I finally had a chance to fulfill one of my biggest fantasies and this is how it went.
As the couple greeted me at the door of their apartment, I knew it was going to be a good time. He was very average looking, which is all I expected from him, but he had clear skin, a nice smile and a full head of hair. She was much better looking than him (not really that surprising as most women are better looking than their partners). She had a very pretty face with bright eyes, curly hair and the kind of body that showed she hit the gym after work but before happy hour. No six-pack or size 0 waist, but the kind of body you'd see at the grocery and give a double take when she walked by in leggings.
We shook hands and I asked if they were ready to begin. We had met online on a "list" website looking for this specific kind of interaction. I shared with them my fantasy and they were more than willing to oblige.
They lead me into their living room and it was set up as we had agreed upon. There was a large couch against one wall and a comfy sitting chair they had moved about 8 feet away facing the couch. The couple stood in front of the couch and I began to take off my clothes. I pulled my t-shirt up over my head and laid it on the arm of the comfy chair. I unbuckled my belt and jeans and stripped them off and placed them on my shirt. My socks came next and I tucked them into the back pocket of my jeans so I wouldn't leave them. I stood in front of the couple in just my gray, athletic boxer briefs, my hard on laying against my hip compressed under the tight underwear. There was a wet spot starting to form near the head from my pre cum.
I walked towards them and double checked that they were ready. They both smiled and nodded and I got started. I unbuttoned his shirt and as I slid it off his shoulders I leaned over and kissed his collar bone. I kissed my way down to his left nipple and sucked and nibbled on it before switching to his right nipple. The moisture from my saliva and the AC in the apartment helped get them as hard and tight as little erasers. Once they were fully erect I continued down his body and knelt in front of him unbuckling his belt and his khakis. I pulled them down to his ankles and helped him step out of his pants. I saw his hard cock pressing against his underwear and slightly rubbed it with my hand, drawing my fingernails all along the length of his member.
I could feel it move and get harder as I grabbed it and gave it a little stoke through the thin material. I reached up to the waistline of his underwear and pulled them down just enough to free his cock, immediately taking the tip into my mouth, savoring the pre-cum that had already began leaking out. While I licked the head of his cock, I pulled his underwear all the way down and he stepped out of them. I then began to massage his balls and suck/stroke his cock. When I thought it was as hard as it was going to get, I took it deep into my mouth, trying to get my nose to touch his belly. It wasn't that difficult, this wasn't my first cock and his was perfectly sized for my mouth. It was thick and veiny with a nice head, but not so long that I couldn't take the whole thing in my mouth without gagging. It gave my mouth a wonderful full feeling as my tongue ran on the underside and it pushed against the roof of my mouth. I got his cock rock hard and slick with my saliva, alternating between stroking him and taking him deep into my mouth.
After about a minute of sucking his cock, I pulled off and stood up. I put my hands on her shoulders and moved her between us. They began to make out as she reached down to stroke his wet cock. I stood behind her, kissed her neck and shoulders and pulled her shirt up over her head. They were still making out as I undid her bra and threw it off to the side. I reached around and began to knead her tits, pinching her nipples and tweaking them a little. I could hear her moan into his mouth as she continued to stroke him and kiss him. I knelt down behind her and pulled her shorts to the floor.