Birthday Pool Party

Hey guys, here's Chapter 21! I hope you enjoy Part 03 of the spring break arc. Thank you for all the comments and reviews on the previous chapters, they mean a lot to me. As always, this is a world without STI's, and every person engaging in sexual activity is at least eighteen years old.

-Witty

Steven

I wake up Tuesday morning with my arms around Lexi's naked body. My morning wood is currently sandwiched between her butt cheeks. Reaching up, I brush a lock of Lexi's auburn hair out of the way so I can lean in and kiss her neck.

"Mm, that feels nice, Baby." Lexi coos as she pushes her body back against mine.

"Good." I reply as I continue to plant kisses all along her pale neck.

"What time is it?" Lexi asks in a sleepy voice as my hand runs along her side.

"Just after seven in the morning." I answer before nibbling on her ear.

"Nice and early." she moans softly as she grinds her butt against my erection. "Fuck, you're big."

"Fuck, you're gorgeous." I whisper in her ear.

"Push it in me from behind?" Lexi asks.

"Sure." I say with a smile.

I grab the covers and toss them off of us, revealing our naked bodies. Taking Lexi's left thigh in my hand, I help her lift her leg, exposing her pussy. She then reaches between us and grasps my shaft. It takes some maneuvering, but soon I'm slotted at her opening. Then I push inside.

"Oh, fuck yes." Lexi moans softly.

"Feel good?" I ask as I start slowly pumping in and out of her.

"Yes!" Lexi hisses. "You're stretching me so good, Baby!"

For several minutes, I hold Lexi's leg in the air as I slowly work my dick in and out of her. Eventually, her body tenses as an orgasm washes over her. Feeling her vaginal walls convulsing around me triggers my own release, and I flood her womb with my seed.

"Mm, cum inside me! Yes!" Lexi groans as the feel of my cum pumping into her causes her to have another orgasm.

"Fuck, that was good." as my dick slips out of Lexi's sopping hole.

"I need to clean up." she says. "Since there's no one to eat the creampie."

"See if you can find out where Marcia ran off to." I reply.

"Will do." she nods.

Lexi slips a hand between her legs and cups her pussy. She then gets up on her knees and knee-walks to the edge of the bed. My girlfriend hops off the bed and starts waddling toward the bathroom. I admire her exquisite backside as she does so.

"That's adorable." I say.

"Fuck off!" Lexi calls out as she waddles out the door.

A minute later, Marcia walks in with a towel wrapped around her body. She looks really sexy with the towel tucked between her breasts. Her dark hair is wet and a strand is plastered to the side of her face. The nearly-nude girl pads her way into the bedroom and gives me her attempt at a strong smile.

"Good morning." Marcia says sadly. "I just passed Lexi when I left the bathroom. She was waddling."

"Morning, Beautiful." I reply. "Yeah, she had cum in her pussy."

"I don't feel beautiful." the quiet girl says.

"Ready to talk?" I ask.

"I think so." Marcia nods as she sits down on the edge of the bed.

"Good." I say as I sit up. I then scoot over to sit beside Marcia.

"I'm so sorry, Steven!" Marcia exclaims as the tears start flowing.

"You have nothing to be sorry for." I assure the distraught girl as I wrap an arm around her bare shoulders.

"I let another man fuck me!" Marcia sobs as she rests her head on my shoulder. "I was just trying to convince myself I'm not in love with you and I can sleep with another man. Now Ashley hates me, and you hate me!"

"Neither of us hate you." I say. I choose to ignore her comment about being in love with me. The poor girl is distraught enough.

"You didn't hear Ashley screaming at me!" Marcia blubbers. "Tom was inside me and she was calling me a whore! And she's right!"

"No, she's not." I say as I lean over and kiss the top of of Marcia''s head. "I love you girls, and I know how close you are. You'll get through this. We'll get through this. Together."

"You shouldn't love me, I'm a whore!" Marcia screeches.

"No, you're not!" Lexi's voice calls out.

Marcia and I both look up to see a naked Lexi standing in the doorway. Lexi walks into the room and sits on the bed, on Marcia's other side. She then puts her arm around the distraught girl so that we both are holding her.

"I am!" Marcia whines.

"Stop. Marcia? Stop!" Lexi states firmly.

"Sorry, sorry! I'm sorry!" Marcia hiccups.

"You are a good person. Probably the best of all of us, in fact." Lexi says as she leans over to kiss Marcia's cheek.

"I don't feel that way." Marcia mumbles.

"Why don't you tell us what happened?" I suggest.

"That's a good idea." Lexi adds. "Start talking."

"After Ashley fell asleep, I went inside to say goodbye to everyone." Marcia begins. "I didn't see Hazel or Kayla anywhere, so I was about to leave when I turned around and ran right into Tom. He said he wanted to see how the party was going inside. I told him that I couldn't find my friends and he said we could look for them together.

