πŸ“š meet-the-new-neighbor Part 2 of 2
meet-the-new-neighbor-2
GAY SEX STORIES

Meet the New Neighbor

Meet the New Neighbor

by Whiteboiwife
20 min read
3.37 (5600 views)
gaygay manoralstraightstraight superiority
Loading audio...

The sun was warm on Josh's shoulders as he knelt in the flower bed, his fingers sinking into the cool earth. The scent of freshly turned soil mixed with the floral notes of the petunias he was planting, was a sure sign that spring had arrived in full force. He wiped his brow, leaving a smudge of dirt behind, and sat back on his heels, admiring his work.

Their front yard was finally coming to life after months of dreary winter grays. A light breeze took the new heat of midday off his body and blew the rainbow flag that swung just beside the mailbox at their front door. Tulips, daffodils, and hyacinths dotted the garden bed, vibrant bursts of color against the deep green foliage. Josh had spent the better part of the morning arranging everything just right, and though his knees ached from kneeling, there was nothing quite as satisfying as watching a garden bloom under his care.

The front door creaked open behind him, and he turned to see Cody stepping onto the porch, a tall glass of lemonade in each hand. The sunlight caught the dark strands of Cody's hair, making the contrast against his pale complexion even sharper. Josh smiled as his husband made his way down the steps and across the lawn, his height giving him an effortless grace.

"I figured you could use a break," Cody said, handing him a glass.

Josh accepted it gratefully, taking a long sip. The tartness of the lemonade was a perfect refreshment against the afternoon sun. "You're a lifesaver," he murmured, licking a stray drop from his lips.

Cody smirked and lowered himself onto the grass beside Josh. "I know," he teased. His brown eyes flicked over the garden. "It's looking really good. You've got quite the green thumb."

Josh chuckled, setting his glass down beside him. "Well, one of us has to keep things alive around here. We both remember what happened when you tried to take care of that basil plant."

Cody groaned. "That was years ago. Are you ever going to let me live that down?"

"Absolutely not."

Cody laughed, nudging Josh's knee with his own. "Fair enough." He took a sip of his own lemonade before glancing up toward the street. "Hey, did you notice the moving truck?"

Josh followed his gaze just in time to see a large white truck pulling into the driveway of the house across the street. It came to a stop, and within moments, a pair of movers hopped out, heading toward the back to unload furniture.

"Huh," Josh mused. "Looks like we're getting a new neighbor."

Cody nodded, watching with mild curiosity as the movers began hauling a couch down the ramp. "Wonder who they are."

Josh wiped his hands on his jeans and took another sip of his drink. "Guess we'll find out soon enough." He glanced at Cody. "What do you say we go introduce ourselves later this week? Give them a chance to settle in first."

Cody smiled. "Sounds like a plan. We can bake something--maybe a pie?"

Josh arched a brow. "You mean I can bake something. And are we really that suburban now?"

Cody laughed, raising his hands in mock surrender. "Okay, okay, you got me. I'll provide moral support."

Josh shook his head, grinning. "Deal." He glanced back at the moving truck, watching as a figure stepped out of the front seat--a lone person, seemingly directing the movers with a nod. "Ohhh and he's attractive."

