After my second time with Mark, I didn't experience any soreness. What I noticed the most is that everything we did felt very natural, and I was looking to keep exploring and experiencing new things.
I didn't feel any different about myself. However, the openly gay guy at work, who I previously only had exchanged pleasantries, suddenly started talking to me more, asking about my weekend plans, if I was dating anyone, etc. Maybe gaydar is a real thing, I thought to myself.
I chatted with Mark on a regular basis, but he was traveling so we weren't able to meet for awhile. Then one day he messaged me that he was having a small "get together ", and asked if I would be interested. I had to think about it, because although I was entirely comfortable being with one guy, I wasn't sure about a group setting. But Mark assured me it would be low key and discreet, and so I finally agreed.
On the day of the gathering I did my usual prep, and made the drive over to Mark's place. When I arrived, there were 3 guests that arrived before me. A couple, Sam and Emily, and Adam. Sam and Emily were in their early 30's. Sam was about 6' tall, and I would guess around 200 pounds. Sam was good looking, but Emily was a knockout. About 5'-6" tall with long brunette hair, and a perfect hourglass figure. She had on a sleek black dress that hugged her figure. I could see that she wasn't wearing a bra, and saw just a thin outline of her thong. I must have been staring at her, because Sam said " Whoa, slow down guy, in due time". The other guy was Adam, who was about 5'-8", and on the thin side. He was almost naked, just wearing some leather straps and a leather collar. Mark introduced everyone, and explained that Adam would be providing the entertainment for the evening. We all had some drinks and traded small talk. After about half and hour, the final guest, George arrived. He was older, mayber mid-50's, and on the heavy side. Mark explained that Adam was George's plaything, and would do whatever George told him to do.
Mark instructed everyone to strip down, so we all took off our clothes. Emily pulled her dress over her head and her body looked even better than I thought it would. I was disappointed that she kept on her thong, but the view was still amazing. I thought to myself that I still am attracted to women, and I was wondering what Sam meant when he said "in due time" earlier.
There was a little planning of what was going to happen. Since I was the new guy, Mark said to have a seat on the couch. I was already hard from staring at Emily, so George told Adam to suck my cock. Without a word, Adam got on his knees and grabbed my cock with both hands. His touch was soft, and he started flicking his tongue over the tip, then slowly licked down one side and up the other. He did this for a minute of so, then put the head in his mouth and started sucking on just the head. George said "get on with it", so Adam looked me in the eyes, and slowly slid all the way down the shaft, never breaking eye contact.
It was incredibly erotic. He continued looking at me and kept my cock down his throat for about 5 seconds, then slowly slid up and down all the way to the base, never breaking eye contact. I was mesmerized at his ability to swallow the whole length without gagging. George said, "OK, that's enough", and just like that, Adam withdrew. I felt Aa little disappointed, but then I looked around and everyone was smiling at me. Mark said not to worry, there will be more. Then it was Marks turn with Adam. As we all watched Adam continued the expert deep throating, and Sam whispered in my ear "I saw how you looked at Emily. If she likes you, maybe you will have a chance to play with us." I didn't know if he was serious or joking.
Adam continued to suck Mark until George once again told him to stop, and Sam took a seat. As Adam was going down on Sam, Emily stood next to me and said, "I wish I could do that, I always gag." Then she explained that they were both bi, and had been swinging for a few years. They had a couple that they played with for some time, but they moved away, and that they currently only had this small group that meet occasionally. She said Sam likes to be deep-throated, and she lets him come to these gatherings to get them. But they usually play together with another man or woman, and that she has final say as to who they play with. Then she turned her attention back to the action and said " You go honey, give it to him!", and soon after Sam tensed up and started cumming. Adam continued deep throating him until he swallowed every drop. I was a little disappointed that I didn't get to cum. Mark saw the look on my face and said, "Don't worry, there's more to come". I asked him what that meant, but he just smirked and walked away.