Dire Consequences 1

Attention Reader! This is the fifth installment of a longer story arc. If, by chance, you are not caught up, here is the series homepage: https://www.literotica.com/series/se/risky-games

The following story includes a very brief recap woven in to the first few paragraphs, just to make sure the most pertinent bits of the previous installments are fresh in the reader's mind.

Note: All (extrauterine) characters are at least 18 years old. This story involves risky, unprotected, consensual sex, including dubiously consensual impregnation, as well as themes of deception/betrayal/revenge and peeping/voyeurism/filming (great material for fantasy, but not recommended in the real world). The following story is purely fictional. Any similarity to real people, places, or events is unintended coincidence.

* * *

"Congratulations?" Gary managed to croak tentatively.

It was all the 38-year old man could muster in response to Katie's announcement. They each stood there, looking slightly embarrassed. Gary shifted his muscular frame and nervously pushed an errant lock of his auburn hair back into place.

"Yes... congratulations." Katie responded with a blush, then in a barely audible whisper, she continued, "It's okay... I want this," and brought her palms to her lower abdomen with a smile. To any casual observer, her taut tummy showed no signs of impregnation. Her womanly hips and lovely bosom certainly fit the picture of fecundity, but only upon hearing those words uttered, would one realize that Katie was a pregnant woman.

Gary's head was spinning. The chicks of weekends past certainly seemed to be coming home to roost!

Katie was the second woman to have dropped by that very afternoon to inform him that she was now carrying his child... and her arrival meant that there were now

three

pregnant women in his house,

each of whom was carrying a baby of his!

It was an overwhelming mix of terror, excitement, dread, and... pride!

Gary knew, at some level, that it was silly to be so proud of his recent sexual conquests. But that didn't stop him from enjoying the feeling. It also wasn't completely illogical:

The notion of 'diversifying' his brood by planting his seed in multiple women felt like an accomplishment. Not to mention the idea that he, Gary Marsh, was desirable to these women, each of whom was a fine specimen herself!

"She totally wanted your baby." Erin drawled slowly from the doorway behind Gary, who jumped a little, not realizing that she had waddled over from the living room, where she had been making out with June on the couch that the three of them had all fucked on only a few minutes earlier. She was completely naked and holding her enormously pregnant belly with both hands as she beamed at Katie.

Erin continued in a sultry voice, dripping with pleasure, "She left an ovulation test in your bathroom wastebasket the night we had a threesome... it was positive. I'm pretty sure she tested herself

before

our ménage à trois... it was showtime, and she knew it!"

Gary screwed up his face. "Really?"

Katie nodded and smiled. "It's almost Shakespearian, actually."

"Sorry, I don't follow." Gary said, suddenly confused again.

Katie generously explained, "So many overlapping deceptions! You thought I was on birth control, and you wanted me to pretend to be fertile, and pretend to freak out when you 'forgot to pull out' of me, for Erin's benefit."

Gary and Erin looked at each other lovingly. "I knew you would like it," he crooned.

"Mmh, I

loved

it!" Erin replied, blowing him a kiss.

Katie continued, "But I

was

fertile, and I allowed you think that you could cum in me safely."

Katie paused for a breath before continuing, "But then, when you... well, there's no delicate way to put this... when you pumped that first load of hot sperm into my ripe cunt, I guess I pretended to freak out too well, so

you

got scared that you had knocked me up... didn't stop you from cumming in me again though, not 20 minutes later, did it?" she ended with an exaggerated wink, directed at Erin, "Your man here double-tapped my uterus."

"So... let me get this straight," Garry started out seriously, "You actually weren't on the pill anymore, but let me think you were, so that I would knock you up, and then you pretended to freak out, just to freak me out?"

"Well...

you

asked me to freak out for

her

benefit. How is it

my

fault, if I did it too well?" Katie sounded somewhat defensive suddenly.

"Oh I'm not mad!" Gary said with a friendly smile. "Lord knows, I have no leg to stand on, if I tried to act holier-than-thou about that!! I just don't see how that has anything to do with Shakespeare..."

"Ugh.. business majors!" Katie said with disgust. "You may be smart with numbers, but I swear you guys are illiterate!"

Gary responded with mock indignation "Hey! I'll have you know I was a business major 15 years ago. Now, I'm an accounting consultant!" Then he added quietly, "And a successful one at that..."