Cody leaned back on his hands, thoughtful. "That may just be one of the movers."

~~~~~~~~

The sun hung low in the sky as Josh and Cody crossed the street, a freshly baked blueberry pie in Josh's hands. The golden crust peeked through the pie dish, the smell of warm berries and sugar lingering in the air. It had been about a week since the neighbor had moved in and the moving truck had disappeared. Cody walked beside him, stealing glances at the house in front of them. The moving truck had been replaced by a stunning Mercedes-Benz in the driveway.

Josh glanced at Cody. "You sure about this? Is it doing too much?"

Cody smirked. "It's just a pie, not a marriage proposal."

Josh chuckled. "Fair point."

As they reached the porch, Cody knocked on the door. A moment later, heavy footsteps sounded from within, and the door swung open, revealing the man they had seen days prior off and on.

Mark was tall, maybe an inch taller than Cody, with firm muscles that strained against his sweat-dampened T-shirt. His brown hair was tousled, a few strands sticking to his forehead, and his hazel eyes flicked between them with mild curiosity. He was certainly an attractive man!

"Hey," Mark said, wiping his hands on his jeans. "Can I help you?"

Josh smiled, lifting the pie slightly. "Hi! We're your neighbors from across the street. I'm Josh, and this is my husband, Cody. We just wanted to welcome you to the neighborhood."

Mark's expression shifted at the word "husband." His relaxed stance stiffened, and his gaze cooled. His jaw tensed, his hazel eyes darkening with something unreadable. For a long moment, he didn't say anything, and the air between them grew heavy.

Cody, ever the optimist, stepped in. "We made you a blueberry pie. Thought you might like a break from unpacking. We were nervous it might be a little Desperate Housewivesy but..." His voice trailed off.

Mark's eyes flicked down to the pie, then back to them. "That's... considerate of you," he said slowly. But there was no warmth in his tone. He hesitated before reaching for the dish, his fingers barely brushing against Josh's as he took it. "Thanks."

Josh tried to ignore the tension but felt his stomach twist. He'd seen that look before--discomfort, disapproval. He exchanged a glance with Cody, who kept his polite smile intact.

"So, where are you moving from?" Cody asked, keeping the conversation light.

"Texas," Mark replied shortly. He leaned against the doorframe, pie in hand. "Got a job up here with the new firm, PNT."

"Them opening a branch here was all over the news," Cody replied.

Josh nodded. "Well, this is a great neighborhood. Pretty welcoming community."

Mark's lips pressed into a thin line. "Yeah. Sure." His eyes flicked between them again, as if reassessing. "So... you two are married?"

Josh's grip tightened slightly at his side, but he kept his expression neutral. "Yep. Seven years now."

Mark exhaled sharply through his nose, shaking his head slightly as if in disbelief. "That is some time."

Cody arched a brow. "Something wrong?"

πŸ“– Related Gay Sex Stories Magazines

Explore premium magazines in this category

View All β†’

Mark shrugged, looking away. "Just... not what I expected, I guess." His tone was clipped, dismissive. "Didn't think I'd be moving across the street from--" He stopped himself, then forced a tight smile. "I guess I should have assumed based on the flag."

Josh felt the heat rise in his chest. He knew exactly what Mark wasn't saying, and Cody did too.

"Well," Cody said, his voice a touch sharper now, "surprise."

Mark gave a short chuckle, but there was no humor in it. He shifted the pie in his hands. "Look, uh... thanks for this. I should get back to unpacking."

Josh's jaw tightened, but he nodded. "Sure. Welcome to the neighborhood." Before the words could leave his lips Mark had already shut the door.

As they turned back toward their house, Josh let out a breath he hadn't realized he'd been holding. Cody shook his head, his easygoing nature dimmed by frustration.

"Wow," Cody muttered. "That went well."

Josh sighed. "Yeah. Guess we know where we stand with him."

Cody huffed. "He'll either come around or stay miserable."

Josh glanced back at the house. "Guess time will tell."

With that, they crossed the street, the warm evening air feeling a little cooler than before. As the pair hit the other side of the road Josh could tell Cody was taking the situation hard than him.

"Don't be discouraged, babe." He said wrapping his arm around his partner's, "What do you say we have a little fun... when we get inside."

"Please don't tell me that man's sweater-toned body got you worked up." Cody rolled his eyes and Josh laughed.

"He was fine, and you know it! But no. Absolutely not." Letting go of Cody's hand he reached for the door handle of their home and opened it to his husband. Looking back at the blue and white single-story home across the street he caught a brief glimpse of someone quickly shutting the curtains.

~~~~~~

Cody sat on the couch, arms crossed, staring blankly at the television. Josh made his way into the room carrying a cheesy romance novel, he couldn't help but notice his partner's firm form barely concealed under his tight green polo that rose up just the slightest bit to reveal his tight midriff as he curled up beside him. Unfortunately, he also couldn't help but notice the way Cody's brow furrowed in thought.

"Alright," Josh said, nudging him lightly. "Spill it."

Cody sighed, running a hand through his hair. "I just can't stop thinking about it. Mark's reaction. The way he looked at us like we were some kind of problem. I hate that."

Josh exhaled, setting his book aside. They hadn't spoken about the insistent since it had happened the day prior. "Yeah, I noticed. It's frustrating, but unfortunately, it's not the first time we've dealt with someone like that. That goes for the entire community. It was a risk we took moving to the suburbs."

Cody shook his head. "I know, but it sucks. I don't want to just write him off as some lost cause. People don't change if they're never given the chance to."

Josh studied him for a moment before nodding. "I suppose...?"

Cody hesitated, then straightened. "What if we invite him to dinner? Give him a chance to see we're just... people. Normal. Maybe break through whatever wall he's built up! I've decided to make Mark my new project!"

"You really don't have to do that," Hosh interjected with lines from their favorite musical turned recent movie.

"I know, that's what makes me so nice!" Cody played.

