Disclaimer: While this is a first time gay encounter, there are a number of experiences with pissing/watersports. If that's not something you're interested in then no harm moving on.
***
The Rangers had just won a stressful playoff game and would be moving on to the semi-finals the following week. Seeing as how the local boys hadn't made even a short playoff run for a long time, the overall feeling in the room was one of elation, so nobody was ready for that night to end. We decided to head to the local bar to continue the celebration for a little longer.
The Graduate was an interesting location. It was a fairly old spot, pretty dark, and almost run-down looking from the outside. Contrast that with the vibe inside which was energetic and free, for lack of a better word. It was our hidden little gem that we liked to go to when the mood was right, and that was one of those nights. It also didn't hurt that it was less than a block from my house.
We thought we had hit the jackpot and were lucky enough to find a table right away but someone swooped in and got it before we got the chance to head over. Resigned to our fate we settled for plan be, which involved heading to the bar and grabbing a few drinks in hopes that it would be a short wait for someone else to vacate their table.
It was fairly crowded by the bar so we paid for our drinks and started to stroll around and take in the scene. After a short lap around the dance floor, John shared that he needed to hit the restroom.
"Cool. I'll go too."
As I turned the doorknob and pushed open the door I joked, "We might as well share the bathroom. I'm going to have to give you a hand anyway since you just had to have a big beer for each hand."
We both laughed as he strolled over to take his turn. I laughed at him as he struggled to try to unzip and free himself while still holding his beers, trying not to spill them, "Shit, I'm about to piss myself here."
I laughed but I could also tell he was actually struggling. "Alright, just hold on for a second." I walked over toward him, "We don't have all night ya know."
He shifted and turned slightly toward me, but I totally misread the room. Instead of doing the sensible thing and taking his drinks, I reached to unzip his pants and fish out his cock to point it at the toilet.
"Okay, get 'er done man."
John was a little in shock but he turned to better take aim, "Uh, okay then." It was then that I noticed him lowering the drinks back into a more comfortable position and realized he had meant to hand them to me.
As I felt the piss flow from his cock I felt like smacking myself. "Dude, I don't know what I was thinking there."
He just laughed, "No big deal man. I appreciate the help though."
To pass the awkward time I focused on what I was doing. I just stared at the flow as it poured from his cock, a cock that I just noticed was decent size, with a swollen head. I stood there staring, pretending to concentrate on the task at hand, thankful when the stream dwindled and finally stopped.
I made sure to shake him off and then adjusted my hand to slip the warm penis back in his pants. I was just starting to take hold again when a small squirt shot out, followed by another. It wasn't a lot but it was enough to get my fingers pretty wet.
"Oh shit. Sorry man. That always happens. I didn't even think to say something."
"It's alright. Not your fault. I don't know what I was thinking. I'm pretty sure that's how we all finish off." I shook him off again and then tucked him back away and zipped up.
"Okay, my turn." He moved and then I stepped up to the toilet, making sure to unzip and pull myself out with my one dry hand. I didn't want to be getting John's pee on my clothes.
As you would expect, my turn was uneventful. The problem came when I had shaken off and needed to get all situated back in my pants. I needed a hand to manage my pants so I could hold them open and put my package away with the other. The choices were to either hold my pants with my wet hand or hold my penis with that same wet hand.
Absent-mindedly, I shook it a little as if to help dry it off and then brought it to my mouth. I moved my hand to my mouth, quickly licking off my fingers, as if I were cleaning them of bbq sauce or something. It wasn't until I had finished that I realized what I had just done. I tore them from my mouth in shock and then reached down to situate myself, after wiping what I hoped was just a little saliva onto my pant leg.
My only hope was that John hadn't seen what I had done. As I was preparing to tuck myself back into my pants I glanced over and, although I had my suspicions that he saw, I couldn't say for sure because his eyes were focused below my waist. The idea of him gazing at my bare cock was causing me to stir so I quickly stuffed myself back into my pants so we could go.
I was standing there at the sink, washing my hands, with that odd taste in my mouth, having just held the cock of a guy that I hadn't even known for very long, and then had him staring at mine a few moments later. My thoughts were racing but I did my best to keep it cool. "Alright. Let's go see if the guys have managed to swipe a table yet."
We were out of luck, so we found the guys near the bar on the edge of the makeshift dance floor. John and I joined the small group and we all just chatted, sipped on our drinks, and people watched.
Nobody wanted to complain about just standing around, but eventually John was the first one to cave, "Dude, I'm so annoyed that we couldn't get a spot tonight. My legs are killing me."
"Same, man. I'd be alright heading out and parking it on the couch in front of the tv. Anyone else?"
John and I had been pretty casual in our people watching, but it was clear the other guys were on the prowl. I was pretty sure they weren't going to want to head out yet. My suspicions were confirmed when they just kind of mumbled and shook their heads.
"Alright, we'll see you guys later."
That too was just met with a nod of the head. We put our empty glasses at the end of the bar and weaved our way to the door and out to start the short walk home. John and I jumped around from topic to topic, not superficial but not really getting too deep into most subjects either.
You can learn a good amount about people without really in-depth conversations if you pay attention. From our meandering conversation the one thing I could tell was that John would be a good addition to the group if he started hanging out more often. We were still talking away when we got back to my place and made our way to plop down on the couch and watch the tv, but not before I filled up a couple of glasses of water, hoping to make for a more enjoyable morning.
I turned the channel on to some random movie, but we just kept talking and didn't really pay it much attention. We continued working our way through more conversation topics but it seemed like each one was lasting a bit longer as we explored them a little deeper. Clearly we were getting more comfortable.
At one point there was a short pause and John jumped in before we picked up again, "Hold up man. Let's take a quick break. I really gotta pee."
"Cool. You know where it is."
"I do. Back in a sec," and he got up to start to cross the room.
I think I must have been losing my mind when I spoke up, "Hold up. Let me give you a hand again. I'm a little embarrassed about my aim last time."
He just shrugged and casually replied, "if you insist." But I could have sworn I got a glimpse of a little smirk as he was turning to go.
"Can't have you walking around telling people I'm all careless in the bathroom ya know."
I followed him into the bathroom, still a little surprised at what I was doing, but what did it really matter. He got over to the toilet and got his pants unbuttoned and unzipped but I stopped him there and took over, "I got this. You just relax."
We both chuckled a little but he did settle a little more. I reached in and pulled his penis from his underwear for the second time of the night and, if we're counting, my second time ever touching another penis in my life. I took aim with my left hand. At that point we were standing almost side by side when I gave him the green light, "fire away."
Just before he started I thought I noticed something. I couldn't say for sure but it sure seemed like he was a little bigger than earlier. He seemed to be filling my hand a little more than at the bar. I didn't have long to think about it though because once more a warm stream shot out. I knew it was coming but it still startled me anyway.