Straight to Hell

Author's Note -- There are elements of non-consent in this story. If that type of element offends you, or is problematic, please do not read.

Chapter 3 -- Cousin Benjamin

Workouts. I love 'em.

There's something about watching a man work out that is highly erotic. True, muscular bodies are nice no matter what but I love watching how a man's muscles pump and flex as they work the weights. It's the way the veins stand out.... the curve of the muscle... the way it gives proportion to a guy's body.

"I'll spot you now, Mr. James."

Damn! Jose's voice broke my reverie as I was just starting to feel the beginnings of a nice erection.

"Jose, how many times do I have to tell you to call me Riley. You make me feel like an old man when you call me 'Mr. James'!"

Jose grinned and just shook his head. "Well, you are an old man compared to a young guy like me. But okay, no more 'Mister'. Just Riley, okay?"

I laughed and lightly punched Jose on his shoulder. "Old man? You may be a young stud but I ain't no old man. I like the word mature. It's more elegant!"

Jose kept laughing and playfully punched me back. "Whatever. Now get your ass down there and do your reps. Or is the 'mature' man worn out already?"

I snorted and lay down on the bench. "Fuck you, Jose!"

Jose grinned but I'm sure had no idea just how much I really did want to fuck him. Talk about a body! Jose wasn't huge but he looked damn good. Especially since his shape came from both the gym and just naturally hard work. Jose worked with the maintenance group at my company and he was kept busy with pretty physically strenuous work. Even in his work uniform, you could see his muscles teasing through his shirt. His pants showcased an ass that I thought might be worth investigating a little further.

I reached up to grab the bar and Jose moved behind me to spot me. I grinned as he moved into one of my favorite positions for my spotters. Flat on my back, looking up, my eyes could look at his crotch without being detected. And what a nice crotch it was to look at! I don't know what Jose is packing there but he has a bulge that pushes the material of his shorts out pretty good. And tonight it was an especially nice site. Jose was wearing some basketball style shorts that were pretty loose and allowed anyone below them to get a clear view of what was inside. And what a coincidence... I just happened to be below him lying on a weight bench!

As I got near my last rep, I started to struggle a little with the weight. Actually, I could easily lift it but I knew what a little struggle would do for me. Sure enough, ole Jose came forward to help grab the weight and guide it to the holder. His shorts were almost directly over my face and my eyes had a birds eye view to the top.

Shit! My first view up his shorts showed some beautiful smooth thighs. As my eyes snaked upwards, I saw a hefty pair of nuts encased in what could only be a jock strap. Unfortunately, that's all I had time for as Jose pulled the weight back and secured it.

"See, I toldja you were an old man! Hell, even I can lift that much weight!"

I laughed and let Jose think he was the stud. Little did he know that not only could I left that weight and more, that little struggle helped me decide that Jose was definitely my top straight boy candidate for a good fucking. I wondered how much of an old man he'd think I was when my cock was lodged up his tight little ass.

"Hey mijo, what's up?"

A new voice came from my right and I turned my head slightly to get a look at this intrusion. It sounded like one of Jose's running buddies and I didn't have time for that right now. Thinking about Jose had made my cock begin to stand up and take notice and I didn't want someone else to spoil my plans for getting it up Jose's virgin hole that night.

"BENJ! Que pasa?"

Benj? Who the hell was Benj? I turned my head further and saw a pair of massive thighs... smooth and heavily muscled surrounded by a tight pair of dark blue gym shorts. As my gaze went up, I almost shit a brick. The thighs came together at the crotch and a humongous bulge protruded from it.

"Nada, mijo. Just about to work out. I didn't know you were a member here."

"I'm not. Mr. James... errrrr... Riley brought me with him as his guest."

When I heard my name, I sat up and looked up at the rest of the man attached to the bulging crotch and muscular legs. As I looked at him, my gaze was immediately attracted to the front of his thin t-shirt, which was struggling to hold some enormous pecs.

"Hi! I'm Benjamin."

"Nice to meet you. I'm Riley. Riley James."

Jose leaned forward and said "Benj is my cousin, Riley."

I was smiling so hard my cheeks were beginning to hurt. "Cool! You look like you work out a lot, Benj. Or do you prefer Benjamin?"

"Either is fine. I don't have a preference."

"So, you work out a lot?"

"I try to. I'm a cop and work out in the weight room at the station. But, I enjoy coming here too because they've got machines they don't have down there."

