Kate's Story
"Hi there!" I said as Cyndi appeared from downstairs. "Get enough sleep?" It was nearly 10 AM, and I was setting out dishes while Jacob whipped up some pancakes. She walked over, wrapped her arms around me and kissed me. Her lips were warm and soft.
"Good morning my loves!" she said. "I hope you feel as good this morning as I do!"
"I guess you needed that more than we realized," Jacob said from his place at the griddle.
"I needed it more than
I
realized," she answered. She was wearing her skimpy outfit from last night, butΒ with the sun streaming through the kitchen windows, on an unseasonably warm day, her nipples were at parade rest. Marginally less distracting than last night.
"Sorry again about not telling you what was happening. We should have asked you at the start." I remembered how upset Cyndi had been when she thought Jacob had cheated on me with her.
"Water under the bridge. What do you want to do today?" she asked.
"That wasn't water," Jacob muttered under his breath.
"Let's go for a hike," I answered. "Have we told you about the Red Rise Trail?"
"I don't think so."
"That's the plan then. It's a great hike, and we've never seen more than two or three other people on it," I said.
"Sounds great," she replied. "How long is it?"
"About five miles."
"Is that too long for flip-flops?"
I gave her the side-eye "Seriously? Yes, you'll want real shoes."
"Shoot. Can we stop by my house and get my hiking boots on the way? Maybe some better shorts too. These aren't really appropriate." She gestured to the tiny satin pajama shorts. The top wasn't ideal for hiking either, barely covering her boobs. And she was going to want a bra.
"These are fine with me, if I get to walk behind you," Jacob said. I snorted, although the thought of her parading around looking like that was making me tingle. But she was right. Also, was that really all the clothing she had with her?
"Didn't you bring anything else to wear?" I asked.
"Just the jeans I had on. And they're too tight for hiking."
"That's all you brought for the whole weekend?"
"You said it was a slumber party!"
"Did you even bring a bra?"
"I was in a hurry," she explained. I rolled my eyes.
"Fine, we can stop by your place," I said. "Pick up whatever you need for the rest of the weekend." Sometimes I wondered how she remembered to eat.
"Cakes up!" Jacob announced. We sat down for breakfast.
"So, everything's still good?" I asked around a mouthful of flapjacks. "You're not feeling weird about sleeping with your friends?"
"Feels surprisingly... normal?" she replied. "How about you guys? I know it's weirder for you, Kate. You still sure you're not a lesbian?"
I laughed. "Considering what Jacob and I did last thing before sleep, I guess not. Besides, I didn't even taste your bread pudding."
She laughed. "So, not 100% sure yet?"
"Well I guess I can't know for certain until we, uh..."
"Until you lick my pussy?" she finished helpfully.
"Yes," I replied. "Until I lick your pussy. And make you come," I added for good measure. I was determined to get over the not-a-lesbian-dammit phase I didn't know I was in until last night.
She smiled and jiggled her chest at me.
"Well I wasn't planning to have a hard-on for breakfast," Jacob chimed in. "But here we are."
"Ooh, that sounds delicious!" Cyndi exclaimed, before bringing us back to Earth. "We do need to talk about where this is going, though. Last night was amazing," she continued. "But we need a clear set of rules. What we each want, what we don't want. I promise you it's better to do that now."
"Of course," Jacob answered proudly. "We already made a set of rules."
"They might have been slightly under-thought," I added.
"Oh? What did you come up with?" she asked.
We showed her the list we had made before inviting her over:
1. No Penis-In-Vagina sex
2. Jacob makes the first move
3. After that, let Cyndi lead
4. No watching or joining in (unless overridden by rule #3)
"Oh, that's so sweet!" she said. "Thank you for letting me lead. It would have been better to let me know the plan up front though." She narrowed her eyes.
My heart twisted in my chest. "I know!" I blurted. "I'm so sorry!"
"Apology long since accepted," she said, laughing. "Consider it a learning experience. But, you did pretty well overall. Writing it down is a great idea. It does need some, uh, fleshing out." She grinned.
I rolled my eyes. "Like what?"
"Well for instance, according to the list, anal is okay. Is that what you intended?"
We both burst into laughter. "That's exactly what J said," I explained.
"Okay, that's funny," she admitted, "And...?"
"The rules say it's okay," I responded.
She raised an eyebrow. "Are you sure? Would you really be okay with Jacob fucking my ass?"
"Would
you
?" I asked.
"That's not the question," she replied. "I need to be sure you've thought about the consequences of your rules. You should ask yourself why you're okay with him fucking my ass but not my pussy," she said.
"Um, well we haven't ever done anal," I said. "So it feels like it doesn't count as sex? And it's more about lust than intimacy anyway."
"Don't be too sure. Think about this: He would only be getting ass from me, while he gets pussy from you all the time. I'd be giving him something you don't. Is that a situation you want? I'm not saying it's wrong! But you should think it through. You can learn a lot by asking why you feel the way you do. What are your no-nos, your kinks, and so on."
"I guess I hadn't thought so far upstream."
"No hurry answering, just something to consider. So, you've never had anal sex?"
"We've played around with fingers there, but only a little. I want to do more, but I've been too nervous to try," I answered.