"Care to join us to celebrate your news?" Erin interjected, changing the subject back to babies and fucking, as she suggestively pulled on one of her nipples and beckoned while biting her lower lip.

"Who's the other chick?" Katie asked, leaving Gary to wonder why she sounded more receptive to a foursome now than she had two minutes ago, when

he

had invited her to join them.

"June. She's the most recent addition to the family. And she's just barely 18!" Erin giggled.

Katie's eyes closed halfway as she sighed in annoyance. "Really, Gary? What the fuck, man? Are you just some kind of man whore now? Can I still trust you're clean?"

"He's

my

man whore, cum slut!" Erin responded asserting her dominance, "and he cums in whoever I want him to." Erin looked down and rubbed her belly as she continued, "And I make sure we're all clean."

Katie felt self conscious as a 36-year old. She had initially resisted the idea of baring herself in front of the 20-year-old Erin, but the experience had been quite incredible.

Now the idea of being nude with both Erin and an 18-year-old was bothering her again. But she was curious about what a foursome would be like. And had gotten surprisingly turned on explaining the irony of her thoughts leading up to and during the threesome to the other two people she had fucked.

"I supposed I can stay a little while. I really should meet June, I guess..." Katie acquiesced, before sliding off her shoes and walking softly into the living room, where she found June lying back on the couch.

Katie's eye was immediately drawn to the completely shaved pussy that gaped back at her from between the 18-year-old's lean, muscular legs, a trickle of creamy jizz slowly oozing out from the base of the obviously-just-fucked twat.

June gave a slightly awkward half smile, but didn't attempt to cover herself in any way as she lounged on the couch.

Erin announced, "June, Katie. Katie, June."

"Congratulations, Katie! I..." June paused, "...overheard most of your little convo... I didn't want to interrupt. But, I think we're in the same boat! Exciting isn't it?" June was still not sure how to feel about her own pregnancy, but she could tell that Katie was glad to be pregnant, and June wanted to share in that joy and excitement, even if her own thoughts tended to turn towards an enraged father, a disappointed mother, or a gloating adopted sister... "Ugh!" June thought, "Casey is going to

own

me if she finds out I got knocked up!"

"So you're...?" Katie left the unfinished question hang there.

Erin confirmed before June could formulate an answer, "Yep, We fertilized her a week after you."

June silently noted how Erin had framed that, "

'We fertilized her'

... WTF?"

Katie was more willing to challenge Erin aloud, though she asked quietly, "What do you mean, 'we fertilized'?"

"Well, obviously I wasn't being exactly literal..." Erin replied, "Poetically... I feel like I am a contributing party to both of your successful impregnations, even if it isn't

my DNA

getting mixed in..."

"So, do you get a power rush when Gary cums in someone for you?" Katie asked knowingly.

"Ohhh, like you wouldn't believe!" Erin moaned.

"Wait, did you try to get

me

pregnant?" June uttered in shock.

"I... got off on knowing that you were

risking

pregnancy." Erin responded carefully, as she silently thought to herself, "Yes, you dumb whore. My goal was to get you good and pregnant, at least, once you fucked Gary behind my back!"

Hearing the women talk in hushed tones, Gary ambled in and shyly said, "Ok, I can tell something's up... I think I'll sit this one out."

"Bullshit!" Erin quipped, "You don't have to pull your cock out if you don't want to, we know your precious 'peony' needs a rest... But you got two hands and a mouth... the least you can do is service your harem..."

June continued Erin's line of thought, "Yeah, c'mon Gary! Help us out!"

Then when he got a little closer, she continued, "Erin and I have already cum, so we should focus on pleasuring Katie first!" She turned to Katie and continued, "you set their bar for a three-way pretty high... Erin told me how amazing her experience was with you and Gary, and that's how she convinced me to do one with her and Gary..." she turned to look at Erin again and said, "Of course it helps, that I think you're, like the definition of sexy!"

Gary grinned as the two naked young women led the third onto the couch, and then helped strip her down. The very pregnant Erin took charge of unbuttoning the older Katie's blouse, removing her bra, and exposing the two large tits underneath, while June set in to peppering Katie with hungry little kisses all over her face and neck. And then, once Erin had removed all obstacles, June continued her kisses down Katie's chest, to her sensitive nipples.

