Moving into my dorm at the start of freshman year, I had low expectations of the guy I'd be sharing a room with. Toby had such a common last name that I couldn't find him on any social media, so I entered our living situation together completely blind.
My parents had helped me unpack and were long gone when he showed up at nearly the last minute. I'd returned from some pre-orientation social bullshit to find him at the tail end of unpacking.
"Sup," he greeted me with a casual nod of his head.
"Hey, man," I replied and shut the door. "I'm Liam."
"Toby."
I kicked my shoes off and took a few tentative steps forward.
"You, uh, need any help or...?"
"Nah, I'm pretty much done. Didn't really bring too much shit. Less to unpack, you know?"
I bobbed my head in affirmation and cast a long glance around the room. He hadn't exaggerated. The only big items he seemed to have brought were a TV, an Xbox, and a gaming chair, all of which he'd assembled around the desk pushed up against the wall on his side of the room.
"You game at all?" He asked, noticing me eyeing his setup.
"A bit, but I didn't bring my PS5 with me."
"Ah, well, I play a lot, so if you ever wanna join, I'm always up for some one on one."
"Nice, I'll definitely take you up on that."
"Yeah? You wanna get a game going right now?"
"You don't need to finish settling in?"
"Nah," he waved his hand dismissively, "like I said, I didn't bring much shit."
"Alright, well then sure," I shrugged.
"Sweet."
He set a game of FIFA up and just as I was pulling my own standard issue desk chair up, Toby turned to me, one eyebrow raised questioningly.
"You smoke weed?"
I'm not sure why his question took me by such surprise. Maybe it was how direct he was about it or the fact that we'd barely just met, but it took me a second to answer.
"Oh, uh, yeah, sure."
Truth be told, I hadn't ever smoked or drank that much before. My parents were strict and I had always been paranoid that they'd find out, but I had been looking forward to partying more in college than I had in high school.
"Excellent," he enthused before fishing a small bowl, a grinder full of weed, and a lighter out from the top draw of his nightstand.
Quickly packing and lighting the bowl, he took a big hit before passing it to me. Having never taken more than a few puffs off a blunt before, I mimicked his actions but took a much smaller hit, knowing that I'd be too stoned to function if I'd inhaled as much as he had.
I coughed out the smoke and passed the bowl back to Toby, who grinned down at me as he took it.
"We'll make a stoner out of you yet," he joked.
I attempted to smile back in between coughs, causing him to laugh.
We spent the rest of the afternoon playing video games before deciding to head down to one of the dining halls for dinner, the weed having made us ravenous.
I stood waiting as Toby pulled on a pair of white ribbed crew socks. When he got up to slip his feet into a pair of beat up slides, I glanced at the reflection of the two of us in the mirror I'd hung on the back of the door and noticed just how markedly different we looked from one another.
While both of us were around 5'10, Toby had a pretty average build whereas my physique was toned from years of competitive swimming. His dark, collar length hair hung lank and his upper lip had the telltale peach fuzz of a teenager who was not yet able to grow a full mustache but was too lazy to shave what little hair had begun sprouting, whereas my smooth, clean shaven face matched the tidiness of my short, closely cropped blonde hair.
Factor in that he was wearing a tank top and cotton shorts compared to my polo shirt and jeans, we couldn't have been more opposite.
But when Toby came up beside me, clapped me on the shoulder, and confidently proclaimed, "Look at those two studs," while grinning at our reflection, I couldn't help but grin back and embrace the cliched sitcom-esque scenario that we appeared to have been thrust into.
We headed out to dinner and upon returning, Toby again offered to smoke me out, but I politely declined, still a little high from earlier. He shrugged and packed another bowl for himself before settling down to play video games again.
I watched Netflix for a bit before going to bed early, the pull of sleep heavy after having gotten so high earlier. Toby was still locked into his game when I fell asleep and he seemed no closer to calling it quits than when he'd started earlier.
------
I pushed open the door to my dorm room and shuffled inside, chortling quietly to myself when I spotted Toby still passed out in bed. He was lying on his stomach, hair matted and mouth ajar, snoring lightly, the sheets haphazardly strewn about. Even though it was nearly noon, I wasn't at all surprised.
Our first afternoon together several weeks ago ended up being indicative of how Toby would spend most of his time; getting high and playing video games, which is exactly what he'd been up late doing last night.
Truth be told, it actually didn't bother me that much. He made sure the room didn't reek of weed and always offered to smoke me out, which I sometimes took him up on. Hell, he even said that I could help myself to his stash when he wasn't around, which he was more often than not.
