Friday morning came (like Mark and I should have already) and we were excited for what potentially could happen tonight with Sam. Mark was quite confident Sam would be all for having sex with us. I was pretty confident as well, but I was still a little worried about it. Yes, Sam has been hitting on me and Mark for over a year now. But what if he's just a huge flirt and that's it? Is it possible we misread him after all this time? What if he's more into one-on-one than threesomes? And if he was into it, would we still be friends afterward? Would we be more? Will it be awkward?
I tend to overthink when I'm nervous, if you hadn't noticed. I tried to shake it off as I got ready to head to the studio. Mark was sleeping in a bit before he went out to get food and booze for tonight, so I let him be. I went into the kitchen and saw Sam grabbing some snacks to take with him to his classes. Time to lay the groundwork.
Sam greeted me. "Morning."
"Hey." I replied. "You finish your project last night?"
"Yeeeeeeesssss!" He enthusiastically answered. "So fucking glad that is done. I can finally enjoy a little quiet time before I have to dive into the rest of my work next week. I'm looking forward to it."
So far so good.
"Fuck yeah, dude." I encouraged him. "Any special plans tonight?"
"Fuck no!" He laughed at that. "I'm just going to chill here. I don't want to go anywhere or do anything. I've been needing this small break, and I'm going to milk it for all it's worth."
That's what I wanted to hear.
"Cool, dude. That's pretty much what Mark and I have planned tonight. We were just going to stay in tonight. Food and drinks. Maybe play some games. You're obviously welcome to join."
Sam smiled at my invite. "Yes, I'd love to."
I smiled back. "Great. See you later than."
"Definitely." Sam said as he put his hand on my arm. He left it there for a few seconds before leaving and heading out the door. That's more than just flirting. He had to be into us......right?
I went off to the studio to work on my tracks. After a few hours, I got a text from Mark saying he was heading to the store. Perfect. I still had a bunch of work to do, so I put my phone down and focused. The more I work, the faster I'm out of here.
It wasn't until after 2:00 I felt satisfied enough with my work to leave the studio and head home. When I finally get back to the apartment, I saw Mark was finishing putting away the groceries and drinks he got.
I knew we would be home alone, so I walk up to him and greeted him with a kiss. He kissed me back. It lingered for a few seconds before Mark spoke up.
"How was the studio?"
"It dragged." I said. "But I'm glad it's done. I was ready to be home. How was shopping?"
"Good." Mark replied. "I figured homemade pizzas tonight. And I got some vodka and sodas. That work?"
"I'll never turn down pizza and booze. I'm in."
Mark smiled as he leaned in and kissed me again. I kiss him back. I loved kissing him. I slid my tongue into his mouth, making it wrestle with his own. One of my hands wrapped around the back of his neck, bringing him in closer. My other hand moved down to his half-hard cock, rubbing it through his shorts. I figured he'd stop me and tell me to save it for later if we were successful in our seduction of Sam. Instead, Mark moaned into my mouth and moved his hand to my cock, repeating my motions. I wasn't going to waste this opportunity. I've wanted his cock for the last month. No more waiting now.
"I FUCKING KNEW IT!!!"
Mark and I jumped and turned our heads toward the screaming voice. It was Sam. He was standing there, his eyes wide with a big shit-eating grin on his face. Busted. Mark and I take our hands off each other and face Sam directly, no doubt showing off our bulges unintentionally.
"Sam! What are you doing here?!" I asked, but I was so choked up, I could barely get the words out.
"Professor's sick. Class was canceled." Sam replied, still maintaining that grin. "But how about I ask the questions. For starters, what the FUCK are you two doing?!"
Mark was still frozen in fear. He didn't move or speak. Just stood there like a statue. I guess I was the one to give the answers. He caught us red-handed. I really didn't see any point in lying.