The anal plug was buried deep within me, and as I tapped on the base of the thick, hearty plug, I once again felt a thrill as I felt he vibrations of that tapping cascading into me. With each tap, my breath caught briefly in my throat, and my manhood throbbed against the pillow beneath me. Yet part of the exhilaration of the moment was the noise coming from the surrounding dorm rooms as students returned from Spring Break – the normal, everyday, mundane sounds seemed to augment the naughtiness of the deep penetration.
For his part, Ryan was sitting on his bed, leaning back against the wall, stroking himself slowly as he watched me. He was breathing slowly, desire in his eyes as they raked over my bare flesh. He had a new box of condoms beside him on the bed, and with his free hand, he worked carefully and deliberately to open the box, never taking his eyes off me, simply feeling his way to ultimately open the box as I continued to tap upon the base of the large anal plug inside me.
In time, my roommate stopped stroking himself. He took a condom from the box, and took his eyes off me long enough to ensure that he did not inadvertently tear the condom as he opened the blue foil enclosure. I watched with great fascination as he rolled the condom onto his tall, thick, hearty erection, imagining how it would feel to have him sliding into me, his entry having been made much easier by the twenty minutes or so of having had the anal plug embedded within me.
A pair of women shrieked with excitement in the hallway, temporarily breaking the intangible connection I felt with my roommate. But then he stood beside my bed, slowly dribbling some lube upon his thinly-covered length, and as I licked me lips in anticipation, he stroked himself, directly in front of my face, spreading the lube evenly, his free hand reaching for the plug...
He tapped, much harder than I had been tapping previously, and my breath caught in my throat again. Ryan continued the tapping, a solid, steady rhythm, and my body of its own volition began to move in the same rhythm. I slid against the pillow, infusing it with my natural scent, anointing it with my natural lubrication. Instinctively, I reached for the other pillow on the bed and slid it underneath my head, my breath coming faster and harder.
The tapping eventually stopped, and Ryan grasped the base of the anal plug with his fingertips. Slowly, carefully, he began to remove the plug, but as soon as the thickest width of the plug successfully been retrieved, he pressed the plug back into me. I groaned softly despite myself, and despite what I had anticipated, my own erection seemed to harden even further.
I heard more voices – two guys – passing by our locked door. While I could not clearly hear their conversation, just their mere presence a few feet away, on the other side of two inches of wood, sent an extra shudder of I-can't-believe-I'm-actually-doing-this! along the entire length of my spine, culminating in a significant twitch against the first pillow.
Ryan toyed with me. At his whim, he would tap the base of the thick plug, or twist it inside me, or briefly withdraw part of the plug and then press it back into my body. He had me guessing, and often guessing incorrectly, what he would do with the plug next, and that perpetuated my arousal and kept my erection sliding against the pillow.
"On your hands and knees," he instructed. It took me a moment to comply, the anal plug moving deep within me as I moved into the indicated position upon the bed. Ryan mounted the bed at last, kneeling behind me, twisting the plug once again.
...and then he removed it for the final time, taking the plug completely out of my body as I groaned into the pillow beneath my head. He would clearly have seen a gaping cavity, and I felt as if I had just lost a part of me. But he quickly set the anal plug upon the towel beside us on the bed and then dribbled the lube into my gaping cavity as it began to tighten anew...