Hmmmmmmmmmm. A cop. A cute, muscular cop. With what looked like a big dick.

"I hear ya. That's why I come here too. Do you bring your wife here with you?"

"I don't have a wife yet. I mean I'm engaged but I'm not married yet. But she isn't into working out, so no, she doesn't come with me."

Even better. A cute, muscular, straight cop. With a big dick. About to be married.

I nodded, took a drink from my water bottle, and looked Benjamin over more carefully. He was about 6'2" and weighed 215 pounds, which seemed to be all muscle. Besides his crotch, his shirt bulged at his arms and shoulders and I wondered if there was any part of his body that didn't have muscle.

Benjamin started looking around the gym and said, "Damn, I hope I'll be able to work out tonight. Seems all the machines are in use."

As Benjamin looked around the gym, I turned to say something to Jose about our next exercise and saw him glancing down.

"Jose, you ready to do some running?"

Jose jerked his head up and he looked at me with an incredibly guilty look. I wasn't sure but I thought for a minute that Jose was checking out Benjamin's cock.

I laughed and said, "Hey man, you okay?"

Jose grinned sheepishly and said, "Of course I'm okay. Why wouldn't I be?"

I just shrugged my shoulders and decided to test Jose to see if he really was checking out Benjamin or if I was totally off the mark.

I tapped Benjamin on the shoulder and said, "I think that Isomax on the far left wall is open."

Benjamin turned around to see what I was talking about. I turned away from Jose so he thought I wasn't watching him. Little did he know that I WAS watching him! The mirrors on the wall were just as good for observations as they were for watching you flex. As I looked in the mirror, I saw Jose turn his head and look down at Benjamin's ass. After a moment, he licked his lips and I could make out what seemed to be the beginnings of an erection in his shorts.

BINGO! Another cigar for the master!

I looked away and kept pointing out the vacant machine to Benjamin but moved towards Jose. As I got closer, I "accidentally" stumbled and tripped into Jose. He grabbed me and pushed me upright, but not before my hand brushed lightly over his crotch. Brushed over his HARD crotch that is!

Why the sly dog! Jose had a hard-on for his cousin!

Benjamin turned towards us. "Yeah, I think it is. I'm gonna book before someone else gets it. Nice meeting you, Riley."

"The pleasure was all mine, Benj." I'm sure he had no idea what pleasure he was giving me.

"Take care, mijo! When am I gonna see you again?"

Jose grinned again and said, "Soon, man. I'll call ya."

"Okay. You better!" Benjamin said and started walking away. As he walked, I watched that tight, virgin cop-ass bunch and flex in the thin shorts. I could feel the heat in my loins as the blood rushed into my cock. Oh yeahhhhhh... it wanted to get up inside that sexy, hard, muscular ass in a bad way. And maybe... just maybe... it could get up TWO muscular asses at the same time!

This was a little bit more ticklish than my other conquests. Debjeet and Mario had given their ass up because they had something to hide or were drunk. But Benjamin didn't seem to have anything to hide. Plus, he was a cop. I could see me trying to get up inside his tight little hole... and then him putting the cuffs on me. I had to find some way to get his hunky little body without getting arrested. But how?

Or maybe... who?

I looked over at Jose and saw him still watching Benjamin walk away.

It was hard for me to believe Jose was into guys the way he was always acting macho and talking about his girlfriend. But, unless my gaydar was waaaay off the wall, this studly little latino had the hots for his cousin. Given Benjamin's body, I didn't blame him but his being at least bisexual certainly put him in a new light with me. Given the fact that I like getting straight men, Jose's place on my list dropped somewhat, and I thought about whether I still wanted to try to get an ass that might or might not be virgin.

Fuck, then it hit me! This was perfect! I mean, instead of me finding a way to get Benjamin, I'd let Jose find a way! After all, it was obvious he lusted after Benjamin and he'd be just as scared to try something as I was. But... if he had someone who could HELP him get his muscular cousin... someone who was experienced in working out plans to get straight guys... someone who could assist him in getting his cock wedged deep in his cousins tight ass so he could fuck it into tomorrow... wellllllllllllllll... I'll bet he'd go for it.

I looked at Jose carefully.

"You like Benjamin, eh?"

Jose started and looked at me.

"Whadda ya mean? Of course I like him, he's my cousin."

"I know. But it seems as if you like more about him than just being your cousin."

