I can't even believe what just happened. I'm still in shock. I guess I don't have anyone to blame but myself. Let me explain. I'm a CL tease. You know the guy, answers ads and leads you along but never follows through. I'm that guy. I don't know why I do it, I'm happily married with a pretty decent sex life. I just like to tease guys, feel wanted. And let's face it, women get a lot of attention so they don't like to play. Guys are easy, just say you wanna suck their cock or you want your cock sucked and you can fill your mailbox with hot emails. It gets me off. Whatever.
So I answer an ad from an older man, 51 he said. He was looking for a regular cock to suck and maybe get sucked. He lived fairly local, too, about 15 minutes away. Perfect. I answered back, "I'm 35, 7c, curious". I always play the straight, curious guy. It gets more responses and I can lead the guy on a little longer. He answered right back...sucker!!
His name is Greg and he's gay. He also has a boyfriend, Joe, who is 53. They live together but have an open relationship so they can play if they find someone they like. Two guys to tease!! I reeled these two in, no problem. Endless emails and hot texts to both of them.
"I want you to take my man-ginity." I'd text them.
"I bet your mouth would feel so hot on my cock!!" I'd text another time.
Email got even hotter. Sometimes I'd have a few beers before emailing them and let it go a little further. "I wonder what it would be like to be on my knees and looking up at both of you...would you feed me your cocks?"
Joe was the rougher one. "I'd fuck your mouth and pump my load down your throat!" he'd reply.
"I want you all to myself so you could kiss and lick my cock. I'm sure you'll love the taste of my cum." Greg would say.
This back and forth went on for five or six months. We chatted about other things too, work, relationships, whatever. Turns out they are actually pretty nice guys. They were pretty funny sometimes, too. We developed a pretty good friendship over those months. I told them everything that was happening in my life. I felt incredibly comfortable with them. So when they offered to meet I didn't hesitate to agree.
My wife is away visiting family so we decided since we had the opportunity we would meet at a bar that was about two blocks from their house. I thought a public place would be best, just to be safe. They were really cool though. You'd never know they were gay. No fruity, flamboyant weirdos here. Just normal guys. Greg was slim, about 5-10, like me, with short salt and pepper hair. Joe was more burly, a bit shorter with a bit of a gut. He had brown hair. He looked younger than Greg. They were both decent looking guys, I guess. I couldn't have asked them to be nicer. We tossed back a few beers and did a couple of shots while we played a little pool. I was feeling pretty good when we decided to leave.
We left and headed over to their house. It was a pretty nice place, an old colonial set back from the street. We went inside and Joe got us a few beers to keep the fun going. It was still pretty early, the sun was still up though that's not unusual in the summertime. After a few beers Greg sat down next to me on the couch. I didn't think anything of it until he put his hand on my thigh.
I tensed up a little and Greg noticed. "It's OK, Just relax." he said as he began rubbing my thigh. It did feel pretty good. I'm sure the alcohol helped but no harm in a little leg rub. Then his hand slid up under my shorts and grabbed my cock! I gasped and looked over at him but I didn't stop him. I was frozen. He began massaging my cock under my shorts but through my underwear. Greg was looking me right in the eyes. He could see I was enjoying it. I closed my eyes and just enjoyed the stroking.
I was awaken from my trance by his lips touching mine. He squeezed my cock a little and I gasped, his tongue slipped into my mouth. It wasn't rough or harsh, it was actually nice. I got into it and began kissing him back. He pulled his hand out of my pants and began unfastening my shorts. He straddled me, taking my face in his hands and kissing me before sitting up and pulling off my shirt. He came back down nibbled on my bottom lip then kissed my chin and kissed and sucked my neck. He was driving me nuts!