Josh arched a brow. "You think one dinner is going to magically change his mind?"

"No," Cody admitted. "But it's a start. At the very least, he'll get to see that we're not what he's made us out to be in his head."

Josh considered it, then gave a small smile. "Alright. If you are crazy enough to do it. I'll be crazy enough to support it I guess." He leaned in and gave his husband a peck on the cheek.

Immediately, Cody's mind began to race with ideas. Maybe something classic and comforting--like a roast chicken with garlic mashed potatoes. Or maybe steak, since Mark seemed like the type who'd appreciate a hearty meal. For dessert, something simple but irresistible--maybe a rich chocolate cake or a berry cobbler. Something that showed effort but wasn't over-the-top. Cody let out a sigh.

Even if it all failed at least they could appreciate the eye candy. As a tech guy who spent most of his day in the office, the men couldn't understand how he maintained such a perfect physique. If Mark wouldn't come around and he was just a neighbor across the street at least he was good to look at.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~

That Friday evening after they had all made it back from their various jobs, Mark had hesitantly stepped into their home, his eyes scanning the space with cautious curiosity. The dinner was warm and inviting, filled with casual conversation and laughter, yet an underlying tension remained. It was as if Mark was looking for any excuse to continue his doubt of the pair.

After dinner, Mark followed Cody and Josh into the living room, looking mildly surprised at himself for staying this long. He sat on the couch, glancing around at the cozy, well-decorated space, the warmth of the room contrasting with the unease still lingering in his expression. His eyes seemed to scan the room.

Josh smiled as he handed Mark a drink. "We honestly weren't sure you'd come."

Mark took a sip and scoffed. "Yeah, well, I figured I should at least be polite. And a free meal is a free meal. I hear you guys can cook. They weren't wrong. I'll give you that."

Cody rolled his eyes when only Josh could see. At least the stereotype was a good one. He leaned forward, resting his elbows on his knees. As he did, he got a whiff of Mark's cologne. It was a musky, woody fragrance with a soft hint of spice. He had to admit it was enticing. "We appreciate that, Mark."

The conversation started light--work, hobbies, sports. Mark mentioned his job at PNT. It was truly boring but the couple kept up their end of the conversation in the hope of building a better interaction. Cody and Josh shared stories of their favorite spots in town, recommended local restaurants, and tried to keep things easy.

But Cody, never one to let tension fester unspoken, eventually steered the conversation toward the issue at hand. "Mark, can I ask something?" Josh felt his blood run cold. This was when his partner was about to lose him.

Mark tensed slightly, his jaw tightening. "What?"

Cody met his gaze. "What is it about us that bothers you?"

Mark exhaled sharply, rolling his shoulders. "It's not personal. It's just... how I was raised."

πŸ”“

Unlock Premium Content

Join thousands of readers enjoying unlimited access to our complete collection.

Get Premium Access

πŸ›οΈ Featured Products

Premium apparel and accessories

Shop All β†’

Josh crossed his arms, his voice calm but firm. "People unlearn things all the time. I just hope we can be good neighbors and build a community."

Mark let out a dry laugh. "Don't y'all have a community already? Those pride thing-a-ma-jigs."

He wasn't wrong. The pair did help out at the local community center that planned the local suburban Pride night in June, an offshoot of the local city branch.

"And you think one dinner is gonna change my whole worldview?" Mark continued and shook his head. "Come on, man. That's not how it works. I just don't believe this shit is real."

Cody felt a fire beginning to burn inside himself. "What shit? Two people in love? Two people having a life together? This is just as real as any straight relationship." He waved his left hand in the air flashing the golden band around his ring finger.

"Cody..." Mark gave his partner a firm stare from his seat across the table.

"Is it?" Mark scoffed leaning back in his seat and spreading his legs. "How long have the pair of you been together, again?"

"Seven years," Josh said, studying him. He could not read this man. For the briefest moment his eyes landed on the rather large bulge in Mark's crouch before he turned his attention back to Cody and their defense, "We met in college."

"On one of those apps?" Mark asked with a slight chuckle.

"Yes," Cody interjected. It wasn't all that surprising that they had met on an app. It was becoming just as common with straight couples as gay ones.

"Were you looking to find a life partner or just looking to hook up with someone?" The straight man questioned. The pair paused for a moment unsure of how to answer.

"Well..." Cody paused trying to find his words. This wasn't exactly what he expected for after-dinner conversation but clearing the air and helping to give Mark a better understanding of their life together was, "No, I wasn't exactly looking to get married to the next guy I saw but I met Josh and..."

