It was another Sunday morning at the Lake. Bill, Ted, Chris and myself used to meet there every weekend to take a swim. We had found a very secluded spot and we had the whole place to ourselves.
As time passed, the temperature rose. We had now reached noon, the hottest part of the day. The heat made me want to fuck. Yet, I knew that it wasn't going to be easy. Nobody knew I was gay and, what is more, none of them was into buttfuck or so I thought. I realised that I had to come up with a plan. If I could somehow force them to strip, then maybe I would get lucky.
We were all sitting on the grass wearing our bathing suits. Suddenly, I turned to Bill and started staring at his crotch.
"What are you looking at?" Bill asked.
"I was wondering if your dick is bigger then Ted's," I answered.
"Of course it is!" Bill exclaimed.
"You wish!" Ted said laughing.
"Mine's bigger!" Chris shouted.
"All right, all right! There's no need to argue. I know the perfect way to solve this. How about a little contest?" I asked.
"What kind of contest?" Bill asked eagerly.
"You'll strip and jerk off until you reach your full length. I'll decide whose tool is bigger," I said playfully.
"Deal!" Bill said.
"I'm in!" Ted exclaimed.
"Me too!" Chris said.
"I'll dive into the lake so as to give you the time you need to prepare yourselves," I said really excited.
"What about you, Doug?" Chris asked.
"I won't take part in the contest. It's the only way to be a fair judge. O.K. boys, show me what you got!" I said diving into the lake.
Instantly, my friends took off their bathing suits and started jerking off right in front of my eyes. It was a sight I could only dream of. While they were doing their best to impress me I pulled down my bathing suit. I wanted to get my ass wet for what I hoped would follow. A few minutes later, Bill told me to come out of the water. I pulled up my bathing suit and joined them. The three men were standing up and so were their cocks. I licked my lips as I carefully inspected each one. It was obvious that Chris was the biggest.
"Well, we have a winner and his name is Chris!" I said triumphantly.
"I guess you're right. But now I'm so horny I could fuck anything!" Bill said stroking his rod.
"Me too, man!" Ted exclaimed.
That was all I needed to hear. Right away, I turned my back on them, pulled down my bathing suit and bending over, I said:
"How about a tight, little asshole?"
Chris was shocked but Ted and Bill responded like I hoped they would. Bill approached me, slapped my butt and said:
"Looks like first class meat to me! What do you think, Ted?"
"I think we should screw his brains out!" he answered really excited.
"What about you, Chris?" Bill asked.
"No way, man! Only faggots do these things," Chris said disgusted.
"A real man can fuck any hole that's offered to him!" Bill said groping my butt.
"Just sit here and watch, Chris. By the time I'm done with those two you'll be begging me to shove this big cock of yours in my asshole!" I said.
I wasn't planning to let him go without tasting his massive erection. After all, he was the winner of the contest. But now I had to service Bill and Ted.
Bill stretched himself out on the grass and ordered me to sit on his cock. I obeyed, taking off my bathing suit. His tool had no trouble piercing my dripping-wet asshole.
"Yeah, fuck my ass!" I howled.
Bill started fucking me mercilessly. He was intoxicated by the tight grip of my hole. He grabbed my waist with both hands, pulling my ass towards his shaft.
"Shake your ass, Doug! I'm gonna ruin your tight hole!" he said in a frenzy of lust.