"I just got hung up is all, it's fine."
"Hung up where?" Hailey pressed.
"The gym. I was at school, you know, pumping," he paused, his brain fog lifting a little. "Pumping iron, working out, you know. Gotta stay strong for the team."
"Football practice ended two hours ago, Clay," Hailey continued, but Clay simply didn't react. He seemed more high than drunk, but it was even less like Clay to do any kind of drug, especially during football season. "Whatever, let's just go inside. Your house is as good as mine, I guess," she finally said. "Even though
my
parents aren't home..." she grumbled lowly.
They went inside and Hailey continued to try to figure out what was wrong with her boyfriend. Her annoyance with him for being late was starting to turn into concern. He really didn't seem like himself. Hailey finally gave up trying to figure it out, and it became apparent that they were not going to be doing anything sexual that night. Hailey eventually tucked her loopy boyfriend into bed and settled in beside him to go to sleep.
A few hours later, Hailey woke up to Clay gyrating in the bed beside her. He seemed pretty out of it, but his hips were moving rhythmically and causing the bed to squeak. Damn teenage boys and their wet dreams, Hailey thought to herself. By the look of the tented sheets and the pace of his thrusting, she was going to be spending the rest of the night next to a pool of her boyfriend's cum. Gross.
Hailey thought about waking him up, but she wasn't sure that would do any good. Impulsively, Hailey pushed herself up onto her sleep-fucking boyfriend and straddled him, letting his thrusting cock press up against her panties. Better for him to cum in her pussy than all over the sheets, right? Hailey cringed again at the thought of getting the stuff on her body in the night.
Hailey pulled her panties to the side and slid down onto Clay's rigid dick as he continued to thrust into the air, still completely oblivious to her presence. Hailey moaned quietly as Clay filled her, placing one hand on the wall above the bed to brace herself and letting the other move down to start rubbing her clit along with the rhythm of Clay's thrusting.
Clay started to whimper to himself, and Hailey grabbed his hands and placed them on her breasts as she rode him, rubbing her clit with increasing intensity. His hands reflexively massaged Hailey's perky 18-year-old tits and his moans became higher pitched and more desperate. Hailey could tell he was about to cum, and was doing her best to hold back her own orgasm until the last moment. She loved when they came together. It was so intimate and beautiful. They were so connected.
Finally, Clay's whimpers turned into a deep groan as he started to cum. Hailey could feel Clay's dick spasming inside her pussy, and she finally allowed herself to crest the peak of her own orgasm. Right as Hailey's eyes rolled back in ecstasy, she heard Clay moan, "Bree..."
Past the point of no return, Hailey was unable to stop herself from cumming even as her boyfriend muttered someone else's name. Her anger fueled the intensity of her orgasm as she pulsed and quaked on top of him.
"What the fuck, Clay?!" Hailey yelled at him as soon as the waves of pleasure subsided enough to let her think again. In her anger, she smacked him in the shoulder, but even throughout their entire session, Clay apparently had not woken up. Hailey shook him as she slid off of his flaccid dick trying to get his attention. But nothing was happening. She even pulled his eyelids up, but his eyes remained completely unfocused. He didn't even really seem asleep, just somehow dazed. Ugh, what the hell, she thought to herself. First he stands her up with a really lame excuse, and then he dream-fucks some other girl? What the hell was his problem?
Hailey got up and put her clothes back on, deciding she couldn't stand to spend one more minute with Clay. He was probably faking being asleep anyway, to get out of having to explain why he had said another girl's name during sex. As she closed the bedroom door, a flicker of doubt and remorse escaped to the surface, but she quickly pushed it back down as she left Clay in a stupor and went home for the rest of the night.
* * * * *
The next morning at school, Hailey was still seething about Clay calling out another girl's name during sex and could barely focus on her studies. It wasn't helped by the fact that Bree Stevens was sitting a few rows ahead of her in English class, looking as effortlessly beautiful as always.
Emery High wasn't quite small enough for Hailey to know every student's name, but she definitely knew who Bree was, and she was fairly certain that was who Clay had been moaning about in his sleep. With Bree somehow on the field hockey, soccer, and track teams, Clay on the football team, and Hailey captain of the cheerleading squad, they had all spent a lot of time at school tournaments together over the past four years, even though Hailey didn't know Bree very well. In previous years, Bree seemed to really only care about the competitive side of sports, pretty much a classic female jock type. She had always been pretty, but lately, Bree seemed... more feminine, and more mature, somehow. Hailey couldn't quite put her finger on it, but she didn't like it.
