Previously in Chapter 08:
Were we going to fuck soon? Was he going to fuck me tonight? Maybe the plug was intended to help ensure I was super stretched by the time we got home. That made sense.
My mind was racing with possibilities. I finally snapped out of it when the waitress returned with the credit card and Michael scrawled a tip amount onto the receipt.
"Let's blow this joint," he said.
"Yeah, give me a second though," I said. I began a careful process of extricating myself from the bench without causing my plug to jostle around too much. Then we were walking out of the restaurant, leftovers in hand, and sliding into his car.
----------
Once we got home, I put the potato in the fridge and went to pee. Once I exited the bathroom, I saw Michael in the process of disrobing in his bedroom. His shirt was off and he was removing his belt too.
"Like what you see?" he asked playfully.
"Maybe," I said in what I hoped was a seductive whisper.
"Good to know. How about you get naked and go wait in your bed?"
"For what?" I asked as excitement raced through me.
"Guess you'll see."
I hopped over to my bedroom and quickly removed all of my clothes. I tried to figure out what position on the bed would turn Michael the most to find me in. I thought about getting on my hands and knees with my plug pointing towards the foot of the bed would be the hottest, but it was also a bit too bold I thought.
I ended up settling on lying on my stomach in a prone position. A few minutes later, Michael entered the room and jumped onto the bed. I twisted my head around and saw that he was naked and was pulling a condom onto his cock. Fuck yeah!
"A condom huh?" I asked slowly "Are we going to fuck?"
"Hell yeah. As long as you're okay with it. I just kind of assumed you would be."
"I've had this plug in me for almost two hours and you made me drench my boxer briefs with precum the entire time we were seated. I need it really bad," I grunted. I shook my ass back and forth at him.
"That's what I like to hear. Let's see how good anal feels for both of us," said Michael in a lustful tone of voice as he slowly lubed up his dick. He crawled onto the bed behind me and slowly eased the toy out and put it on a tissue on the floor. "Bet you're nice and stretched out now. This is a great view but I want you to roll over."
I flipped onto my back and stared at him hungrily.
"L-like this?" I asked, suddenly feeling like the nervous virgin I was.
"Yeah. I figure for our first time we should at least be able to see each other. I want to see your facial expressions while I fuck your brains out."
He slid closer to me and spread my knees wide for himself and lifted them up off the bed.
"I'm going in. Tap me or say something if you need me to stop or slow down or whatever. I know this is your first time getting fucked by a real dick."
"Okay. Be gentle at first," I said.
"Yeah."
He carefully lined himself up and managed to get the tip in after a few attempts. I grabbed the pillow above my head and groaned at the feeling. It felt better than the dildo or plug with all of its fleshy goodness.
"Good?" he asked.
"Yeah. You can probably start fucking me since I'm so warmed up already."
"Okay. Here it goes."
I whimpered in pleasure as he pushed himself all the way inside of me. He wasn't as fat as the plug but he was nice and long like my dildos.
"All nice and filled up like you should be," he grunted in a deep, breathy voice that made me squeeze subconsciously around him. He grabbed my ankles and raised them to his shoulders and leaned over me, pushing my knees towards my chest. "Get ready."
He began fucking me then: long, slow strokes in and out. He quickly increased his speed while watching my face as if to make sure he wasn't going too hard or fast. Before long, we were fornicating at passionate pace.
I was sure my reactions were entertaining for him to watch. I was making faces and opening and closing my eyes as I grunted and moaned and whimpered and gasped.
"You're so tight," grunted Michael. "Going to fuck the cum out of you just like that dildo of yours. Make you my little bitch."
"Ohhhh fuck yessss! I'm your bitch Michael!" I moaned with an embarrassingly unmanly voice. Michael leaned over me further until my knees were touching my chest and his body was pinning me tightly to the bed.
He planted a kiss onto my lips and I kissed back hungrily. He shoved his tongue into my mouth, exerting dominance, and I let my own tongue dance with his for a few seconds before he straightened back up and diverted his full attention to fucking me silly again.
I lost track of time as we went at it. I was filled with a complex assortment of feelings. Lust. Amazement that this was even happening. Romantic feelings. Attachment. Unimaginable pleasure. And a strong desire for this sex to last forever.