"How many men had you hooked up with prior to that?" Mark's expression hardened as he tightened his grip tightened around his glass

"Why... why is that relevant?" Cody's face turned a bright red. He wasn't ashamed of his past. Gay men were known for their promiscuous behavior, but he never had to answer for it to a straight man sitting in his living room.

"How many?" Mark repeated, "It's a simple question."

"32." Cody answered. "...that month."

"Damn." The straight guest chuckled before turning to Josh who sat to his right, "And you?"

"Well..." Josh looked at his partner. He wanted to someone voice to him that he wasn't sure how to make this end, "I had the app downloaded longer... it was like two guys a week for about a year. Nothing drastic."

Mark threw a few fingers in the air as he began to do the math. Josh continued to eye Cody looking for some sort of solution to their house guest situation.

"That's... about 106!" Mark said narrowing his eyes.

"Why is that important?"

"What I'm saying is you guys don't give a damn about love or relationships or any of this nonsense..." Mark said waving his arms through the air to the home around them, "Ya'll playhouse but you just want to hook up with the next new thing! There is a reason why so many see you as sexual deviants."

"Mark that is out of line and untrue!" Josh didn't expect his own voice to come out so loudly, but he was glad it had. This dinner party was drawing to a close, "We had our troubles our first year, but I have been faithful to Cody this entire time!"

"As have I." Cody let out a breath, nodding slowly. He knew his chance of persuading Mark to see them as a normal, happy, healthy couple was fading fast. At least for this evening.

Josh moved to his feet. "We're not asking you to become some LGBT activist overnight. But maybe just... think about it." He pushed with his words trying to help his husband keep his goal of teaching this man he was in the wrong, "Challenge what you've always believed instead of accepting it as fact."

"So, it's a fact you queers don't want this shit?" Mark smiled.

"Mark, that's enough!" Cody jumped in. He was not about to sit and listen to the man's slurs.

Now Josh knew the evening was over. He began to move to the door to direct the man out of their home, but he wasn't taking the hint.

Mark leaned forward to place his glass on the coffee table next to the large Tom Ford and Chanel books, his expression darkening. "You really think this is some great love story, huh? You two? Married? Seven years, and you act like that means something?" He laughed bitterly. "You know I could end this joke of a marriage in a heartbeat?"

Josh stiffened, but Cody kept his gaze level. "And how would you do that, Mark, huh?"

Mark smirked. "I could get you two to break off this shit show by simply offering you both to lick the sweat from my nuts!"

The pair were stunned to silence. Minutes seemed to pass before Josh finally gestured to the front door. "I think it's time for you to leave, Mark."

The straight tech man stayed seated staring at Cody a few feet away. The pair seemed to watch each other trying to gauge the other's next move. Slowly Mark's hand moved from the side of the couch down to the bulge in his jeans. Giving the rather large lump a squeeze, a smirk moved over his face.

"How about it, faggot. Give me those rings and I'll give you a sniff." The man spoke and a firm, almost alluring tone. Cody watched the man expressionless.

"Mark." Josh said, his own voice growing in frustration, "It is time to leave."

Mark ignored the man giving orders. "How's about it, Cody... You wanna lick the sweat off my superior balls?"

Josh looked at his husband still sitting there silently like none of this was happening. Was he in shock? He said Cody's name almost softly, but he didn't respond.

"Come on Cody," Mark said, a smug smile on his face. "You know you want it. You're just like every other gay boy, desperate for a real man. A straight man. Don't think we don't know what's going through your fag brains."

Cody sat in silence his eyes fixated on this hateful man, his thoughts tangled in conflict. His blue eyes, usually so full of warmth, now shimmered with something deeper--an aching sorrow and longing, yet beneath that mourning, there was something else, something raw and unspoken, a quiet hunger. Finally, Cody looked at his husband standing in the small entry of their home they built together starting 7 years ago with a look of unforgivable pity.

"Please..." The word seemed to slip desperately from Cody's lips, "Please let me lick the sweat from your balls."

Josh stood there stunned. He was unsure he had heard what his husband had said. But as he watched Mark laugh hysterically and begin to unzip his pants, he knew he had heard him correctly.

Hooking his fingers into the waistband of his jeans. With one slow, deliberate motion, Mark shoved them down, the heavy denim and cotton briefs pooled over the edge of the couch. The air in the room seemed to thicken, the silence stretching into something unbearable. Cody could feel his pulse in his throat, in his fingertips, in the desperate clench of his jaw.

Enjoyed this story?

Rate it and discover more like it

You Might Also Like