"We walked around for awhile but didn't see them. So, I suggested that I should just leave. He said it would be a shame if I left so early, then he was talking about how pretty I am and, and, and, I'm not even sure how it happened, but I agreed to hang out with him in his bedroom!

"He kissed me! He's really cute, and I was horny, so I kissed him back. Then I felt his hand go up my skirt. I-I didn't stop him. I was going to, I felt so guilty about what I was doing to you, Steven, but I couldn't bring myself to stop him. I just kept telling myself that I can't be in love with you and that you want us to be happy so I should do this. He was fingering me and it felt so good, and next thing I knew I was naked and he was on top of me! In me."

"You didn't do anything to me. You were having fun." I say.

"Then Ashley walked in?" Lexi asks.

"Yes!" Marcia whines. "He didn't make me cum, but it still felt good. I was moaning, and having fun. Then all of a sudden I heard Ashley calling me a whore."

"She shouldn't have said that." I state firmly.

"Tom pulled out of me and got up." Marcia says. "He tried to calm Ashley down, but she just ran out of the room after looking down at me with my legs spread and my tits out! I closed my legs and sat up, and Tom, Tom just wanted to go back to fucking. I told him I didn't want to do it anymore and got dressed. I left him standing there naked."

"I guess you gave him blue balls!" Lexi giggles.

"Yeah, I kind of did." Marcia smiles in spite of herself.

"It sounds like you wanted to do it." I say.

"I did. I mean, a big reason was to prove to myself that I could do it, that I could be with someone else. But still, he was hot. I feel so ashamed, but I wanted him." Marcia admits. "I don't anymore! I swear, Steven, I don't anymore!"

"Marcia, you need to relax." Lexi says.

"You don't owe me an explanation. You're a free woman." I assure her.

"I just feel so bad. I was really horny and he was making me feel good." Marcia sighs.

"You don't have to feel bad." I insist. "I love you, Marcia."

"I love you, too!" Marcia gasps as she turns to me and throws her arms around my neck.

"See? He still loves you. Sleeping with a guy didn't make him love you any less." Lexi says as she rubs Marcia's back.

"But you're not in love with me." Marcia mumbles into my shoulder.

"I don't know." I admit with a sigh. "I feel very strongly about you, but I'm with Lexi."

"I'm sure there's room in his heart for us both." Lexi says with a soft smile.

"W-what about me being with other guys?" she asks with a whimper.

"If that's what you want, it's okay with me." I say. I mean it, too. I would be devastated if Lexi touched another man, but Marcia? I do love her, but I still don't know if it's the same way I love Lexi. It can't be. The way Lexi got so jealous over Stacey, she'd never accept a truly polyamorous relationship. "You like that guy from school, don't you?"

"Yes!" Marcia says. "I like Shawn, but I love you!"

"Hey, there's nothing wrong with that." Lexi assures Marcia. "Just like there's room in Steven's heart for all of us, it makes sense that you'd care for more than one guy."

"I love you both so much!" Marcia cries into my chest. "And I love the others! But now Ashley hates me!"

"I'm sure she doesn't hate you." I say.

"She said she did!" Marcia wails.

"She did?!" Lexi exclaims.

"Yes!" Marcia confirms. "She said it when I went back to the house to talk to her! Then I didn't know where else to go, so I came here and fell asleep crying on your bed. That's how you found me."

"I remember." I reply.

"Thank you for letting me sleep with you guys." Marcia mumbles.

"Anytime, Honey." Lexi says as she kisses the top of Marcia's head.

"That's why you're so upset?" I ask. "Because Ashley said she hates you?"

"Yeah." Marcia nods against my chest. "I've always been emotional, and my bond with all the girls means everything to me! I broke it!"

"Just because you slept with a guy Ashley likes?" I ask in confusion. "I get being a little annoyed, but really, she was just gonna have a fling with him, right?"

"Oh, Baby, you don't understand." Lexi says. "Girls are competitive. Ashley was on the fence about sleeping with someone else. She finally found a guy she wanted to do it with, finally got passed her fear of hurting you, then went to do it and found out Marcia beat her to it."

"Exactly." Marcia nods.

"I still think she's overreacting." I say.

"Oh, she definitely is." Lexi agrees. "But I'm just trying to explain why. Ashley was so worried about sleeping with another guy, she's horny, and part of her probably did think that Tom was her conquest. Then Marcia bagged him."

"You girls need to talk." I say.

"Yes, we do. We all do." Lexi says.

"Okay." Marcia mumbles. "Did I ruin everything?"

"No! I'm sure you didn't." I say. "I'm sure Ashley just reacted in the moment and now regrets what she said."

