Please rate and comment. Your input helps writers improve. Thank you!
That evening they checked the new email and TwoforYou still hadn't replied, but they had a message from Downforitall:
"Hi V and T. Thanks for finding my profile attractive I'd love to get to know you and see if there is mutual attraction. Here's my phone number so you can call using *67 to hide your number from me. That way if it doesn't work out you don't have to worry about me harassing you. Don."
"Well that's a bit of a change," Vickie said. "Apparently real name and phone number and willing to trust us while allowing us to 'hide'."
"I agree. Should we give him a call?" Ted said.
"Let's," Vickie replied as she keyed *67 followed by his number into her phone and set it on speaker. It rang through and moments later they heard "Hello?"
"Hi Don, this is Vickie and Ted from the adult site," Ted said. "Is this a good time to talk?"
"Oh, hi! Absolutely! I think we all know the basics from our profiles - age, situation, interests, etc. So let's jump right into what you guys are looking for? How do you see things going?" Don said.
Vickie replied. "Don, Ted and I have done a few threesomes with another woman but never another man. We think we want to try that. But, total disclosure, it's possible we might start and one of us chicken out."
Don chuckled. "No worries. I chickened out my first time. I thought I was all down for it but when I saw his naked cock I just got the heebie jeebies"
"Why?" Ted asked.
"I was suddenly afraid he wanted to fuck my ass and I'm not into that. I like anal as a top but I'm not interested in being a bottom," Don admitted.
"That's fine, I feel the same way. And I'm not interested in topping a man," Ted replied.
"So what do you want," Don asked.
"I want to be spit roasted and maybe DP," Vickie answered. "But Ted is the only one to get my ass."
"Where am I in the spit roast," Don asked.
"Both. I want you guys to switch part way through. If we do this I'll decide at the time who I want to cum where and you'll start in the other hole," she said.
"Fair enough," Don said.
"Don," Ted said, "You said in your profile that you would never want to come between a couple. What if we hook up, you love it, but we don't want a repeat? How would you handle that?"
"Ted, been there, done that. Look, I like sex and I really don't want any kind of relationship at this point. I'm enjoying playing the field, except for the frequent STI tests I have to take every time one connection ends and I start another. But, just so you know, I've already done that. I'm good to go, although I'll use a condom if that's your requirement."
"Okay Don," Vickie said, "thanks for chatting with us. Let Ted and I discuss this and I promise we'll get back to you by email either later tonight or tomorrow."
"Sounds good, thanks guys!" Don said, signing off.
"So what do you think?" Ted asked.
"I like him, as a candidate for our threesome," Vickie answered.
"Does that mean you want to hook up with him?"
"Yes, but how do you feel?" Vickie asked..
"Let me ask you this: how did you feel when you saw me fucking Julie? Were you jealous, upset, what?"
"I loved it. It turned me on big time. You are the person I will always love the most for the rest of my life. Julie made you feel good and I want you to feel good. It didn't take anything away from me or us, it added something."
"Very open-minded. I'll be honest and say that while I love you more than I thought possible, I'm not sure how I'll feel when I see his cock in your mouth or pussy. But we need to find out, so let's do it," Ted said.
"Are you sure?" Vickie asked.
"No, but there's only one way to find out. Email Don and set something up before he finds another opportunity."
Shortly after she emailed Don he replied. "Great! How's Friday night?"
Ted was reading over her shoulder and nodded yes, so Vickie replied to Don's email with her phone number and their address. She proposed eight p.m. so they wouldn't have to deal with dinner.
Don arrived right at eight Friday night. Ted and Vickie greeted him at the door and Ted fixed drinks for everyone. They chatted about work, weather, and so on while they finished their drinks. Then Vickie went over to the chair Don was sitting in and held out her hand. When he stood up she put her arms around him and kissed him, one eye on Ted the entire time.
Ted understood what she was doing, smiled, and gave her a thumbs up. Vickie began undressing Don while Ted undressed himself and then started removing Vickie's clothes. Ted spread Vickie's yoga mat out on the living room floor and she knelt down on all fours.
"I want Don to start in my pussy and finish in my mouth. Are you okay with that, hon?" she asked Ted.
"Yes, whatever you want babe. This is all about you," he replied honestly.