The party was over. Michelle had been flirting and teasing both James and me all night. Everyone else had left and it was just Michelle, James, and myself left at her apartment. I called James into the kitchen, " She wants me! You are cock-blocking!" I exclaimed, trying to get him to split.
"Bullshit! She wants a piece of raw thick meat tonight!" James shot back.
"Why not wrestle to decide?" Michelle interupted. She had overheard our argument and knew James and I were both ex-high school wrestlers. "I would love to watch that!" she said.
James and I knew it would come down to a match as both of us were all heated up for some action.
"OK Michelle, it's you we both want and it's your match, what kinda match do you want us in?" I asked.
I was totally shocked when Michelle said she wanted to see us in an erotic oil wrestling match, first guy to lose his load loses, winner got to fuck her all night! James and I looked at each other and reluctantly agreed, and it was on!
Let me set this match up, James is olive skinned Italian dude, 26 years old, 5'10'', 185 lb., in great shape, smooth chest and facial area, and smooth cock and balls (as I would find out a little later). He sports a 8.5'' dick that is nice and thick, and is a favorite with the women we hang with. I am a white 27 year old, 6'0'', 180lb., also in great shape with a 8'' smoothly shaven public area.
Michelle, the girl we're wrestling for is totally hot with C sized tits and curves in all the right places, and well worth all this trouble. I wanted to see how James could handle this kinda thing anyway. I have wrestled like this before, I don't think James has and was surprised he agreed to this style of match. Unless he was as curious about me as I was about him, anyway, I think Michelle musta got a sensed that we would be game for this and set us up.
Michelle pulled out a tarp as we moved furniture, and set up a nice mat for the match. She told us to go into separate bedrooms and strip down for the match, when she called for us to come out, she would have our wrestling suit to put on when we entered the room.
I stripped to nothing and my cock was already stirring a little in anticipation of the sex-battle ahead of me. Michelle yelled for us to enter and was on her knees dressed in only a tiny bikini in the middle of the tarp holding a white cotton thong in her right hand, and a yellow cotton thong bikini in her left. I got the white, James the yellow. Michelle then oiled each of us down, lots and lots of oil! She paid special attention to our growing hard-ons and ass-cracks as she oiled us. Both of us took turns kissing and necking her as she oiled our heated bodies. By the time she was done James and I both had raging hard-ons and were ready to do battle. Michelle laid down the rules, 1st to cum during the match lost, you can make your opponent cum by any means necessary, winner gets me for the night, loser goes home. "Get it on boys!" Michelle said, as she sat down on the couch to watch the action.