big step for me to write and I hope some of you like it. I'm not bi but it would be fun to try again.