Warning: Incest!
Characters in this story are over 18.
Read the previous chapters (Coming Home & Coming Out) for the best experience.
Sam:
I was incredibly nervous as I started getting ready to visit Eric again. I had been sitting down with daddy for nearly thirty minutes, both of us were nervous and excited for the changes to come.
It was nearly midnight when we stood up and faced each other.
"I've never done this before." I voiced my concerns to daddy.
"You don't have to do anything you don't want to." Daddy reassured me.
"I want to ... for Eric. I know it will be best for us all."
Daddy kissed me, making me feel slightly better.
"You know there's no going back from this." Daddy reminded me.
"I don't want to go back." I said. "I want to include Eric with us."
Daddy let go off me and told me to go ahead with the plan.
Eric:
Sam was standing in front of me with condoms and lube in hand. He was acting like we have been using condoms on each other for years.
"You'll need to learn proper condom use if you're going to have casual sex with other people." Sam mentioned it as if it was a part of our lesson plan.
"Of course!" I managed to say, completely melting at the sight of my near naked older brother.
He was acting cool and all; but I could tell that he was also excited for what was to come.
"You will not need it with me of course." Sam mentioned. "But it is better to make a habit out of it."
"Why wouldn't I need it with you?" I asked. "I thought you fucked hundreds of people."
"Well ... that's because I've been careful with them silly." Sam chuckled. "Besides, I get monthly check-ups."
"Monthly?"
"Depends on your activity levels." Sam explained. "If you're with only one person you trust, you don't have to get checked that frequently. But if you have been in a couple of orgies; you better get frequent check-ups."
"Frequent orgies?" I could not believe what Sam was talking about. "Where do these people meet up for that?"
"They won't be distributing flyers to invite people to orgies." Sam said. "Let's not get into that right now."
Sam handed me the lube and brought out a single condom out of the pack.
"I'll put it on and show you how it's done." Sam tore the pack. "Then I'll let you put one on later."
What I heard was that he was going to fuck me right now and I would get to fuck him sometimes later. My already hard dick started to pulsate like crazy after hearing him.
Sam just pulled his shorts down, revealing his nice and hard dick. My jaw was open with anticipation. But he immediately started putting the condom on his dick. I realized that I would not be able to put it in my mouth straight away.
This time, Sam just told me to lay down on my back; not even asking if I was ready or not. I guess my hard dick might have been an indicator of my consent.
His dick was slightly bigger and wider than the dildo he used to fuck me last night. Sam pulled my pants down and took the lube from me.
"Okay," Sam started talking as he poured the liquid over my entrance. "I think this would be the best position for your first time since I would be able to see how you react. We can try many other positions later. It's not awkward for you is it?"
I shook my head as I heard that he was planning to have sex plenty of time after tonight.
"What?" Sam wanted me to say the words.
"It's fine!"
"What's fine?"
"I think this position," I gulped. "Would be fine for me too."
Sam smiled as he lubricated his condom covered penis before lining up the dick against my entrance. I took a deep breath and closed my eyes as he started slowly poking around my anus.
He kept circling his dick around my anal opening for what might have been no more than thirty seconds. But to me, it felt like he was teasing me forever, denying me the ecstasy of his dick.
He kept gently pushing against my ass until the tip of his dick popped inside me. My immediate reaction was to open my eyes wide and look at his face. Sam had a vague smile on his face while he slowly started pushing his length inside of me.
The feeling was completely different compared to the dildo. It felt exponentially better, knowing that I was now connected with my brother.
"Remember," Sam mentioned. "You can tell me if it's uncomfortable in any way. I will stop."
I did not respond.
Stop him from fucking me? Not in a million years. Yes, there was slight pain as he kept going forward. But I knew that he was the nicest and best person to do this to me. I know exactly how rough men can get when their dicks are hard. So, to have Sam fuck me like this was a privilege. And I was going to power through any pain just to make him feel good. Besides, I knew the immense pleasure that was waiting for me when we really get started.
My own penis was in a state of confusion as I was not completely hard, but it felt like I was about to when Sam kept his slow forward movement coming in.
I groaned and slightly arched my back as I felt Sam's penis grinding against my prostate. It was a completely different experience compared to the toy he used on me last night.
I opened my eyes once I felt Sam's body touching mine. I realized that he had bottomed out inside of me. I looked up, wide eyed, to see Sam smiling down on me.
"Full?" Sam asked.
"Uh-huh!" I answered.
He stayed there for a while before telling me that he was going to pull out of me. I nodded at him, and he slowly pulled his dick out of me with only the tip inside.
"I'm going to start fucking you now." Sam let me know.
Without waiting for my response this time, Sam pushed his dick deep inside me once again. I was having trouble breathing as I clenched the bedsheets tightly. Once again, he pulled his member out of me with only the tip inside of me. Sam kept going through the same motion, slowly picking up the pace.
Just as I was about to brace myself for some fast and hard action, Sam pulled his dick out of me completely.
"What ... did you cum?" I asked Sam.
"No," Sam answered while breathing heavily. "But I was about to. You're so tight dude!"
"You're ..." I had trouble saying the words. "I was virgin moments ago."
"I know." Sam apologised. "I'm sorry for saying it like that. It's just ... I wanted to last longer, making you feel better."
"I was feeling pretty good." I explained. "You can cum whenever you feel like it."
Sam did not need to be told twice as he started penetrating me right away. He picked up the pace and spat on my dick and started jerking me off at the same time. Any uncomfortable feeling evaporated as soon as his hands touched my dick.
I could tell when he was finished when I felt his dick pulsate deep inside of me. Sam slowly pulled out of me and put his mouth on my dick. He worked on my penis for a minute before I blasted my load in his mouth.
I was riding an orgasmic high when Sam got up and started kissing me all over my face. After feeling so good together, I started feeling slightly emotional when Sam was kissing me.
Of course I did not cry. But I was having trouble formulating the words to say to him. I think Sam also understood what I was feeling as he was also silent. At the end of his assault on my face, Sam quickly kissed me on the lips four times before getting up.
He put his shorts on and started walking out of my room. That's when I found the strength to tell him how I was feeling.
"Sam?" I called him just as he was about to walk out of the door.
"Yes?" He stood still and turned to look at me.
"Can you stay with me ... for the night?" I asked him. "We could sleep together."
"Well," He showed me the used condom in his hand. "I'll need to throw it away. I'll be back after I take a quick shower, OK?"
"OK" I agreed.
I decided that I also need a shower once Sam closed the door behind him.
Sam:
I ran to Daddy's room to show him the used condom and told him what a wonderful experience I just had with Eric. He asked if it was painful for Eric or not. I told him that I did my best and Eric seemed to enjoy himself very much.
"He's so tight daddy," I added. "I could not last very long with him."
"That's pretty normal for your first time."