I swam over to where Hayley and Heather were and noticed Heather had taken her top off. She had nice breasts. Age was pulling them down like mine but they were still nice. Her nipples were a dusky pink with darker pink surrounding them. Her breasts were not as pale as mine so I assumed she must sunbathe topless back in Denver.
"How was it with John?" she asked.
I shivered but not from cold. "Delicious," I answered. "I'm going to need more of that," I grinned.
"Leslie is very protective of him," Heather warned. "If she allowed that, she's probably okay with you having more."
Hayley looked concerned. "What if she didn't?"
Heather shrugged. "I guess we'll know in a minute because here he comes."
I turned around and sure enough, John was at the steps of the pool in all his naked glory. I watched him descend. His cock had softened a little but was still thick. I remembered what he said even though the sight of it made me salivate a bit. I was still very aroused and yet my mouth was where I wanted him. Thinking about what Heather said I wondered if he and Leslie had an agreement like Nick and I had made before the Halloween party. Maybe they played but at the end of the night, John only came with Leslie, or at least, with her agreement?
We heard noise from the table area and watched as Leslie stood up from Nick's lap and walked toward us. She pulled her top and bottoms off before diving into the water. That left three horny men at the table by themselves. I watched as each one stood and walked to the pool. When they were lined up at the edge of the water, Heather, Hayley, and I started humming the intro to The Stripper. Duh duh duh duuuunn, duh duh duuuhh dun... Leslie turned to watch as well. They did not disappoint.
All three turned their backs to us, linked arms, and began kicking their legs up in unison. We continued humming and after a few seconds they stopped and slowly pulled their suits down, revealing their ass cheeks. We laughed and called for more so they shook them at us. They turned around and all three were holding their suits so they wouldn't fall off.
"Take it off," we chanted as they thrust their hips in our direction. I heard John ask Leslie if she enjoyed sitting on Nick's lap. As the guys continued their show, she told him she did but that she really needed to play. I didn't know what she meant and couldn't hear the rest of their conversation because the guys were finally lowering their suits to show us what they'd been hiding. I knew Nick and David had generous portions of cock so I was ready to see Ethan's.
"Come play," Hayley called as their suits fell to the walkway.
"Oh my," I gasped. Ethan's cock was long and lean like the rest of him. He was circumcised like the others and also like them, sporting some tasty looking wood. My clit throbbed and my nipples tightened in spite of the warm water. My brain said I had to share since there were four of us and four guys but oh how I wanted both John's thicker cock and Ethan's long one.
I shook my head to dispel the image that rose of Ethan fucking me while I sucked John. It was then that I noticed what was happening beside me. Leslie had one of Hayley's breasts in her hand and she was plucking at the nipple. I watched even as I heard the splashes from the men getting into the pool. Hayley was enjoying the attention so much that she closed her eyes when Leslie sucked the nipple inside her mouth. I couldn't look away until I felt hands touching me. I turned and there was Ethan.
"Hi," he said as his hands softly enclosed both my breasts.
"Hi," I answered as I turned away from the others. I cupped his cheek and brushed my thumb across his stubbly face. "Did you leave this just for me?" I knew he hadn't since he didn't even know me or how much I enjoy whiskers against my skin.
"No. It was a happy accident," he said as he pulled me closer to him.
I tipped my head back and bared my neck for him. "Do it again, please," I pleaded. He brushed his chin across my neck and my pussy made me beg him to do it more. He did it again while nuzzling the junction where my neck meets my shoulder. I assumed that if Heather had any reservations, she'd have mentioned them when she told me about Leslie's. I felt the head of Ethan's cock brush my thigh. It was then that I felt someone against my back. I assumed it was one of the girls but then I felt hands on my hips. They pushed my lower body closer to Ethan's.
I moaned and turned to see who it was as they lifted me up so my breasts were no longer under water. It was John! He held me up so Ethan could take one of my nipples into his mouth. John's head was slightly behind me as I turned toward him. He kissed me, all while holding me up for Ethan to nip and suck my nipples. My pussy throbbed and leaked fluid into the pool. I so needed to be filled with something. I gasped into John's mouth when Ethan pulled his head back while holding a nipple between his teeth. He stretched my breast out further and I whimpered. John's mouth released me just as Ethan let go of my nipple. I felt Ethan's cock move between my thighs. "Oh God, was I gonna get my wish?" I wondered.
I felt the head of Ethan's cock push against my outer lips. I kicked my legs a bit to lift myself higher. Ethan spread them wide apart and slid right into my slippery cunt. It was heaven as my inner muscles clamped down on him. He pulled me tight against him and just held me there while my entire body throbbed with delight. John released me and moved around so he could watch us.
"I really need to fuck you hard," Ethan groaned as he finally lifted me up and let me slide back down over him. "This water won't let me," he said as I agreed.
"Then let's get out," I moaned. My previous orgasm was forgotten, replaced by the desire to be used hard. Ethan lifted me up and let me slide down one more time. It was slow and wonderful but not what either of us needed right now. He reluctantly slid out of me and we swam to the stairs. The yard beyond the path had an old-fashioned picnic table complete with attached benches sitting in the grass. Ethan pulled me toward it. As we rounded the walkway, we heard David call us.
"Come give her a hand," he said.
Hayley was at the edge of the pool lifting her arms toward us. Leslie was staring at her, one hand hidden underwater while the other partygoers floated nearby. Ethan reached down and grasped her upper arm. I did the same and while Leslie and John pushed, we pulled Hayley from the water. She turned and sat on the edge with her legs still in the water. She reclined and used her elbows for support while Leslie moved between them. I watched as Leslie pushed the sides of Hayley's slit open and licked her from her hole to her clit.
Ethan grabbed me and pulled me toward the picnic table. He hadn't forgotten what we were going to do even if I was momentarily distracted! I watched Nick pull Heather close and kiss her as David moved up behind Leslie. Ethan got my attention back so I didn't see John heading for the stairs.
"Lie down," he commanded. I put my butt on the edge of the table and complied.
He lifted my feet high in the air and walked up to rub his cock on my pussy. It felt so good. He held my legs together so my lips couldn't open. He just gently thrust back and forth over the outside. Then he pushed the head inside and kept pushing until he slid into my hole. I was so excited I nearly climaxed just from that. He pulled my legs apart and drew back while I moaned at the loss. When the tip pulled free, he thrust forward, purposefully sliding his slick tool over me so the bulbous tip banged into my clit. It was wonderful. The next thrust put him back in my hole just as I heard Hayley exclaim that she was cumming.
We both looked over at the pool and Leslie's face was still between Hayley's legs. Her arms were around Hayley's thighs holding her legs apart while her lips and tongue did whatever they were doing to the stiff clit in her mouth. David was behind Leslie, holding her low against him so I suspected his cock was inside her. Nick appeared to be slowly fucking Heather beside them while still in the pool. He had one of her nipples in his mouth and didn't even look up when Hayley cried out. I would probably have been more interested in all the action if Ethan hadn't chosen that moment to start thrusting into me again. His cock was so long that he was holding back to keep from bottoming out in my pussy.
I hadn't seen John and just then I realized why. He was standing beside the table slowly stroking himself. He could see us and the action at poolside. Ethan's strokes were getting faster as I gripped the edge of the table. I looked up as he put my feet on his shoulders and changed the angle of his thrusts again.