Barely registering Miss Davis's voice lecturing about commas or something, Hailey spent all of senior English staring daggers at the back of Bree's head. As mad as Hailey was at Clay, the more Hailey thought about it, the more she started to get suspicious of Bree. Why would Clay be dreaming about Bree in the first place? They weren't friends, and Clay had basically no free time. Even if he wanted to, when would he find the time to start a thing on the side with Bree? The football team and the field hockey team didn't really even hang out all that much. And Clay had been acting
really
weird yesterday. And he hadn't come to school today. Something was definitely off.
Hailey let out a little gasp to herself as she had a thought. What if Bree had, like, drugged Clay or something! He wasn't calling out her name during sex, he would never do that. He was accusing her! He was trying to tell me who did that to him! It must be.
Hailey made up her mind to follow Bree and see if she could figure out what that bitch was up to. There wasn't much to report by the end of the day, and Hailey had to go to cheer practice, so she decided to keep tailing Bree every day until she found out what was going on.
Hailey kept at it for the rest of the week. Every day, she followed Bree around from a distance, watching any time she was near a guy to see if she could catch her drugging someone. But Bree really didn't seem to do much at all. She'd talk to guys, and she spent a lot of time staying after class in some of the teachers' offices, but Hailey never caught her with any kind of powder or trying to slip anything in anyone's drinks. And all this time, Clay still hadn't come back to school. Hailey had gone over to his house after he hadn't come the first day, but his mother just said he wasn't feeling well, and that he'd be back in school in a few days. He'd responded to a few of her texts, so she knew he was conscious at least.
Hailey was getting just about bored enough with this whole endeavor to give up when she caught Bree doing something strange. She had gone into a classroom alone with one of the members of the chess team, which was already pretty odd on its own. But before that she had been kind of, flirting with him. Her body language had gotten all loose, and she had just kind of, walked away from him. And the guy had followed her immediately, like some switch had flipped in his brain. Hailey followed the two of them and peaked through the small window in the door to see what was going on.
Hailey watched the whole show. She watched Bree move from position to position as this random nerd actually pulled out his dick and started to beat his meat right in front of her! This was so weird. Bree could have basically any guy she wanted, and could probably get them to
do
anything she wanted, and she was spending her time giving a strip-tease to a chess geek while he jerked off without even touching her? Bizarre. Maybe she was getting paid? Had
Clay
paid for a lap dance with the school slut? Hailey started seething again as she imagined her boyfriend jacking off to Bree like that. In her anger, she kept watching, her hands clenching in rage as she witnessed the obscene display. She leaned a bit too far and accidentally pressed on the handle, causing the classroom door to swing open and Hailey to fall into the classroom.
Bree spun around from her position in annoyance. Bree looked Hailey up and down with derision.
"What are you doing in here?" Bree demanded.
"Hey, I just caught you doing something super inappropriate," Hailey responded defensively. "I could get you in so much trouble. I don't think you have any right to ask what
I'm
doing."
Oddly, despite being interrupted and caught in the act, the chess geek was still just sitting there masturbating.
"What is wrong with you?!" Hailey squealed at him when she realized this. The nerd didn't seem to even register the question, and just continued stroking himself as he stared at Bree, seemingly oblivious to Hailey. He did seem to be getting a bit more agitated, though. And he was starting to whine.
"You did something to him," Hailey said. "And you did that same something to Clay! You drugged them or something!"
"Or something," Bree said, rolling her eyes. "And what are you going to do about it, princess?"
"I'll tell them what you did!" Hailey responded.
"Who? And who's going to believe you? Face it, blondie, your boyfriend just wasn't that loyal. Guess you just weren't doing it for him. You go around telling people I screwed your boyfriend, they're just going to think less of you anyway. Poor Hailey, can't keep her guy. And so she lashes out at the other woman even though
he
was the one who cheated. Slut-shaming prude. Not very feminist of you, Hailey. Where's that sisterly spirit?"
"I'll tell the principal that you had sex on school grounds, during school hours. I don't even have to mention Clay," Hailey said desperately.
"What makes you think I won't just "drug" the principal, if you're so sure that's what I'm doing?" Bree asked deviously. Hailey paused, unsure of herself or what she could do.
"Get out of here, Hailey. Fred and I here aren't quite finished," Bree said dismissively, turning back toward her victim. The chess geek moaned at the mention of his name, increasing the pace of his masturbation.
"I'm going to go get the principal. See how he likes this little strip club you've started. I'll tell him the boys are paying you for lap dances. You'll get expelled for being a literal whore," Hailey responded, feeling more and more heated as she continued her threats.
Bree exhaled strongly at that. "No, you're not going to do that," she said, turning carefully back to face Hailey.
"What, are you going to stop me?" Hailey asked with false bravado. "You haven't touched my drink," she continued, less and less sure of herself.
"I don't need to mess with your drink," Bree said dryly. "I just have to look at you the right way, and you won't be able to stop thinking about your desire for me."