For several days, they tried to go back to their normal routine: basketball in the afternoon, sometimes a jog together in the morning. Riley worked every other day as a lifeguard at the local pool, a band of sunscreen permanently marked on the bridge of his nose, while David had odd tutoring jobs mixed in with helping his neighbors mow their lawns and clip their hedges. It was going to be a long, lazy summer.
It was like a dream, what had happened two, three days ago. But the farther they got away from it, the clearer it became. Each one of them, unknowingly, was replaying the afternoon in their heads.
Finally, five days after the first incident, before they could reach the court, Riley turned around and said, "You know what, man, I can't do this anymore."
David stopped cold. For a moment, he thought Riley was announcing that because of what had happened, and because of the awkwardness between them, he had to end their friendship.
They stood there on the sidewalk, just yards away from their old high school. David could see the goalposts, the field where he had thrown countless winning touchdowns, behind the plane of Riley's shoulders.
"Do what?" David asked. His question came out more aggressively than he had meant to.
"Not talk about what happened."
To his own surprise, David felt relieved. If Riley was willing to talk about what happened, that meant that he wouldn't try to just brush off the whole thing.
David came up to Riley and looked him square in the eye, going for hopefully the right balance of assertion and, well, not seeming like he wanted to bring this up again so that he could get a blow job from a guy. "So," he said, "let's talk about it. What do you think we should do?"
"Let's just...look, let's just shoot some hoops, and then..." Riley trailed off.
Nothing but the sound of cicadas filled the air. "And then what, exactly?" David asked.
Riley was determined to hold us his end of the bargain. "You won fair and square," he said. "So I gotta do this."
"Are you sure, dude?" David blurted out. He stared at Riley, looking for signs of heatstroke. "It was really just a joke. We were both...you know...
Horny? Yeah, Riley knew. It was all he could and had been thinking about.
"Fine," David said, "I'll give you another chance. If I win this game, you suck me off, like we agreed. If you win this game, we lower the penalty."
"To what?"
"I don't know, Riley. Just lick my balls or something."
"I see you thought this through," Riley said, grinning.
"I didn't, because I don't expect to lose," David shot back. He stuck out his hand. "We have a deal?"
Riley took David's hand in his own, feeling his warm, tight grip. They met each other's gazes. "Deal."
That afternoon, Riley played more aggressively than he had since he had been on the water polo team. For about twenty minutes, he was in the lead, and it seemed that he wouldn't get to-have to-taste David's dick anymore.
David stripped off his muscle tee, and not just to give Riley a gratuitous view of his shimmering pecs and abs. Riley followed suit. With the afternoon sun beat down, and both guys were becoming drenched in sweat. Soon, they were colliding into each other, skin-to-skin, as Riley tried to maintain his lead and hit 21 points first. But David's extra height (OK, it was probably only like two inches), and perhaps a natural knack for basketball, slowly began to win out. They were tied at 21, then 22. Riley concentrated everything into making the next shot, and he was up at 23.
"Guess you won't be getting off after all," he shouted down the court.
"Don't fucking bet on it."
There was something else in David that then came forward as he barrelled down the court. He easily got past Riley and made the next shot from just inside the three-point line. Riley took possession and nearly made it down to his end before David swiped it from him and raced to the other side. The swish of the ball through the net told Riley it was over.
David picked up the basketball and tucked it under his arm. They headed back to Riley's house in silence, leaving the lengthening shadows of the hoops and goalposts behind them. When they reached the house, once again, they stopped for a drink of water. While Riley tipped the glass up to his lips, he watched David do the same, the rim of the glass rising to his lower lip, the water trickling slowly past his tongue. A drop managed to slip past the corner of his mouth and landed on his upper pec, until gravity slowly teased it down to David's dark nipple. Riley gulped.
They went deeper into the house, through the cool hallway, until they reached the closed door of Riley's room. Riley led the way, with David only a few paces behind him.
Riley sat down on the edge of his bed, and he heard the snap of David closing the door. Neither one was too sure about what to do next. They sat there for a few minutes, neither really able to read the other's thoughts. Finally, David hitched his thumbs into his waistband.
"It looks like you're having some trouble there," he said, getting off the bed.
Riley got up off the bed too and turned to face David. He wondered if he should put his shirt back on, but he suspected that David would cum quicker if he didn't, and then they'd be done with this.
Now they were stuck again, standing face-to-face, at arm's length. David, almost imperceptibly, cast his gaze downward. Riley looked down too.
"What, do you want me to get on my knees and do this?" Riley asked.
"It's either that or I lie back on your bed and enjoy watching you give me a grade-A blowjob."
With a sigh, Riley got down on his knees in front of David's muscular thighs. For the second time that week, Riley found himself on his knees in front of David. Looking down at David's bulge, and then sneaking a glance at his own, a strange but somewhat familiar palette of feelings went through his head: apprehensiveness, slight disgust, but also intense curiosity to know what it would be like. That is, what would it really be like to pull down David's shorts, open his mouth, and take David's hard member between his lips? David would stand over him, one of his large hands palming the back of Riley's head, while the other-
Riley felt, and tried to suppress, a twitch below his navel. He was doing it again. He didn't need to enjoy this. He just needed to get it over with.
"You ready?" David asked.
Riley nodded. His knees sank down and came to rest on the cool hardwood floor, inches away from David's bare feet. The outline in David's basketball shorts was nearly at eye-level. He looked up and David one more time to see that he too was nervous.
And, with a note of surprising gentleness in his voice that was almost tender, David added, "Only if you actually want to, of course. Not going to make you do anything you don't want to."
Riley acknowledged this with a nod, and when considered David's expression, looked into those deep, brown eyes, he saw lust, obviously, but also quiet tenderness and, behind that, a vulnerability. What had he been thinking, David seemed to think, getting a guy from high school, whom he had just reconnected with, to blow him? But would it be so bad, Riley thought, to do this for him?