"And you still want me?" Marcia asks.

"Marcia, you are one of the most beautiful, sexy women I've ever known." I state firmly. "As long as Lexi is okay with it, I'm happy to keep having sex with you."

"And I'm perfectly fine with it." Lexi says with a smile. "I love you, Marcia."

Marcia lifts her head from my chest and looks into my eyes with a tear-filled gaze. "Make love to me?"

"Right now? Are you sure?" I ask.

"Unless you really don't want me anymore?" Marcia asks.

"I do, but I just came a few minutes ago." I explain.

"Let me get you hard again with my mouth!" Marcia offers as she stands up and spins around to face me.

The gorgeous, young woman drops her towel, showing me her naked body. Marcia really is stunning. She's short, with wavy dark hair. Her breasts are large and full and perfectly-shaped. Her entire body is tight and smooth.

"How can you refuse?" Lexi asks with a giggle.

My girlfriend gets up and walks across the room to where the small chair is. She spins the chair around so that it faces the bed and plops her naked ass down onto it. Crossing her legs, she looks over at us.

"I'll just watch. You two have fun." Lexi says.

"Please?" Marcia asks as she walks up to me.

Marcia places her hands on my knees and slowly spreads my legs. She then drops to her knees between my spread legs. The quiet girl looks up at me with pure lust and love in her eyes. I can't help but smile.

"Please let me suck your cock." Marcia begs.

"Okay." I state simply after glancing at Lexi and getting her approval. We both know Marcia needs this. Needs to know we don't hold anything against her.

Marcia just smiles as she reaches out and takes my soft dick in her small hand. Lifting my member, she strokes it several times as she admires it. Then she leans down and kisses my tip before opening her mouth and taking me inside.

"Yeah, Marcia! Suck that dick!" Lexi encourages with a cheer and a clap.

"Mm!" Marcia hums around my cock as her hand cups my balls.

"That's it, Baby, suck me." I groan as I toss my head back.

The quiet girl works on me for the next minute, slurping on my dick. Her hand massages my balls as she moans around me. Despite my recent orgasm, Marcia's talented mouth is able to get me to full hardness. Soon, her little mouth is stretched wide around my thickness.

Marcia makes love to my cock with her mouth. She lashes the underside of my dick with her tongue as she massages my balls. Then she takes me out of her mouth and plants kisses all along the shaft while pressing her face against it.

"Damn, you give great head." I groan as I bury my hands in Marcia's dark hair.

"Mm, mm, mm." Marcia moans as she smiles around me.

"Fuck her titties!" Lexi shouts from her spot on the other side of the room.

"What do you say, Babe?" I ask while reaching down and taking a boob in each hand.

"I say, yes!" Marcia giggles after she spits out my cock.

I play with Marcia's breasts as the cute girl lifts her body so that her boobs are level with my cock. When I release her tits, Marcia takes my dick in hand and slaps first one boob, then the other with it. Marcia grabs her own boobs and wraps them around my cock. She then begins giving me an amazing tit-fuck.

"Fuck, this feels good." I grunt as I watch my dick slide between Marcia's breasts.

"I love your cock." Marcia coos as she holds her tits tightly around my shaft. "It's so big, so hard!"

"It's hard for you, you're so sexy." I reply.

"Mm, keep talking dirty!" Lexi encourages.

"I can't wait to feel you inside me." Marcia moans, her nipples rock hard. "You make me feel so good. So hot."

"Keep. Going!" I grunt.

"You're making me so wet. My pussy is dripping for you, Baby." Marcia says in a sultry voice. "I want you in me, fucking me with your big dick. I want you to make me scream!"

"Yes, I want to make you scream." I respond with a sharp nod.

"I wanna be your little Slut." Marcia announces. "I'll bend over for you, I'll spread my legs, I'll open my mouth, I'll do whatever dirty thing you want!"

"I need to be in you." I whisper urgently. Hearing the usually quiet girl talking so dirty is driving me crazy. "Get on the bed, get on the bed!"

I pull my cock out of Marcia's tits and help the dark-haired girl to her feet. As she climbs onto the bed, I give her ass a playful slap, making the cute girl cry out while her butt cheek ripples. Marcia lays on her back on the bed and spreads her legs. She then places her hand between her legs and runs her finger along her moist slit.

"Make love to me?" Marcia asks in a small voice.

"Fuck her, fuck her, fuck her!" Lexi cheers.

I don't respond with words. Instead, I make my way across the bed and settle into position on top of Marcia. I look down into her pretty eyes as I reach between us and grasp my erection. Then I rub my mushroom head along her labia before slowly easing myself inside of her.

"Fuck, you're tight!" I grunt as I place my hand on top of her head and mold my body to hers.

