Note to Reader: While you can read this story on its own, it will make much more sense if you go back and read Chapter 1 first as it picks up immediately from the ending of that chapter. This is only my second submission to Literotica, and this is the first time I've taken advantage of the volunteer editor program. Huge thank you to alalu777 for all of the help editing this story! A lot of hours went into this work, and I wouldn't be able to make it what it is without alalu777's help!
Chapter 2
It was past one in the morning now. We were all sitting at my cheap, rickety kitchen table, almost in complete darkness. A small lamp in the corner provided only a dim light. We weren't talking much but that was mostly because none of us could stop stuffing our faces between pizza slices. Hannah and Alison's faces were positively glowing with these post-sex, dreamy and satisfied smiles between bites. Hannah had slipped her sundress back on and Alison just her panties and tight purple t-shirt.
We finished the last slices of pizza and the girls exchanged a knowing look before giggling. I didn't know what was funny, but it was contagious. I involuntarily joined in on the laughter myself.
"That." Alison exclaimed, referring to the raunchy threesome we'd just had, "was the hottest single thing I've ever seen. Really, ever, seen in my life!" Hannah and I agreed.
I had been holding in a truth I was a little worried to tell, but this seemed like the right moment. "Umm, so I know we talked about fulfilling all three of our fantasies tonight. I'm a little worried I'd be doing a disservice to you with the little, if any performance I have left in me after that... I've never cum that hard in my life and that was round two for me tonight" I was so worried I was giving up an opportunity I wouldn't get back.
"Dude, I couldn't handle more right now anyway. I'm so sensitive, and I still can't feel my legs at all!" Hannah reassured me. Alison gave me a devilish smirk, "Yeah, I'm whooped too, and I would be disappointed if Hannah got more cum than me anyway. You need to recharge before you can make my fantasy come true."
Alison continued, "Look. I am just going to say it. If I left here tomorrow morning, I wouldn't be able to stop thinking about either of you. I can tell I'm going to wake up horny as fuck tomorrow just thinking about this. Plus, I've never felt more connected with two people as I do with you. It's a weird sort of crush infatuation thing I have going on with..." Alison paused mid-thought "...whatever this is between us." She paused again to calculate the rest of her idea. "I say, let's cancel the rest of whatever the fuck we have planned... I want a full weekend with you two. Please?"
Hannah and I both smiled .I felt so reassured I hadn't blown my chances for more of this, I was happy to hear I wasn't the only one feeling total infatuation and obsession with my new-found, trusting and open relationship with these two. It was the first time I hadn't felt alone in a long time.
"Okay" Hannah spoke up "I'm game. Best weekend ever. Spence?" both girls looked at me as I realized I had only thought of my agreeance reply and not yet vocalized it... "I'm supposed to go into work tomorrow, and I have two papers due... but... absolutely. I'm in. I'll figure out a way to blow both of those off." I said it casually, but truthfully this was something I'd never done since landing this job. I shoved it out of my head. Everyone's allowed one moment of irresponsibility and lapse in judgement once in a blue moon. Right?
We all got up from the table and dispersed. Alison cleaned up the mess from the pizza, Hannah picked up some of the beer bottles from the party, and I excused myself to go change my bed sheets.
As I finished putting the clean, fitted sheet on the bed, the girls walked in. Without any conversation of the sleeping arrangement, all three of us climbed into my queen size bed. I was closest to the wall, then Hannah next to me and Alison near the edge of the bed.
We recapped some of our favorite parts of the whole evening, the party and what followed as we all winded down in the dark, waiting for sleep. My groin was pressed up against Hannah's ass just a little bit as she was facing Alison. For a moment I couldn't help but have what just happened a few hours earlier flash through my head and think of how close her tight little asshole was to my cock right now. I wanted to know how it felt to be inside her there. Not just my fingers but the full length and girth of my hard cock, if it would even fit.
Alison, who was propped up on an elbow looking at Hannah, glanced over the top of her friend at me with this look like she knew what thought I had just had. We smiled at each other momentarily before turning away.
Somehow, sleep came for the three of us.
I woke up first, ever the early riser. My head was pounding from the alcohol, but my overall giddiness at waking up and being able to look at a sound asleep Hannah and Alison in my bed. I convinced myself last night was real, and that allowed me to easily shove the headache aside. I sleepily shuffled into the kitchen wearing just my boxers.
The sun shined in brightly from the sliding patio door as I traversed the cheap, beige carpet and white-walled living room. The darkness of the small galley kitchen was welcome I put on a pot of coffee in my cheap plastic and glass coffee maker and waited for it to brew. As I stood there, my heart suddenly burst up in my chest as I realized that before this day was over, I'd likely get a new sexual experience that rivaled what had happened last night.
"Morning" Hannah mumbled as she sleepily crept into the kitchen, shielding her eyes from the bright living room. She was gorgeous. She was gorgeous, standing bare-foot, hair messed up, with the sunlight shining on her sundress, making me aware of her nudeness underneath. Her nipples showed through the fabric.
"Morning" I replied back. "Coffee's almost ready." She just smiled at me lightly before I caught her eyes gaze at my bulge in my boxers. The look made me twitch just a little down there.
We fixed up coffee and sat at the table for a minute, our eyes adjusting to the mid-morning daylight. Hannah hadn't mentioned it last night, but she was supposed to go to her cousin's graduation party today, and she shared her plans for how she was going to get out of it. My heart leapt in my chest again as I realized how casually she was talking about cancelling on family plans for the purpose of fulfilling her best friend's sexual fantasies in a threesome. That last part was left unsaid, but we both knew it was true.
"I'm going to go wake Alison up. She'll sleep until 3pm if we let her." As Hannah got up, her foot grazed my calf, and there was my morning wood! Holy shit if that night of sleep and half a cup of coffee had me rearing to go again. I wanted to stop Hannah and take her on my kitchen table. I resisted the urge and watched her backside as she walked down the hallway.