Toby only seemed to attend class about half the time, something I personally couldn't imagine doing.
"I go enough to pass," he'd said with a crooked smile and a casual shrug when I'd asked him about it one day, which to be fair, wasn't hard to do. Our college was a second rate state school in Florida. The bar wasn't exactly super high.
Despite entering quietly though, the sound of the door closing still roused Toby from his slumber, and he groaned, barely lifting his head to look at me through bleary eyes.
"Damn, is it 3 already?"
He knew I usually didn't get back until mid-afternoon on Mondays.
"Nah," I told him, plopping my backpack onto the desk. "I just stopped by to grab some Bio notes before class. I'll be in and out."
"Good," Toby rolled over onto his back and began to stretch. "'Cause I really need to rub one out."
I glanced over and saw his morning wood tenting out obscenely from the front of his underwear before quickly looking away, my cheeks coloring slightly in embarrassment.
During our first couple days living together, it became pretty apparent that Toby lacked a healthy amount of modesty. Unless he had to leave our room for whatever reason, he was always lounging around in just his underwear, which meant I rarely saw him in anything other than a cheap pair of boxer briefs, something I was not at all used to.
As the only child from a relatively formal household, I didn't grow up with the type of casual behavior and attitude that someone from a more laid back family or who'd had brothers might have, which made it a bit difficult for me to adjust to Toby's lax manner of dress as well as certain habits that he was less than discreet about.
I'd gotten better about it, but I still wasn't quite used to it all, mainly because Toby was hung like a horse and completely unabashed about having his prodigious bulge casually on display all the time.
One evening during the first week of classes, we were both in our room together. Toby was playing video games while I sat hunched over my desk getting a jump on some reading for a Lit class.
"Hey, you wanna grab some food or something?" He asked me. "I'm fucking starving."
I sat up and swiveled around to answer him but came to an abrupt halt, the words dying on my lips.
Toby was slunk low in his chair with his left leg propped up on the desk, allowing his large, flaccid member to bulge prominently against the tight constraints of his underwear, which kept it pressed firmly along the length of his inner thigh.
I sat there dumbfounded until I realized that I hadn't answered him and was just gawking open mouthed at his substantial package.
I was finally able to look away, meeting Toby's gaze just as he paused the ongoing game to turn his head toward me.
"Uhh...," I stammered, scrambling to form a sentence.
"You good, bro?" Toby raised an eyebrow, but remained seated, not at all concerned about his dick jutting out the way it was.
"Yeah, sorry," I laughed, a little nervously, and shook my head. "Took me a sec to come out of my reading coma. Shakespeare, you know?"
"Fuck, I know what you mean," he rolled his eyes. "Anyway, you up for some food?"
"Yeah, I'm game."
"Bet, mind if we order something? I'm already tired of the shit that this school serves."
I made a concerted effort to maintain eye contact while we discussed dinner options, too awkward and embarrassed not to, especially when he offhandedly began readjusting himself.
I stared into my backpack as I shoved the notebook inside and readjusted the contents.
"Well," I said, pulling the zipper closed, "I guess I'll leave you to it then."
Toby chuckled lightly as I slung the back over my shoulder and headed out, not looking in his direction.
Even though I'd been exposed to plenty of locker room talk and behavior over the years, encountering it in such close proximity within my own personal living space and by someone who was a practical stranger left me a bit untethered, and the entire walk to class I was distracted by the knowledge that Toby was back in our room jerking his big cock.
------
That Friday night, I came back early from a party that turned out to be a dud to find myself alone, something which surprised me.
So far, Toby had spent every Friday and Saturday night exactly as he spent every other night, even when I had invited him out.
"Not really my thing," he'd declined after I'd asked if he wanted to tag along to a house party an acquaintance of mine had thrown the first Saturday of the semester.
I couldn't imagine that he'd somehow had a change of heart, especially after declining a similar invitation I'd extended earlier in the evening.
Since I didn't have any other plans and it was still relatively early, I had planned on asking Toby if he wouldn't mind smoking me out. But since he was gone, I debated about waiting for him to get back or just testing out his previous offer to help myself to his stash when I was alone.
After about a minute, I shrugged and opted for the latter option. Toby was a pretty chill guy, we got along great, and he seemed genuine about his offer.
I opened the top drawer of his nightstand where I knew he kept his supplies and paused. Inside, laying next to the grinder, bowl, and lighter, was a fleshlight.