I was blindfolded and completely naked. My cock was rock hard in anticipation.
My girlfriend said she had a surprise, she was going to fulfill one of my deepest sexual fantasies.
The door-bell rang.
"Here comes your surprise," April teased as she went to answer the door.
My heart was beating so loud now, I swear I could hear it through my chest!
As she returned to the bedroom, I heard a voice behind her. A male voice!
"What the hell April," I yelled, as I started to get off the bed.
"Shut-up, Michael. You aren't fooling anyone with this routine. We can both see your cock twitching with excitement."
I was embarrassed to admit, but April was right. It was a show and I was secretly excited.
I remained where I was - still blindfolded. Still, rock hard.
Heavy footsteps approached the bed.
"Turn on your stomach," the accompanying voice said. As I turned, I realized that I recognized the voice! I racked my brain, but could not place it. My chest felt as though it was engulfed in fire. I was terrified that someone in my life was witnessing this. He must have sensed my fear, "don't worry, your secret is safe with us," the voice reassured me.
Was it someone who worked with me? A guy from the gym? I was still wondering who it could be when I felt the bed dip.
"Just relax," said that familiar voice.
Then I felt his hands on my bare ass - his strong, muscular hands. I was tense with fear and anticipation. In a moment I heard him spit and immediately felt the wetness on my ass. He used his saliva as lube, and I felt his finger enter. I didn't even realize I was holding my breath until he told me to breathe. I let out a deep sigh.
With my exhale, his finger went in deeper. I felt violated, uncomfortable, humiliated, and turned-on. I was the hardest I've ever been in my life. His finger gently started to prod in and out of my ass. A slow rhythm to gradually open me up. A second finger slid in.
"Oh, fuck," I said. I was not prepared for this second finger.
"Just relax," he uttered again. "I don't want you coming too soon," he warned.
He continued fingering my ass. His two fingers went in about three inches, angled downwards, towards my belly button. He reached my prostrate and started to massage it. Fuck, that felt amazing!
"A bit more pressure," I murmured blissfully. The mystery guy did as asked. I felt a rush of ecstasy each time his fingers ran over my prostrate.
After a few moments, I felt him get up. I turned to look back, but then remembered I was blindfolded. I wasn't sure what was going on until I heard the unmistakable sound on a belt unbuckling.
"April, I'm not sure I'm ready for this." She approached the bed and sat next to me.
"Honey," she said gently, "we both know you've been craving cock, but have been too embarrassed to admit it. There's no need to be ashamed of what you desire."
At that moment, I knew I was going to lose my anal virginity.
"He's ready," I heard her say to the mystery man.