She suckled and nipped at the ends of Katie's tits for a minute, before continuing her descent, across Katie's flat (for now) belly. When she reached Katie's waistband, she grinned up at Katie mischievously, and then popped the button off of Katie's pants with her teeth, allowing her to yank down the buttonless slacks, and expose the black silk panties underneath.

June reached out and began to tease Katie's pussy through the smooth, thin layer of satin, eliciting pleasured noises as her flingers glided lightly over the silky contours.

Gary heard Katie's soft moans and took them as his cue to enter the fray. He patted June's ass twice, and she made room for him and returned to kissing Katie on the mouth as he reached up to peel Katie's last remaining item of clothing off of her aroused body.

He left the kissing to June and the titty play to Erin, and made his way straight to Katie's... ass! He began kneading her juicy glutes, and even threw in a few light spanks, saying, "This is what you get for scaring me like that."

June was shocked to witness it, but Katie clearly didn't mind the rougher play, instead moaning louder with each slap. Erin could just make out the reddening imprint Gary's hand left on Katie's round ass, but she knew it wouldn't leave a mark for more than a few minutes.

June and Erin began to suckle Katie's luscious tits, taking her sensitive nipples into their mouths and teasing them with their tongues. And Gary moved to survey her pussy.

There were droplets of her nectar beaded up on the pubic hairs nearest to her self-lubricated hole. Gary could smell the musky scent of her arousal as he leaned in to burry his face in her furry folds.

Katie had never been in a foursome before, but she was loving it. She could just lean back and relax while three lusty mouths sensually nipped and lapped at her most sensitive bits. It was like being devoured by a pack of wild beasts, but in a sexual way!

At this point, Erin saw Gary was getting hard again, so she pointed it out, "Looks like there's something going on in those pants," and went on to suggest, "You should take those off again, and then you should fuck Katie properly."

Katie grunted in agreement and reached down to grab Gary's waistband.

Erin slapped her hand away and scolded her, "Lie back and relax! Let us ravish you. June can play with your pussy while I get him naked and ready."

So Katie laid back down and allowed June to climb over her into almost a 69 position. Katie could feel June's little tongue darting out over her pussy, and also had an unobstructed view of June's shaved pussy, which was inches from her face. Katie could even see traces of Gary's spunk from when he had cum in June a few minutes prior.

Katie then looked to the side and watched as Erin was sucking Gary's cock into a full erection. "This is crazy!" Katie thought to herself, before getting distracted by June's ministrations again.

Erin released Gary's cock from her mouth and guided it to Katie's welcoming slit, which June was holding wide open to accept the incoming intrusion.

"Wait!" June yelped, suddenly, then she popped her small mouth over Gary's bulging cockhead. She gave one small bob, and then released the appendage again, so Erin could place it against the entrance of Katie's slick hole.

Gary plunged all the way into Katie's welcoming love tunnel in a single, very slow thrust. He held himself buried all the way in her, while June rubbed her fingertips lightly in fast little circles around Katie's clit, and Erin caressed Katie's chest.

If she opened her eyes, Katie was treated to a view of June's youthful, but meaty shaved cunt swaying inches from her face. And if she closed her eyes, Katie could focus all her attention on the sensations

With the three people servicing her, Katie soon found herself swept away into the ecstasy of the pre-orgasmic frenzy. She felt the tingles from every kiss, caress, pinch, slap, and thrust, radiating from her nipples, neck, cheeks, thighs, pussy, and clit. The sensations added to each other and began to overwhelm her senses.

Gary, Erin, and June were all attuned to Katie's pleasure, and could feel that she was getting very close to an incredible orgasm. Erin made eye contact with Gary as she slid her hand delicately down from Katie's nipple to her clit, by June's hand.

Erin pushed down on top of June's hand and began rubbing June's fingertips furiously over Katie's sensitive nub, as she maintained eye contact with Gary and began nodding vigorously and urging him to cum inside Katie. "Ok man, she's almost there. I want you to take her over the edge by exploding inside her!"

"I'm getting close!" Gary said huskily.

As he approached his orgasm, Gary admired his harem, entwined with each other so sensually. The three women, each one carrying one of his offspring, were a tangle of shapely legs, tits, asses, pussies, and faces. All of them willing receptacles for his cum!

It was with this last thought, that he locked eyes with his vigorously nodding Erin, his dominant breeding queen, and he felt his loins explode into Katie's already-fertilized womb.

