As we snuggled together, Jerry and Patsy in front and Sara and I in the back, I thought: It doesn't get much better than this. Nobody said a word, we just kept thinking about what had happened. It did not seem real. It had just seemed natural to all of us and we went with what we were feeling. The sex was amazing and I couldn't help but think about how good it had been. Sara was not only beautiful and sexy, but also very responsive and very willing. Patsy seemed a little wilder, but just as beautiful and sexy. A thought came to me.
"So," I said "How old are you girls anyway. I hope it isn't too late to ask." Everyone laughed.
Patsy turned "If we were 15 and 16 it would be too late wouldn't it?" I grimaced and she smiled.
"No worries baby. Sara is my little sister. I am 21 and she is 19. We're legal!"
"That's a relief! So what do you girls do? Besides this."
They both laughed. "We don't usually do this, Jim. Honestly. We're both in college, and we're roommates just like always. We just took the night off and were bored. We decided a sexy movie would break the boredom. It sure did! When you guys showed up.
We sat in silence for a while. Patty turned and looked at Sara. "Do you think we should go home." Sara said, "Yeah, if Jerry can take us that would be great." "No problem" Jerry said. We put our clothes back on and he started the car. Sara and I snuggled together. Patsy gave directions.
As we pulled up in front of the dorm, we hugged each other and got out. As I was getting into the front seat, Sara and Patsy put their heads together and whispered to each other and then turned to me. "Would you both like to come in for a minute?"
Jerry parked the car and we followed the girls into the house. Their room was on the first floor and we hurried into it before anyone saw us. Patsy locked the door and said "Make yourself at home. Would you like a beer? "Sure would" I said and Jerry nodded. She came back with four tall necks.
Patsy started the conversation. "I don't know about the rest of you, but I had a great time tonight." "Me too." Sara said smiling at me. "Ditto" Jerry and I both replied.
"So..." she said, "Is it over or are you guys up for some more?" Sara looked shocked for a minute, and then smiled shyly at me. I was somewhat taken aback myself. "Whoa" said Jerry, "I'm always up!" We all laughed.
"What did you have in mind?" Jerry said.
"Well... You were so good to me and Jim was so good to Sara, I thought we might just switch off and see if we can all be good to each other again."
Now I was shocked. Sara was looking at Patsy and then looked over at Jerry. Jerry looked back at her and smiled. I looked at Patsy and she said "What do you say, Jim. Wanna go at me?"
I thought for a minute and not wanting to offend Sara, I replied "I don't know, you're much older than Sara."