Chapter 2 - Part 1
I gulp and scramble to my knees as Nick, Caleb, and Jay approach me. Caleb uses his pointer to nudge my chin up so I'm looking in his eyes.
Caleb starts, "So, which one of us do you want to serve for your mock session?"
I blink, stunned.
"Huh?," I reply.
"Your first escapade here isn't going to be three on one. Choose one of us to play with. The other two will watch," Caleb continues.
I genuinely don't know what to say. Number one, they're all hot. Number two, I don't want them to know who I'm most attracted to right now. Number three, I don't want the ones I don't pick to be pissed.
"Tick, tock," Caleb says.
I stammer a reply, "I... I don't know."
"You're gonna have to be more steadfast in your choices if this is going to work," Caleb declares. "You already said you find us all attractive, right?"
I nod.
"Good," he continues, "then play your cards right you'll get a chance with all of us in due time. The ones you don't pick right now will not feel slighted if that's what you're thinking. But, you need to be able to articulate your desires when prompted. So, choose one of us. Who do you want to be intimate with most right now?"
I realize I'm hard in my jeans and I do want the position, so I better pick quick.
Nick is the quietest. I feel like he'd be the one I'd most want to be my boyfriend even though aesthetically Caleb and Jay are.1% more attractive. So, since I feel like I'd like Nick in the most intimate way, I decide to rule him out for this.
That leaves Caleb and Jay. Both of them are statuesque could-be male models who anyone into dudes would die to be with. Caleb seems a bit more serious where Jay seems carefree and sociable. I wouldn't put it passed him to be vocal during the session even if I'm with Caleb. I don't know if I'd be able to handle that this first time, especially since I've never been with more than one person at a time. So, I decide to choose Jay so that at least, even if he's vocal, it's not distracting since it'll be him I'm whatever-ing with.
"Ok. Jay," I say, "I choose Jay."
For a split second, I read surprise in Caleb's eyes, but he quickly conceals it.
"Ah, Jay, ok," Caleb says. "So you like our 6'5" blonde adonis, huh?"
He's clearly trying to see if I'll be embarrassed. I am, but I can't let it show if I'm about to be doing who-knows-what in front of them any minute now.