Katie's eyes rolled back into her head as she felt the large cock within her begin to swell and twitch and spasm. In that instant, Katie felt her mind go completely blank, and she moaned wordlessly as her own orgasm roared throughout her body.

As soon as Gary was done depositing his load, he pulled out of Katie, and Erin ordered June to slurp it out, "Ok June, you get to do the honors. Please suck his cum out of her pregnant twat and hold it in your mouth. Don't swallow it!"

June took her job very seriously. She thoroughly licked and sucked as much of Gary's cum out of Katie's battered, hairy pussy before she dutifully showed the rewards of her efforts, and the three women leaned in to share a very cummy kiss.

Gary spoke up, "I think you ladies should each swallow some of that... you know... nutrients for the babies!"

He winked. And the three women all winked back and began licking the cum off of each other with exaggerated smacking sounds.

* * *

The next morning, Gary entered the pharmacy with some apprehension.

The pregnancy tests weren't behind the pharmacy counter, so he didn't need to interact with the pharmacist, who he had learned was June's father. But the tests were

right next

to the counter, and it would be hard to grab one discretely.

It had been awkward enough buying the first plan B pill, but then the pharmacist called him out for buying another one just a few weeks later, and had strongly recommended he invest in some condoms.

Gary grimaced as he thought about what sort of lecture he would have to endure if caught buying a pregnancy test now.

And Mr. Kim wouldn't even know that both the pregnancy test, and one of the 'morning after' pills were intended for his own sweet daughter, June, who Gary had been inseminating regularly now. The other pill Gary had purchased was for Mr. Kim's other daughter, Casey. Well, adopted daughter. She looked and acted nothing like June, but she still found her way into Gary's house and ultimately submitted to him and Erin.

Just like June, she had needed to make her way back home with a load of his potent sperm leaking out of her cunt, her panties getting soggier and soggier with every step.

Gary tried to be surreptitious as he bent over to inspect the tests on the rack. At-home drug tests, covid tests, blood sugar tests... he groaned as he through to himself, "Where is it?"

"Can I help you find something, sir?" a man asked in a quiet but stern voice.

Gary knew without looking that this was June's father. "Why didn't I send someone else to get it?" Gary asked himself silently as he mentally prepared to turn around and engage with Mr. Kim.

"Umm... hi. Yes...." Gary started nervously. "I'm having difficulty finding a pregnancy test."

The pharmacist's eyebrows raised up inquisitively. "For the same lady you got the Plan B pill for?"

"Um yes... just as a precaution! She's a nervous type." Gary said defensively. "Not that it's any of your business..."

"I see..." Mr. Kim said with a very judgmental tone.

He continued, "Very chivalrous of you to be buying these things for her... any other reason she couldn't get them here herself?"

Gary looked at him suspiciously, and gathered himself before he answered. "Well, actually,

Mr. Kim

, she was rather put off by the idea of interacting with

you

. She is a sensitive soul, and has no interest in feeling your judgement."

The pharmacist bristled visibly as Gary continued, "If I'm to be perfectly blunt. I find it rather off-putting myself. What business is it of yours what kinds of sexual activities go on in this town?"

"Do you have any daughters, Mr. Marsh?" the pharmacist asked quietly. He continued on without giving Gary a chance to answer, "I have two teenage daughters, and I often lie awake at night, thinking about the cesspool of a world that they will undoubtedly need to contend with once they move out."

Gary shifted back and forth very uncomfortably as Mr. Kim went on, "Frankly it's people like you that I worry most about. Playing fast and loose as you stumble through your meaningless life, causing harm to those closest to you."

Gary's face flushed deep red in anger as the pharmacist continued his insulting diatribe, "If either of my daughters had the misfortune of getting mixed up with someone like you, I would fear for his safety..."

Gary drew himself up, trying to contain his emotions, and calmly stated, "I would like to speak with your manager, Mister.... Kim, is it?"

"You're speaking to him now," the pharmacist replied, puffing himself up, "Manager and proprietor... so if you have a complaint, you can leave. I am under no obligation to serve you."

"Maybe not, but if you had any decency-"

Mr. Kim interrupted, "Decency, Mr. Marsh? Speak for yourself! Do you know what kind of shame and dishonor you are bringing on yourself and your lady friend? If

you

had any sense of decency at all, you would marry her so you could support her, and

your child!

"