A few years ago, an attractive young woman named Ashleigh hired me for some boudoir photography -- tasteful, sexy photos as a wedding gift for her fiancΓ©. It was her first time doing intimate photos with a photographer, but it didn't take long to get into the groove, and we worked through the poses pretty quickly. The mood stayed lighthearted and fun, I captured some beautiful shots, and we set a date for her to pick up the prints after their honeymoon.
Great shoot, great photos, great client -- another job on the books.
One month later, the newly-married couple arrived at my studio to pick up the prints. They were tanned, relaxed, and practically glowing with honeymoon bliss.
The photos were a surprise for Ashleigh's husband, James. He showed up expecting to do a boring couple's portrait and was delighted when he opened the portfolio of her boudoir prints.
"Oh, babe!" He looked between the photos and his wife with a giant grin on his face.
She hugged his arm. "You like them?"
"Ash, these are amazing." He was completely focused on the prints, eyes wide and hungrily consuming every detail.
I love these moments -- most of the time I mail the prints or send someone the digital files, so I don't get to see the reaction in person. I was basking in the compliments and trying not to grin like an idiot.
She got up on her tiptoes and planted a peck on his cheek before wrapping her arms around him in a big hug. "I hope these keep you warm when I'm not home!" She clung to him tightly and gave him a little wiggle.
He laughed, then gave me a guarded look. "You took these?"
I nodded reassuringly. "She made it easy. She knew exactly what she wanted to do for you. It all went very smoothly, and the photos turned out great."
This is all about you and her; she was safe and in control; don't mind the photographer.
"Yeah, these are great." He grinned and extended his hand. "Thank you." We shook. All was well.
We made small talk for a couple of minutes, then wrapped it up with another round of handshakes and compliments. Another happy customer!
I didn't think anything more of Ashleigh and James until two months later, when I got a phone call. "Hello, Tony's Studio."
"Hey Tony, this is James. We met a couple months ago; you took photos of my wife, Ashleigh. Petite girl, dark hair, red lingerie?"
"James! Yes, it's great to hear from you. How are you two doing? What can I do for you?" I love getting calls from my customers; it usually means they're interested in booking another session.
"We're doing great, thank you! Hey, we're hoping you would take some photos of Ash and me."
Bingo!
"Of course! What kinds of photos? Family portrait? Big announcement? Or are you thinking about something more intimate?"
"More intimate," he laughed. "Like, a lot more intimate."
"Yes, of course." I grabbed a pen and some paper to take down notes. "Tell me more about what you're looking for and I'm sure we can make it happen."
He paused for a moment. "Well, I was hoping we could chat with you in person. Are you available after five tonight? Happy hour? My treat."
My curiosity was piqued, and we arranged to meet at one of the trendy hotel bars downtown.
A few hours later I was walking up to the entrance of the fashionably appointed hotel. It was a beautiful summer evening, and the sun was still bright in the sky as I crossed the lobby and entered the bar, a light and airy modern affair with floor to ceiling windows, big paintings, and wood slab tables. I arrived a couple of minutes early and found a private booth where I could see the entrance.
James strolled through the door a few minutes later, punctual to the second. He was an easy six feet tall, with an athletic build and dark hair. He looked sharp in a pale blue button up shirt, crisp haircut, and a deep tan. His sleeves were rolled halfway up his forearms, and he looked like he'd just stepped out of the pages of GQ. He took off his sunglasses and appraised the room.
"James!" I flagged him down and stood to greet him.
He weaved his way through the bar with a grin on his face. "Tony, good to see you!" He pumped my hand enthusiastically, then hung his sunglasses off the top button of his shirt. He gave me an award winning smile. "Thanks for coming down to meet us. Ash is on her way."
We sat down and made small talk for a minute before the waitress arrived to take our order. As soon as she departed, James glanced at his phone and tapped out a quick message, then gave me a smirk.
"Ash says she'll be here in a minute, but I'm going to get straight to the point."
I nodded encouragingly. He leaned in with a conspiratorial smile.
"So," he said in a lowered voice. "We tried taking some pictures of us fucking, but they were awful. We want your help making some good ones."
Sex photos? Like, porn? That's not what I do...
I gave him a confused look, and a grin spread across his face as he watched my reaction.
My stomach did a little anxious flip and I tried to cover my surprise with a laugh. "I can't imagine the two of you taking unflattering photos. You're both pretty damn good looking!"
"Well, she is, for sure," James said and gave me a knowing smile. "Look, I can't take the kinds of pictures you take. I don't even know where to start. Ash suggested you could do it, and it's a special occasion. What do you think?"
A special occasion... for porn?
The waitress appeared with our cocktails, and I took advantage of the interruption to collect my thoughts. James and I tapped glasses, toasted to the beautiful day, and enjoyed our first sips.
Here's my hangup: I pride myself on being a professional photographer -- emphasis on professional. I built my business by taking great pictures of people, and over time my work gravitated toward fashion for my commercial clients, and portraiture and boudoir for private individuals. I gained success because of my professionalism in and out of the studio: I stuck to tasteful subjects, and built my reputation on being a good guy to work with. I did my best to make people comfortable and treated them with respect: no leering, no suggestive comments, and above all else -- appropriate physical distance. Even if a model needed a shoulder strap untwisted or a stray hair tamed, I gave her direction, or asked a stylist to help.
My issue with James's proposal was this: boudoir and pinups might be sexy, but it's completely different than shooting porn! Don't get me wrong -- I'm no prude, and I've taken plenty of those kinds of photos with my partners over the years, but that's just for my private enjoyment.
My professional instincts shouted no: don't cross that line with a client.
I took another sip and cleared my throat. I was figuring out how to decline politely when Ashleigh appeared next to the table.
She wore a close-fitting deep blue dress with an A-line skirt and elbow length sleeves. A thin gold necklace, a matching bracelet, and low black heels pulled it all together in a crisply professional and beautifully feminine look.
"Hi, Tony!"