"I want to be the prize for your boys night poker game?" Asked a suddenly shy Andrea. The question that brought about this startling answer centered around sexual fantasies and her answer stopped me dead in my tracks.
Let's back up a little before we unpack the previously low key Andrea's newly revealed desire to be used as a poker prize by a group of drunken twenty somethings.
Andrea and I are what you'd call friends with benefits. Both of us are working full time and going to school in the typical early twenties hustle. No time for real relationships, but not ignoring our physiological need for fucking. We had stumbled across each other in a class eighteen months ago and within a few weeks discovered the perfect FWB fit.
Andrea was maybe 5' tall, curvy hips and 34D tits that look huge on her tiny frame. Her Middle Eastern creamy brown skin and dark hair give her a mysterious foreign look that matches the smoky tones of her smooth voice.
I'm your typical white guy, ten inches taller than her, light hair and an athletic build. I prided myself on my eight inch cock in high school, but found college and work had relegated it to the occasional porn based jack off. That was until Andrea came into my life. Her matter of fact way of asking to be fucked was a pleasant alternative to the dating game I had failed at in the past.
Simple texts like "I'm not working tonight and just shaved my pussy smooth, do you want to see?" Where now a high point of my day. We often hooked up at her apartment and had broken more than a few pieces of furniture.
As of late we had been texting each other sexy fantasies and I had revealed my desire to be with two women. She mocked the cliche nature of the fantasy, but soon fell into a sexting thread that described how she'd make the other girl clean my cum out of her pussy or hold her head as I fucked her face. She was damn creative and often left me with a raging hard on in the middle of classes.
Her fantasies often revolved around being used as a submissive, clothes ripped off and hair pulling. Her thick mane of black hair was ripe for pulling and I'd had fistfuls of it while I fucked her from behind in the past. She also seemed to like dress up and role play and owned more than a few sexy school girl, cheerleader and maid outfits under the guise of Halloween attire. My guess is most have never left her apartment and that's pretty ok with me!
Our fantasy teasing action had escalated over the last few months and it seemed as though if we were not working or in class, we were sexting and more often than not we were sexting while at work or in school. Hard to focus on quantum mechanics when your FWB is detailing how she wants to be tied up and gang banged by your buddies.
That all came to a head late last month when I swung by Andrea's place for our Friday evening blowout. I had picked up Chinese and was looking forward to sex after endless texts and not seeing much of each other for several weeks.
Andrea answered in full makeup, thigh highs and a basque that displayed her tits spectacularly. Her heels were easily 6" tall and she had undoubtedly had a few drinks.
It wasn't totally out of character for Andrea to greet me dressed up (so far cheerleader in pigtails was my favorite), but it was unusual for a Friday as she has to work at the bar by 8:00pm.
I must have paused too long staring at her amazing body as she grabbed the food and said "I hope you have enough for three". It's Chinese, so I started to explain, there's always too much, but stopped as it clicked. Three? Dressed slutty, but has a friend over? I was struggling to process as Andrea ripped open the food and dug in as I tried to get my head around the scene.
Andrea looked up at me through giant fluttery eyelashes and asked "Are you curious who's here? Are you ready for a really big surprise?"
I was still struggling with the math when her friend Celina walked out of the bedroom "Do I smell Chinese? Did you get Beef & Broccoli?" Asked Celina as if this were a routine dinner and she wasn't wearing a nearly matching outfit to Andrea's.
Celina walked straight up to me and kissed me hard on the lips while rubbing my cock through my pants. "Easy girl, we don't want to break him, at least not this early in the evening" instructed Andrea as Celina nibbled my neck and continued to rub my cock.
"Are you ready for your surprise? Remember telling me your ultimate fantasy was two hot girls? Well, it just so happens Celina has had a six month dry spell and I thought, maybe I can help you both." Andrea explained in her highly animated way.
"Can you fuck us both? But maybe fuck me first, I need a really hard pounding" shared Celina as she ground her body against mine.
All the while Andrea watched, eyes slack while licking soy sauce off her fingers. "Happy birthday baby, I got you a hot little slut, she's mostly unwrapped already, I hope you like her"
I had processed by this point, weeks of sexting where clearly as much research as they were erotica on Andrea's part and I had a fourteen day hard on that was now making the decisions. I slid my fingers up the back of Celina's head, gently grabbing a fistful of hair and tilted her head back so I could kiss her neck and cleavage. She moaned and felt as though she would fall over.
Andrea chimed in between egg rolls, "she likes it a little rough, doesn't do anal, but could swallow a coke bottle if you asked her to"
That seemed like my cue to pick her up (she was just as small as Andrea) and carry her to the bedroom. A semi rough toss onto the bed was met with a guttural moan and "Fuck I need this, so bad"
As I stripped, she shimmied out of underwear, bra and shoes, leaving just her thigh highs framing a very shaven pussy. I love smooth pussy lips, and after a bit of hard kissing, had my head between her legs.
From behind me I heard Andrea say "I told you he loves to eat pussy, lay back like a good pillow princess and let my man take you to heaven"
Celina responded with a series of distorted fucks mixed in with loud moaning. I was glad to hear Andrea was in the room as well.
It wasn't long before Celina arched her back, grabbed my hair and came all over my face in a staccato of animalistic groans. This was really hot and I needed to fuck one of them very soon!
Andrea plopped down on the bed next to her friend and played with her nipples. "Is this what your fantasy is like? Two drunk and horny girls that just want to fuck the night away?"
She knew damn well every detail of my fantasies and was now assuming a starring role in making this one a reality.
"Fuck me baby, Celina can't have all the fun tonight" begged Andrea as she pulled her legs up and apart.
I slid over, dragged my tongue across her wet slit and moved up to push my dick into her. Andrea moaned as I slid in and clawed at my back while wrapping her legs around me.
Celina reached over and kissed me, licking Andrea's juices off my lips. "She tastes good, doesn't he? Asked Celina as Andrea began pleading for a hard fuck.
This was pretty much dead on my dream and I knew I'd need to make one of Andrea's come true as well.
The two of them must have pregamed as Andrea was cumming in minutes, begging for me to fuck her harder and dragging her nails across my back. I slowed down the pace as Andrea's orgasm crescendo subsided and she whispered in my ear
"Do the same to Celina, I want to watch you cum in her pussy and lick the cream pie out when you're done" there was the subby Andrea I knew and loved.
