I then take matters into my own hands (literally) and pull James back onto the couch. I reach out both hands and grab each shaft, getting my first look and feel of the couple's packages. Both were pretty average-sized, both cut, and both absolutely rock hard. I stroke for a minute and we continue to make out, but I then eagerly slip to my knees and start blowing them, alternating every few seconds so as to not leave anyone out. After a few minutes of back and forth, I look up at them, almost as if to say "well, what else do you want?" With that, Matt stands up and moves towards me, placing his cock in front of my face. I eagerly take it in my mouth, sucking him off and stroking his shaft simultaneously. James, meanwhile, is stroking himself on the couch. After a minute of this Matt speaks: "Would you be open to sucking off James after I cum on his cock." Never did that before, but definitely was up for it. I took my mouth off of his dick just long enough to say "absolutely."
So James is on the couch, stroking himself to the sight of me giving his partner a blowjob. I continue to work Matt's cock for a while, stroking myself as I do. But after a few more minutes, Matt is obviously ready to blow. With one final pump of his shaft, he gently pulls out of my mouth and turns to James. I scurry to the couch to make sure I'm ready (plus I wanted to see him unload), and Matt strokes himself just a few more times before unleashing a pretty sizeable load right onto his partner's cock. Most of it made it on to James' dick, with a big on his stomach. He bends a bit, rubbing his cock on James', making sure to get the last remnants off. Then, without hesitation, I dive in. My mouth envelops James' head - the familiar taste of thick, salty cum hitting my tongue. I'll be honest, I swallowed some right off the bat - but the rest I used on James, both with my mouth and with my hand.
Matt collapsed to the couch, just watching me work over his man. I did so for another few minutes - but then James gave me the warning: he was going to unload. I kept sucking and stroking (i was kinda messy at this point), he tensed up and then delivered another solid load (a bit smaller than Matt's) directly into my mouth. This one I swallowed immediately. I made sure to clean him up before crawling back to the couch and dropping between them.
They got close and we began to make out again, with both sets of hands again working my own cock (im 5 inches cut). The makeout session became pretty intense - going back and forth between the partners as they stroked me. I'd never cum like this and the thought really expedited things. We couldn't have been going for more than a couple of minutes before I started moaning (I'm a moaner) - at which point they stroked harder and faster until I exploded. I came quite a bit, mostly on their hands, with a shot or two hitting my stomach. We made out a little more, got dressed, and went for a drink.
It was a really fun night with two really great guys. We have plans to go to a Yankee game together (seriously) and I'm sure that will lead to other stuff. All in all - total home run of a meetup (yea - sorry, I did it).