A nervous look crossed Jose's face, followed by a flash of anger. "What the hell do you mean by that?"

"Jose man, c'mon! I saw you checking him out."

"I was NOT checking him out, dude."

"You're not?"

"NO, I'm fucking NOT!"

"Then why are you getting so hostile about it?"

Jose looked down and was quiet for a moment.

"I mean, it's fine if you are."

Jose jerked his head up angrily. "Man, I'm TELLING you..."

I quickly moved up close to Jose and put my mouth near his ear.

"And I'm telling you that if you play your cards right, you can be fucking your cousin's tight ass soon," I whispered.

Jose didn't move and I kept whispering before he had a chance to say anything.

"I'm fucking serious, so shut the hell up and listen."

Again, Jose kept still as I continued on.

"I know you want him and that's fine. And I know you're scared because he's family and a cop, and that's fine. But, what I really want to know is if you want me to show you how you can get him and fuck his brains out?"

Total silence. I looked down and could see Jose's chest rising and falling as he breathed. I reached forward and lightly touched his cock through his shorts. Why did it not surprise me to find it was hard?

I pulled away from Jose and he looked at me. His face had a mixture of fear, combined with interest and I knew I'd pegged him right. Nevertheless, I waited to hear his answer.

"So, are you gonna answer my question?" I asked.

Jose looked carefully to the right and left, to see if anyone was listening. When he looked back at me, he wore a slight smirk on his face.

"What makes you think you know how to do it?"

BINGO! YES! My humpy little latino had come through for me!

"Trust me Jose, I've done this many times."

Jose's face quickly became animated. "No shit? How many?"

I smiled confidently at him and said, "More than you can count on your hands, bud. And all straight men. Muscular, built, big-dicked, tight-assed straight men."

Jose looked at me in admiration, smiled, and said quietly "Sweeeeeeeeet!"

"However, I've never done a cop like your cousin Benjamin."

Jose's face fell for a moment and I reached around him and put my arm around his shoulder, pulling him close to me.

"But I've got a hunger for some tight cop muscle ass. And I know exactly how I'm gonna get it."

Jose grinned again, playfully punched me in the chest, and said, "Okay. So tell me... how are WE gonna get it?"

Like I said. I LOVE workouts!

Two days later, my plan to get Cousin Benjamin was in full swing.

Early that morning, I saw Jose working on my floor. He was repairing an electrical socket in the hall and I casually sauntered over to him. As I walked up, he was still bent over trying to unscrew the socket cover. His pants were pulled up tight around his ass and I could feel my cock begin to get hard.

"So, are we still on for tonight?"

Jose looked up and grinned.

"Yeah. Benj gets off his shift at 7 PM. It's Wednesday night, and he normally has a short workout before he goes over to Maria's apartment." Maria was his fiancée. "But I'm pretty sure he'll go to his apartment to shower and change clothes before he goes there. At least, that's what he usually does."

"Good. If it all falls into place, we're gonna have a helluva fuck tonight."

"Man, I'm nervous about doing him like this. Benj will haul our ass to jail quick if we get caught."

I laughed and just shook my head.

"Have some faith in me, Jose! I told you. I've done this lots of times. If you don't lose your nerve, it'll work like clockwork. BUT... you've got to do what I TELL you to do, WHEN I tell you to do it, no questions asked. If you don't, we'll both end up in the slammer. You understand?"

"Yeah."

"If we go there, your ass will end up getting fucked a helluva lot more than Benj's will tonight. On the other hand, if you play your cards right, you'll have what you've lusted after all these years."

"I know, I KNOW! God, I wanna fuck him so bad!"

I nodded at Jose and kept smiling. Little did he know that not only did I plan on fucking Benjamin, I was gonna get his spicy little latino muscle ass at the same time. Jose had told me yesterday that he'd had men want to fuck him before but that he wouldn't let them. Well, tonight he would find out that he WAS going to get fucked whether he liked it or not!

Two virgins with one plan. Could life be any sweeter?

At 6 PM, Jose met me in the parking lot next to Benjamin's apartment complex. I had scouted the complex the day before and it was a rapist's paradise! The place had about 250 apartments but only about 100 of them were occupied. The units were on 2 stories and were spread out over a large area, making it easy for someone to move around undetected. Jose told me that Benjamin was saving money for his wedding and provided security for the complex in return for free rent. Benjamin's apartment was near the back of the complex and the lighting around the units was either poor or non-existent. I guess Benjamin thought he was immune to trouble because he was a cop but this hubris would play right into my hands.