"Holy shit, you're stretching out my little pussy! Oh, my God!" Marcia gasps as her hands grip my biceps.

I place both my hands firmly on the bed, on either side of Marcia, as I start thrusting into her tight, young body. Marcia hooks her ankles around my calves and rolls her hips to meet my thrusts. Her breasts push out from her chest as her hands grip my back with desperate strength.

"Does that feel good, Marcia?" Lexi asks. "Do you like my big, strong boyfriend fucking you like the slut you are?"

"Yes! Oh God, yes!" Marcia calls out as she throws her head back against the pillow.

"You feel so good." I grunt as my thrusting speeds up.

Marcia's hands grip the sides of my face as she looks up at me, breathing and panting heavily. Her shapely legs wrap tightly around me; I can feel her heels on my ass. I lower my body so that my chest squishes her breasts as our bodies become one.

We continue making love for several minutes, our eyes locked. The two of us exchange soft kisses while I move in and out of her. As Marcia's panting intensifies, I feel my balls start to clench. We're gonna cum together. Just as Marcia cries out her orgasm, I bury myself to the hilt and explode in her tight, pink hole.

"Cum in me! Please, cum in me!" Marcia begs as she feels me squirting inside her.

"Yeah, fill her!" Lexi breathes.

"I love you." Marcia whispers at the end of her orgasm.

"I love you, too." I reply as I peck her lips.

"And I love you both!" Lexi chirps as she hops up onto the bed and gives my ass a light smack. "Now get out of her, Baby. I want the creampie!"

Laughing, I roll off of Marcia and lay down beside her. Marcia keeps her legs spread as Lexi kneels between them and sticks her face in the quiet girl's box. Marcia just giggles and grabs Lexi's auburn head.

"I love being part of this family!" Marcia laughs as she enjoys getting eaten out by Lexi.

"You're one of us." I say. "Fucking some guy doesn't change that."

Marcia smiles and runs her fingers through Lexi's hair. The redhead enthusiastically slurps all the cum she can get out of Marcia's tight twat while I run my fingers along Marcia's perfectly-shaped boob. She laughs when I roll her nipple between my fingertips.

"That feels good, keep doing it." Marcia giggles.

"You got it, Babe." I say as I continue playing with her titty.

"Sometime this week, I'm gonna give you my ass." Marcia says sincerely.

"Are you sure?" I ask as we listen to Lexi slurping away. "Last time the pain was too much."

"I remember, and yes, I'm sure." Marcia nods. "Remember, I told you to stick a finger up my ass? That felt so good. I can only imagine how great your cock will feel plowing me up the butt."

"If you're sure, I'm happy to try again." I reply.

"Great!" Marcia smiles. "Oh Lexi, that feels good!"

"Mm." Lexi hums against Marcia's box.

"Just remember, you can tell me to stop at any time and I will." I tell her.

"I know you will." Marcia responds, her grin broadening before it turns into a sexy grimace as she concentrates on the feelings Lexi's tongue is causing.

Once Lexi slurps all the cum out of Marcia's cunt, she climbs up Marcia's body and lays on the quiet girl's other side. Lexi and I both end up cuddling Marcia between us, whispering sweet words to the overwhelmed girl. All these girls really do mean the world to me.

"We're here for you." Lexi coos as she holds Marcia's head to her chest.

"Yes, we are." I agree.

"Ashley's so mad." Marcia mumbles.

"I know, Honey, I know." Lexi says. "But remember what we promised?"

"Slut-sisters forever?" Marcia answers.

"Exactly!" I say with a smile. "She's mad now, but she'll calm down. You two just need to talk."

"Okay, let's go talk to her." Marcia nods weakly.

"First, I need to shower." Lexi announces. "Come join me, Baby?"

"Sure." I agree.

"Have fun. I'll wait here." Marcia says.

Lexi and I walk out the bedroom door naked and make our way to one of the two bathrooms in the house. Soon, we're standing under the hot water together. That's when Lexi turns to me, her hands on her hips.

"Are you in love with Marcia?" she asks.

"I don't know." I answer honestly.

"Are you in love with Ashley and Hazel?" Lexi follows up with.

"I don't know." I repeat as I watch the hot water running down Lexi's nude frame.

"My eyes are up here, Babe." Lexi says with humor in her voice.

"Sorry." I mumble as I look into her eyes and am relieved to see she doesn't seem upset.

"What are you gonna do?" she asks with a small smile.

"You're not upset?" I ask.

"No." Lexi says plainly.

"You were pretty pissed about Stacey." I point out. "And worried I'd leave you."

"That's because Stacey isn't family. Marcia, Hazel, and Ashley are." Lexi explains. "Stacey works with you, she's closer to you in age. I thought she could steal you away from us. Us. Not just me."