I had told Jose to dress in dark brown. Little did he know that he would stand out somewhat in the dark in the dark brown color. I, on the other hand, dressed totally in black. That way, if something went wrong, it would be easier for Benjamin to find Jose than it would me. As Jose got in my car, I noticed his jeans and t-shirt were tightly molded to his body. I smiled inwardly, thinking how much fun it was gonna be to rip them off later on.

Jose had a nervous expression on his face and kept looking around.

"Relax, Jose."

Jose looked at me. "I can't help it, man. We could go to jail for a long time for this."

"Yes, we could. Which is why you need to chill and just follow through with the plan."

"I know, I know."

"Just think about how good Benj's ass is gonna feel wrapped around that big cock of yours."

Jose got quiet, laid his head back, and closed his eyes. After a minute, I snuck a peek at his crotch. He was hard and it was obvious that he really HAD thought about his cock up Benjamin's ass. I grinned and just shook my head.

As dark started to settle in, Jose and I got out and walked over to Benjamin's apartment complex. There was nobody around as he and I walked over to the deserted laundry room. Around 7:20, I heard a car drive into the parking lot. A few minutes later, Benjamin came walking slowly into the courtyard, workout bag over his shoulder, heading towards his apartment.

I elbowed Jose, nodded towards Benjamin, and we began pulling on our ski masks and gloves. Inside the courtyard, it was like a cemetery. There was no sound, no movement, no lights. Time for the show to begin.

As Benjamin passed, Jose rushed out and tackled him around the thighs. Benjamin went down like a shot and I hopped over and got on top of his back. Benjamin had started to struggle to get free and I pulled out my knife and put it under his throat. He evidently knew what a knife felt like because he stopped moving immediately.

I leaned down and whispered quietly in his ear. "Move again motherfucker and I'll use this. You understand me?"

Slowly, very slowly, Benjamin nodded his head.

I motioned my head to Jose and he pulled the workout bag off of Benjamin's shoulder.

"Put your hands behind your back."

Benjamin didn't move. I leaned forward over him and pressed the knife harder against his throat.

"I'm not gonna tell you again, cop." I whispered louder in his ear.

I could feel Benjamin tense up and begin to move his arms. It may be that he was alarmed that I knew he was a cop. Whatever the reason, he put his hands behind his back and lay there.

Jose pulled out a tie-strap and bound his wrists together. I put my knife away, got a ski mask and pulled it over Benjamin's head facing backwards. After making sure he couldn't see and was securely bound, I stood up and looked around.

Silence. No one knew what had happened. No one cared.

I nodded again at Jose and we leaned down and pulled Benjamin up. He was curiously compliant and didn't struggle at all. I guess he was wondering where the knife was. I pulled Benjamin down and whispered in his ear again.

"You did good. You keep being good and you won't get hurt. But know one thing... if you try to run or make any sound, I'll cut you up. Understand?"

Again, Benjamin nodded slowly and stood still.

I nodded at Jose again and he pulled Benjamin forward. I walked behind them, looking around to make sure nobody saw us. When we got to Benjamin's apartment door, Jose stopped and leaned over to me and whispered.

"Where's his keys?"

I shrugged my shoulders and whispered back. "Look in his bag. I'll see if he has them in his pockets."

Jose started rummaging through Benjamin's bag and I put my hand in the right pocket of Benjamin's workout shorts, searching for the keys. As I felt around, my hand touched something full and solid in the lower part of the pocket. It was Benjamin's cock.

Fuck! If it looked as good with his clothes off as it felt with his clothes on, I was gonna have a great time!

I found the keys in the left pocket and Jose opened the door. After he went in, I pushed Benjamin inside and closed the door.

Now... time for the game... to begin!

Pulling my mask off, I felt around on the wall until my hand hit a switch. I flipped it and the lights came on. Benj was standing where I pushed him earlier and Jose was standing beside him, looking at me. I put a finger to my lips and Jose nodded his head.

I moved forward and pushed Benj farther into the room. His apartment was small but furnished well.

"Nice place, cop. You must do well for a living."

Jose looked nervous and continued to watch me. I walked over to him and whispered "Don't talk at all. He doesn't know my voice but he DOES know yours. If you talk, you're dead meat." Jose nodded.

"Stay here and watch him. I want to check things out."